Pappy's Place Menu
Most Ordered
There are 12 food items in the Pappy's Place Most Ordered menu, with an average price of $ 14.75. The cheapest item is P's House Made Cheesecake, priced at $ 7.00, while the most expensive is The Dip at $ 17.50. You can examine, compare, and download pricing and calorie data by browsing the full list of food items.
-
P’s Chicken Strips
$15.50
Fresh chicken breast, hand-cut on-premise beer batter fried served with house-made BBQ sauce.
Delivery Price Comparison
GrubHub Cheapest$19.88DoorDash$20.64Uber Eats$22.28Includes base price + estimated fees
-
Ellsworth Cheese Curds
$12.00
Wisconsin white natural curd deep-fried golden brown served with P’s creamy BBQ sauce.
Delivery Price Comparison
GrubHub Cheapest$15.70DoorDash$17.13Uber Eats$18.37Includes base price + estimated fees
-
The Dip
$17.50
Thinly sliced choice beef and caramelized onions on a crusted French hoagie roll with choice of cheese and beef au jus.
Delivery Price Comparison
GrubHub Cheapest$22.27DoorDash$22.65Uber Eats$24.51Includes base price + estimated fees
-
Bacon Cheese
$16.99
Crisp pecan smoked bacon, smoked tomato aioli, and your choice of cheese.
Delivery Price Comparison
GrubHub Cheapest$21.66DoorDash$22.14Uber Eats$23.94Includes base price + estimated fees
-
Pappy Deluxe
$17.50
The pappy deluxe – cheese curds, onion ring, housemade bbq sauce, lettuce, tomato, pecan smoked bacon and pickles.
Delivery Price Comparison
GrubHub Cheapest$22.27DoorDash$22.65Uber Eats$24.51Includes base price + estimated fees
-
Pappy
$16.99
The pappy – Wisconsin cheese curds, pappy’s onion ring, and house-made creamy bbq sauce.
Delivery Price Comparison
GrubHub Cheapest$21.66DoorDash$22.14Uber Eats$23.94Includes base price + estimated fees
-
Chicken Wings Bone-in or Boneless
$16.00
Tossed with your favorite sauce: buffalo, smokey honey bourbon, tropical mango habanero, balsamic buffalo, honey stingin
Delivery Price Comparison
GrubHub Cheapest$20.48DoorDash$21.15Uber Eats$22.83Includes base price + estimated fees
-
Swiss and Fungi
$16.99
Gooey Swiss cheese, smoked tomato aioli and lots of sautéed mushrooms.
Delivery Price Comparison
GrubHub Cheapest$21.66DoorDash$22.14Uber Eats$23.94Includes base price + estimated fees
-
Raspberry breadpudding
$7.00
Delivery Price Comparison
GrubHub Cheapest$9.73DoorDash$12.11Uber Eats$12.79Includes base price + estimated fees
-
House Made Potato Crusted Walleye Fingers
$16.50
Hand cut, flash-fried walleye strips with housemade tartar sauce.
Delivery Price Comparison
GrubHub Cheapest$21.07DoorDash$21.65Uber Eats$23.39Includes base price + estimated fees
-
P's House Made Cheesecake
$7.00
Delivery Price Comparison
GrubHub Cheapest$9.73DoorDash$12.11Uber Eats$12.79Includes base price + estimated fees
-
Quesadilla Burger
$16.99
Grilled flour tortilla, pepper jack cheese topped with red onion, tomatoes and southwest ranch sauce.
Delivery Price Comparison
GrubHub Cheapest$21.66DoorDash$22.14Uber Eats$23.94Includes base price + estimated fees
Sandwichs and wraps
There are 5 food items in the Pappy's Place Sandwichs and wraps menu, with an average price of $ 16.8. The cheapest item is Gyro Wrap, priced at $ 16.00, while the most expensive is The Dip (Sandwichs and wraps) at $ 17.50. You can examine, compare, and download pricing and calorie data by browsing the full list of food items.
-
Buffalo Chicken Wrap
$16.50
Grilled chicken, lettuce, tomato, red onion, and a spicy buffalo sauce and Amableu sauce on herb tortilla wrap.
Delivery Price Comparison
GrubHub Cheapest$21.07DoorDash$21.65Uber Eats$23.39Includes base price + estimated fees
-
Steak and Blu Wrap
$17.00
Delivery Price Comparison
GrubHub Cheapest$21.67DoorDash$22.15Uber Eats$23.95Includes base price + estimated fees
-
Gyro Wrap
$16.00
Beef and lamb gyro meat, lettuce greens, tomato, onion and tzatziki.
Delivery Price Comparison
GrubHub Cheapest$20.48DoorDash$21.15Uber Eats$22.83Includes base price + estimated fees
-
The Dip (Sandwichs and wraps)
$17.50
Thinly sliced choice beef and caramelized onions on a crusted French hoagie roll with choice of cheese and beef au jus.
