Show Food Recommendations
You are viewing Cafe 58 prices confirmed by PriceListo at the following location:
169 58th Street, Brooklyn, NY 11220 US 1(718) 492-4300
Order Online
Prices shown in: USD
Beta Price change data displayed below is the difference between the previous and the last record in our database. The two records could be derived from different sources, and as such, should only be used as estimates.
Item Price Change

Breakfast

2 Eggs Any Style
With potatoes and toast.
$4.95 - -
Huevos Rancheros
Two sunny side up eggs on corn tortillas topped with red or green salsa, avocado and queso fresco.
$5.95 - -
Steak and Eggs
Served with home potatoes and toast or fries.
$6.95 - -
Huevos A La Mexicana
With chorizo, onions, jalapenos and tomatoes. Served with rice, beans, tortillas and coffee.
$3.95 - -

Omelettes

Omelette
With your choice of any two ingredients. Served with coffee and potatoes or fruit.
$6.49 - -

Breakfast Sandwiches

Grilled Cheese On Toast
Served on toast.
$2.00 - -
Bacon, Egg and Cheese
Served on a hero or a roll.
$3.95 - -
Sausage, Egg and Cheese $3.95 - -
Hamwich
Toasted croissant with ham and Swiss cheese.
$3.95 - -
Eggs On A Roll $2.00 - -
Ham, Egg and Cheese $3.95 - -
Western Sandwich
Served on a hero or a roll with ham, eggs, onions and peppers.
$3.95 - -

Pancakes

Pancakes with Syrup and Butter
Three pancakes, served with coffee or tea.
$3.95 - -
Pancakes with Strawberries $5.49 - -
Pancakes with Chocolate Syrup $4.95 - -
Pancakes with Eggs and Bacon
Three pancakes with eggs, any style, served with coffee or tea.
$6.25 - -
Pancakes with Eggs and Sausage $6.25 - -
Pancakes with Bananas $5.49 - -
Pancakes with Chocolate Chips $4.95 - -
Pancakes with Eggs $5.25 - -
Pancakes with Eggs and Ham $6.25 - -

Student Specials

Student Special Breakfast
Includes breakfast sandwich and drink.
$2.99 - -
Student Special Lunch
Includes sandwich, fries and a drink.
$4.99 - -

Appetizers

French Fries $2.49 - -
Chicken Fingers
6 pieces.
$5.49 - -
Fried Calamari $5.95 - -
Fresh Mozzarella
With tomatoes.
$5.95 - -
Empanada $2.00 - -
Tostones $2.00 - -
Fruit and Cheeses $4.95 - -
Buffalo Chicken Wings
7 pieces.
$5.49 - -
Mozzarella Sticks $5.25 - -
Fresh Broccoli
With garlic roasted peppers.
$5.95 - -
Fried Shrimp
15 pieces.
$3.75 - -
Salchi Papas $3.49 - -
Maduros $2.00 - -
House Salad
Greens.
$3.95 - -

Crispy Salads

Caesar Salad
Parmesan cheese and croutons.
$5.95 - -
Vegetable Salad
Chopped vegetables and Italian herbs.
$5.95 - -
Mozzarella Salad
Peppers, sun-dried tomatoes, olive oil and black pepper.
$6.49 - -
Chicken Salad
Fresh oranges, greens, dressing and tomato.
$6.95 - -
COB Salad
Chicken, bacon, tomatoes, cucumbers and cheddar cheese.
$7.50 - -
Tuna Salad
Tomatoes, peppers and red onions.
$5.95 - -

Hot Sandwiches

Tuna Melt
Tomatoes and your choice of cheese on your choice of bread. Served with fries or salad.
$7.50 - -
Chicken Breast
Lettuce, tomatoes, peppers and mayonnaise on your choice of bread. Served with fries or salad.
$6.49 - -
Grilled BBQ Chicken Hot Sandwich
Tomatoes, jalapeno jack cheese, fries and a pickle.
$6.49 - -
Chicken Parmigiana Hot Sandwich
Marinara sauce and melted mozzarella cheese on your choice of bread. Served with fries or salad.
$6.49 - -
Monterrey Melt
Smoked Turkey, peppers, onions and jalapeno jack cheese on your choice of bread. Served with fries or salad.
$6.49 - -
Grilled Veggies Hot Sandwich
Carrots, zucchini, broccoli, onions and asparagus on your choice of bread. Served with fries or salad.
$6.49 - -
Philly Cheesesteak
Swiss cheese, onions and peppers on your choice of bread. Served with fries or salad.
$6.49 - -

