Navigation

Bennigan's Menu Prices (3955 W New Haven Ave, Melbourne)

Verified Prices
PriceListo is not associated with Bennigan's
You are viewing prices confirmed by PriceListo at the following Bennigan's location:
3955 W New Haven Ave, Melbourne, FL 32904 US (321) 802-9693
Beta Price change data displayed below is the difference between the previous and the last record in our database. The two records could be derived from different sources, and as such, should only be used as estimates.
Item Price Change % Change

Top Menu Items

Mix and Match Choose 3 $14.00 - -
World Famous Monte Cristo Sandwich $12.00 - -
Kilkenny's Country Chicken Salad
Crispy or grilled chicken with garden greens, bacon, Colby cheese, eggs and tomatoes. Served with smoky honey Dijon dressing.
$12.00 - -

Salads and Soups

Steakhouse Salad
Baby greens tossed with balsamic vinaigrette, tomatoes, grilled onions, crispy mushrooms, house-made croutons and blue cheese crumbles. Served with 4 oz. of sliced and marinated flat iron steak.
$12.00 - -
Baby Spinach and Bacon Salad
Fresh baby spinach, sun-dried tomatoes, golden raisins, onions, eggs, pecan pieces, bacon and blue cheese crumbles tossed in our own sweet pepper vinaigrette.
$9.00 - -
Apple Pecan Salad
Garden greens, spicy glazed pecans, Granny Smith apples, Craisins and blue cheese crumbles tossed in maple vinaigrette dressing. Drizzled with a balsamic glaze.
$9.00 - -
Kilkenny's Country Chicken Salad (Salads and Soups)
Crispy or grilled chicken with garden greens, bacon, Colby cheese, eggs and tomatoes. Served with smoky honey Dijon dressing.
$12.00 - -
Loaded Cobb Salad
Fresh mixed greens and romaine lettuce, loaded with marinated chicken, Applewood smoked bacon, blue cheese crumbles, Colby cheese, avocado, tomatoes, eggs and cucumbers. Served with choice of dressing.
$12.00 - -
Ultimate Buffalo Chicken Salad
A fresh combination of tender greens, carrots, celery, pico de gallo and blue cheese crumbles. Served with ranch dressing. Topped with crispy or grilled buffalo-seasoned chicken breast.
$12.00 - -
Soup
Choice of hand-crafted French onion or ultimate baked potato.
$4.00 - -
Soup and Salad Combo
Garden or Caesar salad and a bowl of hand-crafted soup.
$8.00 - -

Crowd Pleasers

Bennigan's Premium Buffalo Wings
8 crispy fried wings, Buffalo sauce, chunky blue cheese dressing and crisp celery sticks.
$12.00 - -
Irish Tower O'rings
Our house-made colossal onion rings, deep-fried to perfection. Served with a side of chipotle ranch and Cholula sauce.
$9.00 - -
Hogan's Egg Rolls
Tender wraps filled with chicken, sweet corn, black beans and fresh herbs. Served with a house-made pineapple sweet-pepper cream sauce.
$8.00 - -
Flip's Super Loaded Nachos
Crispy corn tortilla chips loaded with grilled flat iron steak, made-from-scratch beef and bean dip, fresh chili con queso, melted Colby cheese, pico de gallo, cilantro and jalapeno peppers. Topped with shredded lettuce and guacamole, then drizzled with lime and sour cream.
$16.00 - -
Reuben Fritters
Handmade with diced corned beef, sauerkraut, cream cheese and Swiss cheese, dipped in buttermilk and breaded in panko breadcrumbs. Dusted with parsley and served with a side of Thousand Island dressing.
$9.00 - -
Dubliner Quesadillas
Garlic-marinated chicken with Colby and Monterey Jack cheese, flavorful spices and crispy fried onions folded in a flour tortilla. Served with salsa, pico de gallo and guacamole. Drizzled with a lime and sour cream sauce.
$9.00 - -
Boneless Buffalo Wings
Our signature, hand-breaded bites with choice of traditional or tossed in Buffalo sauce. Served with your choice of ranch or blue cheese dressing.
$9.00 - -
Mix and Match Choose 2 $11.00 - -
Mix and Match Choose 3 (Crowd Pleasers) $14.00 - -
Original Recipe Broccoli Bites
Delicious blend of broccoli, cheese and bacon, lightly breaded and dusted with Parmesan, garlic and herbs. Served with a smoky honey Dijon dressing.
$8.00 - -
Mangia Mozzarella
Mozzarella sticks gently fried to golden perfection. Served with our zesty homemade marinara sauce.
$8.00 - -
Cheeseburger Pub Bites
3 hand-crafted cheeseburgers served on top of shredded lettuce on brioche buns. Served with crispy haystack onion rings.
$8.00 - -
Flip's Crispy Fried Buffalo Chips
Golden fried potato chips, seasoned and tossed in Buffalo hot sauce. Topped with Colby cheese, blue cheese, fresh chopped tomatoes, green onions and drizzled with our house-made ranch dressing.
$10.00 - -
Cheesy Potato Skins
Thick cut potato skins filled with Colby cheese, bacon and green onions. Served with sour cream.
$8.00 - -
Sheela's Sriracha Shrimp
12 sweet shrimp hand-dipped in our secret batter recipe and fried until golden brown. Tossed in our spicy dynamite dressing and served with extra dressing for dipping.
$10.00 - -