Delivery Price Comparison
GrubHub Cheapest$22.27DoorDash$22.65Uber Eats$24.51Includes base price + estimated fees
-
Pike Reuben
$17.00
↑+$2.01Wild walleye fillet, lightly breaded, topped with Pappy’s slaw and Swiss cheese on grilled rye bread.
Delivery Price Comparison
GrubHub Cheapest$21.67DoorDash$22.15Uber Eats$23.95Includes base price + estimated fees
Pappy’s Burger
There are 10 food items in the Pappy's Place Pappy’s Burger menu, with an average price of $ 16.74. The cheapest item is Californa Burger, priced at $ 14.00, while the most expensive is Pappy Deluxe (Pappy’s Burger) at $ 17.50. You can examine, compare, and download pricing and calorie data by browsing the full list of food items.
-
Pappy Deluxe (Pappy’s Burger)
$17.50
The pappy deluxe – cheese curds, onion ring, housemade bbq sauce, lettuce, tomato, pecan smoked bacon and pickles.
Delivery Price Comparison
GrubHub Cheapest$22.27DoorDash$22.65Uber Eats$24.51Includes base price + estimated fees
-
Swiss and Fungi (Pappy’s Burger)
$16.99
Gooey Swiss cheese, smoked tomato aioli and lots of sautéed mushrooms.
Delivery Price Comparison
GrubHub Cheapest$21.66DoorDash$22.14Uber Eats$23.94Includes base price + estimated fees
-
Pappy (Pappy’s Burger)
$16.99
The pappy – Wisconsin cheese curds, pappy’s onion ring, and house-made creamy bbq sauce.
Delivery Price Comparison
GrubHub Cheapest$21.66DoorDash$22.14Uber Eats$23.94Includes base price + estimated fees
-
P’s Patty Melt
$16.99
Beef patty, grilled rye bread with sautéed onions, Swiss and American cheeses.
Delivery Price Comparison
GrubHub Cheapest$21.66DoorDash$22.14Uber Eats$23.94Includes base price + estimated fees
-
Quesadilla Burger (Pappy’s Burger)
$16.99
Grilled flour tortilla, pepper jack cheese topped with red onion, tomatoes and southwest ranch sauce.
Delivery Price Comparison
GrubHub Cheapest$21.66DoorDash$22.14Uber Eats$23.94Includes base price + estimated fees
-
Smoked House Burger
$16.99
P’s smokey BBQ sauce, smoked pecan bacon, onions, and choice of cheese.
Delivery Price Comparison
GrubHub Cheapest$21.66DoorDash$22.14Uber Eats$23.94Includes base price + estimated fees
-
P’s Bleu Moon Burger
$16.99
melted creamy blu cheese, mushrooms, bacon, crispy onions
Delivery Price Comparison
GrubHub Cheapest$21.66DoorDash$22.14Uber Eats$23.94Includes base price + estimated fees
-
Californa Burger
$14.00
The “I only want a plain burger” person, served with smoked chipotle tomato aioli.
Delivery Price Comparison
GrubHub Cheapest$18.09DoorDash$19.14Uber Eats$20.60Includes base price + estimated fees
-
“The Hangover“
$16.99
Pecan smoked bacon, cheddar cheese, hot sauce, and fried chicken egg.
Delivery Price Comparison
GrubHub Cheapest$21.66DoorDash$22.14Uber Eats$23.94Includes base price + estimated fees
-
Bacon Cheese (Pappy’s Burger)
$16.99
Crisp pecan smoked bacon, smoked tomato aioli, and your choice of cheese.
Delivery Price Comparison
GrubHub Cheapest$21.66DoorDash$22.14Uber Eats$23.94Includes base price + estimated fees
Pappy’s Tizers
There are 7 food items in the Pappy's Place Pappy’s Tizers menu, with an average price of $ 16.29. The cheapest item is Ellsworth Cheese Curds (Pappy’s Tizers), priced at $ 12.00, while the most expensive is P’s Artichoke Lobster Dip at $ 19.00. You can examine, compare, and download pricing and calorie data by browsing the full list of food items.
-
P’s Chicken Strips (Pappy’s Tizers)
$15.50
Fresh chicken breast, hand-cut on-premise beer batter fried served with house-made BBQ sauce.
Delivery Price Comparison
GrubHub Cheapest$19.88DoorDash$20.64Uber Eats$22.28Includes base price + estimated fees
-
House Made Potato Crusted Walleye Fingers (Pappy’s Tizers)
$16.50
Hand cut, flash-fried walleye strips with housemade tartar sauce.
Delivery Price Comparison
GrubHub Cheapest$21.07DoorDash$21.65Uber Eats$23.39Includes base price + estimated fees
-
P’s Scallop Benedict
$18.00
Pecan wood smoked bacon wrapped scallops served over toast points and topped with hollandaise sauce.