Sandwiches

Sliced Breast Of Chicken Sandwich
With roasted peppers, tomatoes and low-fat mayonnaise. Served with mixed greens.
$5.49 - -
Grilled Pesto Sandwich
With tomatoes and melted mozzarella on wheat baguette. Served with mixed greens.
$5.95 - -
Ham & Melted Cheese
Served with mixed greens.
$5.95 - -
Fresh Mozzarella Sandwich
With tomatoes and pesto spread on wheat baguette. Served with mixed greens.
$5.95 - -
Monterey Melt
With smoked Turkey, roasted peppers and melted jalapeno jack cheese. Served with mixed greens.
$5.49 - -
Steak Sandwich
Flat top meat with grilled onions, served with French fries.
$7.50 - -

Burgers

Pizza Burger
8 oz. Marinara sauce and melted cheese.
$3.95 - -
Mex Burger
8 oz. Jalapeno jack cheese, avocado and onions.
$4.49 - -
Turkey Burger
8 oz.
$3.49 - -
Chicken Burger $2.95 - -
Deluxe Cheeseburger
8 oz. With lettuce, tomato, onions, pickles and fries or onion rings.
$6.49 - -
Deluxe Mushroom and Swiss Burger
With lettuce, tomato, onions, pickles and fries or onion rings.
$5.95 - -
Deluxe Veggie Burger $5.75 - -
Cheeseburger $3.49 - -
Mushroom and Swiss Burger $3.95 - -
Veggie Burger $3.25 - -
Deluxe Pizza Burger
8 oz. Marinara sauce and melted cheese with lettuce, tomato, onions, pickles and fries or onion rings.
$5.95 - -
Deluxe Mex Burger
8 oz. Jalapeno jack cheese, avocado and onions with lettuce, tomato, onions, pickles and fries or onion rings.
$6.95 - -
Deluxe Turkey Burger $5.75 - -
Deluxe Chicken Burger $5.49 - -

Triple Deckers

Smoked Ham Triple Decker
With American cheese, lettuce, tomato and mayonnaise. Served with your choice of side and a pickle.
$6.49 - -
Steak Triple Decker $6.49 - -
Breast Of Chicken Triple Decker $6.49 - -
Sliced Turkey Triple Decker $6.49 - -
Virginia Ham Sandwich
Mustard, greens and Swiss on rye with fries.
$6.49 - -
Fresh Mozzarella Sandwich (Triple Deckers)
With pesto, greens and sun-dried tomatoes on wheat bread.
$6.49 - -
BLT Triple Decker $6.49 - -
Chicken Milanese Triple Decker $6.49 - -
Fried Tilapia Triple Decker $6.49 - -
Turkey Czar Sandwich
Greens and tomato on white bread. Served with fries.
$6.49 - -
Goat Cheese Sandwich
Greens and sun-dried tomatoes on wheat bread.
$6.49 - -

Wraps

The Gobble Wrap
Smoked Turkey, onions, tomato, Swiss cheese and Caesar dressing. Served with fries and a pickle.
$6.49 - -
Fresh Garden Wrap
Pesto, mixed vegetables and mozzarella cheese. Served with fries and a pickle.
$6.49 - -
Wild Tiger Wrap
Shrimp, guacamole, lime, peppers and red onions. Served with fries and a pickle.
$6.49 - -
La Fajita Wrap
Steak or chicken with peppers, onions, avocado and jalapeno jack cheese. Served with fries and a pickle.
$6.49 - -
Chicken Czar Wrap
Romaine, red onions and tomatoes. Served with fries and a pickle.
$6.49 - -

Nachos, Quesadillas & Tostadas

Crispy Tortillas Nachos
With beans, sour cream, jalapenos, guacamole and cheese.
$4.99 - -
Steak Quesadilla
With your choice of flour or corn tortillas.
$5.49 - -
Pollo and Chiptole Sause Quesadilla $5.49 - -
Shrimp Quesadilla $5.49 - -
Vegetable Quesadilla $5.49 - -
Tostada
Crispy tortilla with beans, sour cream, lettuce, cheese and red or green salsa.
$1.75 - -
Chicharron Quesadilla $5.49 - -
Chicken Quesadilla $5.49 - -
3 Queso Quesadilla $5.49 - -
Chorizo Quesadilla $5.49 - -
Mushroom Quesadilla $5.49 - -

Tortas & Cemitas

Chicken Torta
On a soft white Portuguese roll with beans, mayonnaise, lettuce, tomatoes, cheese, avocado and jalapenos.
$5.49 - -
Steak Torta $5.49 - -
Pork Milanese Torta $5.49 - -
Cecina Torta $5.95 - -
Lengua Torta $5.95 - -
Carne Enchilada Torta $5.49 - -
Chicken Milanese Torta $5.49 - -
Steak Milanese Torta $5.49 - -
Torta Cubana
Ham, carnitas, Swiss cheese, honey mustard and pickles.
$5.95 - -
Chicken Cemita
With beans, mayonnaise, papalo, onions, cheese, avocado and chipotle on sesame seed bread.
$5.95 - -
Steak Cemita $5.95 - -
Pork Milanese Cemita $5.95 - -
Cecina Cemita $5.95 - -
Lengua Cemita $5.95 - -
Carne Enchilada Cemita $5.95 - -
Chicken Milanese Cemita $5.95 - -
Steak Milanese Cemita $5.95 - -

