Navigation
Show Food Recommendations
These are some of the top rated items our users enjoy. Rate your favorite items on PriceListo to get personalized recommendations.

Underhill Cafe & Grill Menu Prices

Verified Prices
PriceListo is not associated with Underhill Cafe & Grill
You are viewing Underhill Cafe & Grill prices confirmed by PriceListo at the following location:
760 Dean Street, Brooklyn, NY 11238 US 1(718) 484-3744
Order Online
Prices shown in: USD
Beta Price change data displayed below is the difference between the previous and the last record in our database. The two records could be derived from different sources, and as such, should only be used as estimates.
Item Price Change

Appetizers

Avgolemono soup Large
Chicken lemon orzo soup With pita.
$8.00 - -
Soup of The Day
With pita.
$5.00 - -
Sesame & Honey feta
A store fave ! Fried feta cheese, honey, sesame seeds served with house pita
$13.00 - -
Sesame & Honey feta (Appetizers) $13.00 - -
Sesame & Honey Saganaki
Fried Kefalograviera cheese, honey, sesame seeds.
$13.00 - -
Spanakopita (homemade <3
House-made spinach, leek and Feta pie, evoo.
$10.00 - -
Grilled Octopus (Appetizers)
Lemon vinaigrette, red onions, dill, parsley.
$21.00 - -
Spanakopita $9.00 - -
Zucchini Croquettes
Blend of Feta, dill, mint, served with tzatziki dip.
$13.00 - -
Zucchini Croquettes (Appetizers) $13.00 +$1.00 +8.33%
Lamb Keftedes
Greek meatballs, tomato sauce, Manouri cheese. served with pita
$15.00 +$2.00 +15.38%
Falafel
Served with hummus.
$9.00 - -
Grilled Halloumi
Olive tapenade, tomato, toasted pita.
$13.00 - -
Fried Calamari
Served with sweet red harissa dip.
$17.00 +$1.00 +6.25%

Popular Items

Lamb Burger
Graviera cheese, bacon onion jam, garlic aioli, dill pickles.
$17.00 - -
Grilled Octopus $21.00 - -

ΜΕΖΈΔΕΣ

Served with pita.
Tirokafteri dip (spicy feta cheese) 8 oz
served with pita
$10.00 - -
Tzatziki
yogurt ,dill dip. served with pita bread
$6.00 - -
Melizana (Eggplant) 8 oz $10.00 - -
Hummus
served with pita bread
$5.00 - -
Hummus dip (8 oz) $10.00 - -
Melizana (Eggplant) $5.00 - -
Tzatziki dip (8 oz) $10.00 - -
Tirokafteri (Spicy Feta Cheese) $6.00 - -
Any Three Spreads (4 oz each) $15.00 - -
Any Three Spreads $15.00 - -
All Four Spreads (4oz each)
Tzatziki (vegetarian), hummus (vegan), melizana (eggplant) (vegan), tirokafteri (spicy Feta cheese) (vegetarian) served with pita bread
$18.00 - -
All Four Spreads $18.00 - -

Salads

PRASINI "NEW" & AWESOME
Romaine lettuce , dill, scallions, cucumber, feta cheese , evoo, lemon dill dressing
$13.00 - -
Greek Salad
Vine tomatoes, cucumbers, kalamata olives, peppers, onions, Feta, oregano.
$14.00 - -
Greek Salad (Salads) $14.00 +$2.00 +16.67%
Dakos Cretan Salad
Barley rusk, chopped tomatoes, onions, capers, Feta, herbs.
$14.00 - -
Dakos Cretan Salad (Salads) $14.00 +$1.00 +7.69%
Ceaser Salad
toasted bread crumbs, romaine lettuce, caesar dressing.
$13.00 +$1.00 +8.33%

Mains

Moussaka
layered oven casserole dish made with eggplant, potatoes, zucchini, ground  meat sauce, topped off with a creamy béchamel sauce.
$18.00 +$1.00 +5.88%
Shrimp Saganaki
Seared shrimp with fresh tomato sauce, Feta, onions, dry white wine, oregano, served with pita.
$25.00 - -
Pastichio w/ lemon potatoes
Basically a Greek Lasagna. A baked dish , Layers of meat sauce with noodles topped with a cheesy bechamel. Served with lemon potatoes.
$18.00 - -
Grilled Salmon
sauteed zucchini, evoo, and cinnamon buttered mashed sweet potato
$25.00 - -
Ribeye
sauteed onions and mushrooms, served with seasoned steak fries
$35.00 - -
Spanakopita Plate
House-made spinach, leek and Feta pie, served with house salad.
$16.00 - -
Grilled Chicken (Mains)
ladolemono sauce (Lemon & oil sauce) , lemon potatoes, brussels sprouts.
$16.00 - -
Grilled Chicken
ladolemono sauce (Lemon & oil sauce) ,served with side of lemon potatoes and Arakas (Greek style peas)
$17.00 - -