Celebrated Sandwiches

World Famous Monte Cristo Sandwich (Celebrated Sandwiches)
Honey-wheat bread layered with tender ham, roasted turkey, Swiss and American cheese. Batter-dipped, gently fried and coated with powdered sugar. Served with red raspberry preserves for dipping. Served with home-style french fries seasoned with sea salt.
$12.00 - -
The Original Irish Dip Sandwich
Succulent roast beef with a layer of caramelized onions on a toasted garlic roll. Served with Bennigan's au jus and sour cream horseradish sauce. Served with home-style french fries seasoned with sea salt.
$12.00 - -
Turkey O'toole Sandwich
Freshly sliced turkey breast, melted Swiss cheese and smoky honey Dijon dressing. Served on a pretzel bun. Served with homestyle french fries seasoned with sea salt.
$11.00 - -
Cajun Chicken O'Toole Sandwich
Blackened grilled chicken breast, Applewood smoked bacon, melted Swiss cheese and smoky honey Dijon dressing. Served on a pretzel bun with home-style french fries seasoned with sea salt.
$11.00 - -
Kilkenny's Country Chicken Wrap
Chicken tenders, lettuce, tomatoes, Colby cheese and bacon, wrapped in a flour tortilla with smoky honey Dijon dressing. Served with home-style french fries seasoned with sea salt.
$10.00 - -
The Classic Reuben
Sliced corned beef, sauerkraut, Swiss cheese and Thousand Island dressing. Served on rye bread with homestyle french fries seasoned with sea salt.
$11.00 - -
Bennigan's Club
Honey-wheat bread, toasted and seasoned with freshly made basil mayonnaise. Layered with tender ham, roasted turkey, bacon, Applewood smoked bacon, tomato, shredded lettuce, Swiss and cheddar cheese. Served with home-style french fries seasoned with sea salt.
$11.00 - -
Lina's Crispy Chicken Sandwich
A tender chicken breast, hand-breaded and gently fried to golden perfection. Topped with pepper jack cheese, drizzled with spicy Sriracha aioli and finished with kicked-up coleslaw. Tossed in Lina's secret sweet and spice sauce. Served with home-style french fries seasoned with sea salt.
$12.00 - -
1/2 Bennigan's Club with Salad
Served with choice of salad.
$9.00 - -
1/2 Bennigan's Club with Soup
Served with choice of crock size soup.
$9.00 - -
World Famous Monte Cristo Sandwich with Salad
Served with choice of salad.
$9.00 - -
1/2 World Famous Monte Cristo Sandwich with Soup
Served with choice of crock size soup.
$9.00 - -

Legendary Favorites

Danny Boy Chicken
2 grilled and garlic-marinated chicken breasts. Served with roasted garlic mashed potatoes and broccoli saute.
$12.00 - -
Char-grilled Flat Iron Steak
Asian-marinated, tender flat iron steak grilled to perfection and served with rice pilaf and broccoli saute.
$15.00 - -
Baby Back Ribs
Slow smoked and tender baby back ribs. Brushed with zesty BBQ sauce and finished on the grill. Served with home-style french fries and kicked-up coleslaw.
$18.00 - -
Cajun Chicken and Shrimp Pasta
Cajun grilled chicken and shrimp, fettuccine pasta, smoked vegetables and a Cajun cream sauce. Served with toasted garlic bread.
$13.00 - -
Our Signature Chicken Tenders
Hand-breaded and served with our home-style french fries, kicked-up coleslaw and smoky honey Dijon dressing.
$12.00 - -
Passion Fruit Glazed Pork Chop
Bone-in, thick cut pork chop, seasoned and grilled to perfection. Brushed with our chef inspired passion fruit glaze. Served with roasted garlic mashed potatoes and broccoli saute.
$15.00 - -
Finn's Beer-battered Fish and Chips
Tender white fish fillets, hand-crafted in delicious beer batter. Lightly fried to crispy and golden brown. Served with home-style french fries, kicked-up coleslaw and jalapeno tartar sauce.
$12.00 - -
Grilled Salmon Fillet
Simply grilled or Cajun seasoned. Served with herb rice pilaf and broccoli saute.
$15.00 - -
The Irishman Whiskey Glazed Chicken
2 chicken quarters, grilled to perfection, basted and glazed with our house-made Irish whiskey glaze. Served with roasted garlic mashed potatoes and maple roasted Brussels sprouts.
$15.00 - -