Burritos and Chilaquiles

Steak Burrito
Steak, rice, refried beans, sour cream, guacamole and cheese. Served with fries or salad.
$6.95 - -
Shrimp Burrito
Shrimp, rice, refried beans, sour cream, guacamole and cheese. Served with fries or salad.
$6.95 - -
Vegetable Burrito
Vegetables, rice, refried beans, sour cream, guacamole and cheese. Served with fries or salad.
$6.95 - -
Chicken Burrito
Chicken, rice, refried beans, sour cream, guacamole and cheese. Served with fries or salad.
$6.95 - -
3 Queso Burrito
Jalapeno jack cheese, hebra and cheddar cheese, rice, refried beans, sour cream, guacamole and cheese. Served with fries or salad.
$6.95 - -

Fresh Fruits and Juice

Apple $1.00 - -
Fruit Salad $2.49 - -
Strawberries $2.95 - -
Cantaloupe $2.49 - -
Apple Juice $2.49 - -
Celery Juice $2.49 - -
Banana $1.00 - -
Orange Juice $3.75 - -
Honey Dew $2.49 - -
Grape Fruit $1.50 - -
Carrot Juice $2.49 - -
Smoothie
Made with yogurt, orange juice, milk and honey.
$2.49 - -

Pastries

Toast $1.00 - -
Bagel w/ Cream Cheese $1.49 - -
Croissant $1.50 - -
Muffin $1.25 - -
Bagel with Butter $1.00 - -
Bagel w/ Lox & Cream Cheese $4.95 - -
Fresh Mexican Bread $1.25 - -

Sides

Side Of Bacon $2.49 - -
Side Of Sausage $2.49 - -
Side Of Traditional Rice $2.49 - -
Side Of Mixed Garden Vegetables $2.49 - -
Side Of Spicy Mexican Guacamole $2.49 - -
Side Of Red Salsa $2.49 - -
Side Of Chipotle Salsa $2.49 - -
Side Of Ham $2.49 - -
Side Of Mashed Potato $2.49 - -
Side Of Seasoned Beans $2.49 - -
Side Of Avocado $2.49 - -
Side Of Tortilla Chips $2.49 - -
Side Of Green Salsa $2.49 - -
Side Of Corn Tortillas $1.89 - -

Dessert

Rice Pudding $1.49 - -
Flourless Chocolate Cake $2.95 - -
Tiramisu $2.95 - -
Vanilla Ice Cream $2.75 - -
Strawberry Ice Cream $2.75 - -
Pound Cake
Ice cream, fudge, whipped cream and cocoa.
$3.95 - -
Hot Fudge Sundae
Chocolate syrup, whipped cream, nuts and a cherry.
$3.95 - -
Flan
Caramel custard.
$2.00 - -
Cheesecake $2.95 - -
Apple Pie $2.95 - -
Chocolate Ice Cream $2.75 - -
Banana Split
Triple ice cream, fudge and whipped cream.
$3.95 - -
Brownie $3.95 - -
Milkshake $3.95 - -

Beverages

Coffee $1.49 - -
Decaffeinated Sanka $1.49 - -
Latte $3.75 - -
Americano $2.75 - -
Nestle Chocolate $1.75 - -
20 oz Soda $1.49 - -
Jarritos Soda $2.25 - -
Sunny D $0.75 - -
Apple and Eve $0.75 - -
Honest Tea $2.00 - -
Coconut H20 $2.00 - -
Red Bull $2.00 - -
Monster $2.00 - -
Arizona Energy $2.00 - -
Tea $1.49 - -
Espresso $2.75 - -
Cappuccino $3.75 - -
Abuelita Choco $1.75 - -
Canned Soda $1.00 - -
2 Liter Soda $2.25 - -
Jumex Nectar $2.00 - -
Capri Sun $0.75 - -
Welches $0.75 - -
Nesquick $2.00 - -
Black Mamba $2.00 - -
Rockstar $2.00 - -
Disclaimer: PriceListo gathers actual pricing information from sources such as on-site visits, business websites, and phone interviews. The prices reported on this webpage derive from one or more of those sources. Naturally, the prices reported on this website may not be current, and may not apply to all locations of a given business brand. To obtain current pricing, contact the individual business location of interest to you.
Back to Top