Platters

With small salad and fries
LAMB GYRO PLATTER
seasoned lamb strips , served with toasted pita, tzatziki sauce, tomato onions, side house salad & fries
$15.50 -$1.50 -8.82%
LAMB GYRO PLATTER (Platters)
seasoned lamb strips , served with toasted pita, tzatziki sauce, tomato onions, choice of house salad or fries
$16.00 - -
HALLOUMI CHEESSE PLATTER
traditional Cypriot imported cheese, grilled until golden brown served with Tzatiki, tomato, cucumbers, onions, toasted pita bread With small house salad and fries
$17.00 - -
Chicken Souvlakia Platter (Platters)
Marinated skewers, tomato, onions, tzatziki, house-made pita with small sides of fries and house salad
$15.75 -$1.25 -7.35%
Chicken Souvlakia Platter $15.75 - -
Pork Souvlakia Platter (Platters) $15.00 -$2.00 -11.76%
mediterranean chicken bifteki platter
seasoned ground chicken patty with scallions, herbs , served with toasted pita, tzatziki sauce, tomato onions, choice of house salad or fries
$17.00 - -
Falafel Platter (Platters)
Served with hummus, tomatoes, cucumbers, toasted pita. With small house salad and fries
$16.00 - -
Pork Souvlakia Platter $15.00 - -
Shrimp Skewers
Two marinated skewers served on the side with tzatiki, toasted pita bread, tomatoes, onions. WIth small house salad and fries
$21.00 - -
Falafel Platter $16.00 - -

Burgers

Served with hand cut french fries or house salad.
Beef Burger
Cheddar cheese, caramelized onions, dill pickles, garlic aioli.
$16.00 - -
Beef Burger (Burgers) $16.00 - -
American Burger
Cheddar cheese, lettuce, tomato, red onions, underhill special sauce , pickles
$16.00 +$1.00 +6.67%
Lamb Burger (Burgers) $17.00 - -
Underhills Favorite Lamb Burger $17.00 - -
Underhills Favorite Lamb Burger (Burgers) $17.00 - -

Souvlaki in a Pita

Personal pita sandwich with fries inside, tomato, red onion, cucumber.
Grilled Shrimp Pita $13.00 - -

Sides

Arakas (Greek style peas
tomato sauce , onions carrots peas, feta
$10.00 - -
Patates Tiganites
French fries.
$7.00 - -
Crispy Brussel Sprouts (Sides)
Harissa, pickled red onions, pistachio.
$13.00 - -
Crispy Brussel Sprouts $13.00 - -
Patates Fournou (lemon potatoes)
Roasted lemon potatoes.
$8.00 - -
Marinated Beets
subtle spicy greek yogurt, evvoo, oregano, feta cheese, pea shoots
$12.00 - -
Patates Fournou $8.00 - -
French Fries with Greek cheese $10.00 - -

Sodas

seltzer $3.00 - -
gingerale $3.00 - -
sprite $3.00 - -
orange soda $3.00 - -
diet coke $3.00 - -
coke $3.00 - -

DESSERT

5 Baklava bites
Baklava is a rich, sweet dessert pastry made of layers of filo filled with chopped nuts and sweetened and held together with syrup or honey
$10.00 -$5.00 -33.33%

BRUNCH

Lamb gyro Pita
Personal Pita sandwich with fries inside, tomato, red onion, cucumber
$10.00 - -
Pork Souvlaki Pita $10.00 - -
Chicken Souvlaki Pita $10.00 - -
Grilled Halloumi Pita
Vegetarian. Personal Pita sandwich with fries inside, tomato, red onion, cucumber
$11.00 - -
Falafel Pita
Vegan. Personal Pita sandwich with fries inside, tomato, red onion, cucumber
$10.00 - -
Keftedes Pita $11.00 - -
Disclaimer: PriceListo gathers actual pricing information from sources such as on-site visits, business websites, and phone interviews. The prices reported on this webpage derive from one or more of those sources. Naturally, the prices reported on this website may not be current, and may not apply to all locations of a given business brand. To obtain current pricing, contact the individual business location of interest to you.