The Prime Burgers

The B.O.M.B Burger
Slathered with bourbon-infused bacon jam over melted American cheese, then topped with crispy fried haystack onions. Served with lettuce, tomato, onion, pickle and french fries seasoned with sea salt.
$14.00 - -
Guinness Glazed Bacon Burger
Guinness stout glaze, Applewood smoked bacon, cheddar cheese and crispy fried onions. Served with lettuce, tomato, onion, pickle and french fries seasoned with sea salt.
$14.00 - -
St. Brigid Burger
Layered with our house-made pub cheese, Applewood smoked bacon, grilled onions and mushrooms on a toasted brioche bun. Served with lettuce, tomato, onion, pickle and french fries seasoned with sea salt.
$14.00 - -
The Big Irish Burger
2 mouth-watering 1/2 lb. beef burgers piled high, double-decker style with double the toppings. Served with lettuce, tomato, onion, pickle and french fries seasoned with sea salt.
$16.00 - -
The Irishman Whiskey Glazed Burger
Brushed with our house-made Irish whiskey glaze and layered with ale sauteed onions, cheddar cheese and Applewood smoked bacon on a toasted brioche bun. Brushed with our velvety, made-from-scratch Irish whiskey cream sauce. Served with lettuce, tomato, onion, pickle and french fries seasoned with sea salt.
$14.00 - -
BBQ Bacon Cheddar Burger
Cheddar cheese, BBQ sauce, Applewood smoked bacon and mustard. Served with lettuce, tomato, onion, pickle and french fries seasoned with sea salt.
$12.00 - -
Spicy Chipotle Burger
Crispy fried onions, pepper jack cheese, and freshly made chipotle garlic mayo. Served with lettuce, tomato, onion, pickle and french fries seasoned with sea salt.
$12.00 - -
The Classic Burger
Choose from American, Swiss, cheddar, pepper jack or blue cheese crumbles. Served with lettuce, tomato, onion, pickle and french fries seasoned with sea salt.
$11.00 - -

Steak and Ale Classics

Smothered Chicken
2 perfectly seasoned, grilled chicken breasts, layered with luscious ale onions, Merlot mushrooms. Topped with cheddar cheese and Applewood smoked bacon. Served with a side of roasted garlic mashed potatoes and maple roasted Brussels sprouts.
$13.00 - -
Hawaiian Chicken
2 chicken breasts, infused with our heavenly Hawaiian marinade. Topped with perfectly grilled pineapple rings, then finished with more Hawaiian glaze. Served with herb rice pilaf and broccoli saute.
$13.00 - -
Grilled 8 oz. Kensington Club
Top sirloin marinated in our secret Kensington glaze. Served with roasted garlic mashed potatoes and maple roasted Brussels sprouts.
$16.00 - -

Sides

Garden Salad Side
Choice of dressing.
$3.00 - -
Caesar Salad Side $3.00 - -
Sweet Potato Fries Side $3.00 - -
Broccoli Saute Side $3.00 - -
Roasted Garlic Mashed Potatoes Side $3.00 - -
Maple Roasted Brussels Sprouts Side $3.00 - -
Kicked-Up Coleslaw Side $3.00 - -
Home-Style French Fries Side $3.00 - -
Herb Rice Pilaf Side $3.00 - -
Seasonal Vegetables Side $3.00 - -

Desserts

Legendary Death by Chocolate
Bennigan's original recipe of rich chocolate ice cream, almonds, mini-marshmallows, chocolate fudge sauce and Twix cookie bars, on a crumbled Oreo cookie crust. Covered in a chocolate shell with a side of hot chocolate topping.
$7.00 - -
New York Cheesecake
Rich, traditional New York style cheesecake. Topped with a fresh strawberry sauce.
$7.00 - -
House-Made Bread Pudding with Praline Sauce
Our house-made bread pudding drenched in hot praline sauce, then topped with a scoop of vanilla ice cream and powdered sugar.
$7.00 - -
Brownie Bottom Pie
A chewy chocolate fudge brownie with vanilla ice cream on top. Covered with hot fudge, whipped cream and a cherry.
$7.00 - -
Disclaimer: PriceListo gathers actual pricing information from sources such as on-site visits, business websites, and phone interviews. The prices reported on this webpage derive from one or more of those sources. Naturally, the prices reported on this website may not be current, and may not apply to all locations of a given business brand. To obtain current pricing, contact the individual business location of interest to you.