Show Food Recommendations
These are some of the top rated items our users enjoy. Rate your favorite items on PriceListo to get personalized recommendations.

Extraordinary Cupcakes Menu Prices

Verified Prices
PriceListo is not associated with Extraordinary Cupcakes
You are viewing Extraordinary Cupcakes prices confirmed by PriceListo at the following location:
1220 Richmond Road, Williamsburg, VA 23185 US 1(757) 645-2122
Order Online
Prices shown in: USD
Beta Price change data displayed below is the difference between the previous and the last record in our database. The two records could be derived from different sources, and as such, should only be used as estimates.
Item Price Change


The Extraordinary
Moist chocolate cake filled with fluffy cream - topped with chocolate icing.
$4.00 - -
Uncommon Carrot
Super moist cake with carrots, pineapple, walnuts and Vietnamese cinnamon and a cream cheese icing.
$3.50 - -
Uncommon Carrot (Everyday) $3.50 - -
Wicked Chocolate
Rich chocolate cake topped with deep, rich chocolate icing.
$3.50 - -
Fantastic Vanilla Flip
Our vanilla cake - with rich chocolate icing.
$3.50 - -
Fantastic Vanilla Flip (Everyday) $3.50 - -
Remarkable Red Velvet
Super-moist and tender red cake with cream cheese icing.
$3.50 - -
Marvelous Madagascar
Our best seller! Super rich vanilla bean pound cake with nielsen-massey vanilla buttercream.
$3.50 - -
Fantastic Chocolate Flip
Our wicked chocolate cake - with nielsen-massey vanilla buttercream.
$3.50 - -
Red Velvet Whoopie Pie
All the moist goodness of red velvet and cream cheese filling - in a "sandwich"!
$5.00 +$0.25 +5.26%

Monday Wednesday Friday

Bodacious Boston Creme
Nielsen-massey vanilla cake filled with vanilla custard then topped with chocolate icing.
$4.00 - -
Sinfully Salted Caramel
Nielsen-massey vanilla cake filled with caramel then topped with caramel frosting and a dash of French sea salt.
$4.00 - -

Tuesday Thursday

Curious Coconut
Light coconut cake with coconut pastry cream - topped with toasted coconut icing.
$4.00 - -
Curious Coconut (Tuesday Thursday) $4.00 - -
Inconceivable Coffee
Chocolate cake (made with illy coffee) with espresso buttercream and a pinch of espresso sugar.
$3.50 - -

Saturday Sunday

Phenomenal Peanut Butter
Wicked chocolate cake, creamy peanut butter filling, peanut butter buttercream icing.
$4.00 - -


Only available for a limited time.
Luscious Lemon Raspberry
Lemon cake, filled with raspberry compound, topped with a raspberry buttercream icing.
$4.00 - -

Monthly Flavor

Only available during the current month.
Tremendous Tres Leches
Our "3 milk" cupcake. Vanilla cake, soaked in a 3-milk mixture, and topped with a fluffy 7 minute icing.
$4.00 - -
Disclaimer: PriceListo gathers actual pricing information from sources such as on-site visits, business websites, and phone interviews. The prices reported on this webpage derive from one or more of those sources. Naturally, the prices reported on this website may not be current, and may not apply to all locations of a given business brand. To obtain current pricing, contact the individual business location of interest to you.