Delivery Price Comparison
GrubHub Cheapest$22.86DoorDash$23.15Uber Eats$25.07Includes base price + estimated fees
-
Rotisserie Chicken Nachos Supreme
$17.00
Delivery Price Comparison
GrubHub Cheapest$21.67DoorDash$22.15Uber Eats$23.95Includes base price + estimated fees
-
P’s Artichoke Lobster Dip
$19.00
Lobster meat, artichokes, and a special blend of cheese topped with scallions and toasted almonds served with French bre
Delivery Price Comparison
GrubHub Cheapest$24.06DoorDash$24.16Uber Eats$26.18Includes base price + estimated fees
-
Ellsworth Cheese Curds (Pappy’s Tizers)
$12.00
Wisconsin white natural curd deep-fried golden brown served with P’s creamy BBQ sauce.
Delivery Price Comparison
GrubHub Cheapest$15.70DoorDash$17.13Uber Eats$18.37Includes base price + estimated fees
-
Chicken Wings Bone-in or Boneless (Pappy’s Tizers)
$16.00
Tossed with your favorite sauce: buffalo, smokey honey bourbon, tropical mango habanero, balsamic buffalo, honey stingin
Delivery Price Comparison
GrubHub Cheapest$20.48DoorDash$21.15Uber Eats$22.83Includes base price + estimated fees
Pappy’s Entree's
There are 10 food items in the Pappy's Place Pappy’s Entree's menu, with an average price of $ 34. The cheapest item is P’s BBQ Pork Ribs, priced at $ 27.00, while the most expensive is P’s Filet Migon at $ 44.00. You can examine, compare, and download pricing and calorie data by browsing the full list of food items.
-
P’s Filet Migon
$44.00
Nine ounces of hand-cut center cut steak served to sizzle with sautéed mushrooms.
Delivery Price Comparison
DoorDash Cheapest$49.24GrubHub$53.89Uber Eats$54.10Includes base price + estimated fees
-
Batter Fried Shrimp
$28.00
Six large white shrimp batter fried. Served with your choice of house-made tartar sauce or cocktail.
Delivery Price Comparison
DoorDash Cheapest$33.19GrubHub$34.80Uber Eats$36.23Includes base price + estimated fees
-
Grilled Ribeye
$40.00
14 ounces of well-aged, hand-cut grilled to liking topped with herbed butter.
Delivery Price Comparison
DoorDash Cheapest$45.23GrubHub$49.12Uber Eats$49.63Includes base price + estimated fees
-
P’s Petite Filet
$37.00
Six ounces of hand-cut steak served over the balsamic glaze.
Delivery Price Comparison
DoorDash Cheapest$42.22GrubHub$45.54Uber Eats$46.28Includes base price + estimated fees
-
Pan Fried Sea Scallops
$35.00
All-natural scallops Pan Fried
Delivery Price Comparison
DoorDash Cheapest$40.21GrubHub$43.15Uber Eats$44.05Includes base price + estimated fees
-
Wild Walleye
$28.00
Minnesota’s favorite! Your choice of Parmesan-crusted, lemon pepper broiled or beer batter fried.
Delivery Price Comparison
DoorDash Cheapest$33.19GrubHub$34.80Uber Eats$36.23Includes base price + estimated fees
-
Steak and Shrimp
$38.00
Six ounces of tenderloin filet of beef with three large fried shrimp.
Delivery Price Comparison
DoorDash Cheapest$43.22GrubHub$46.73Uber Eats$47.40Includes base price + estimated fees
-
P’s BBQ Pork Ribs
$27.00
Special rub and slowly braised to perfection! Finished with P’s house-made BBQ sauce.
Delivery Price Comparison
DoorDash Cheapest$32.18GrubHub$33.60Uber Eats$35.12Includes base price + estimated fees
-
BBQ Ribs and Shrimp Combo
$33.00
Fall off the bone ribs with three jumbo batter-fried shrimp.
Delivery Price Comparison
DoorDash Cheapest$38.21GrubHub$40.77Uber Eats$41.81Includes base price + estimated fees
-
BBQ Ribs and Chicken Combo
$30.00
Fall off the bone ribs with batter-fried chicken strips.
Delivery Price Comparison
DoorDash Cheapest$35.20GrubHub$37.19Uber Eats$38.47Includes base price + estimated fees
Pizza & Bread
There are 1 food items in the Pappy's Place Pizza & Bread menu, with an average price of $ 19. The cheapest item is The Meat Head Pizza, priced at $ 19.00, while the most expensive is The Meat Head Pizza at $ 19.00. You can examine, compare, and download pricing and calorie data by browsing the full list of food items.
-
The Meat Head Pizza
$19.00
Crispy thin 12″ crust topped with Pappy’s house red sauce, spicy Italian sausage, Canadian bacon, and pepperoni and aged
Delivery Price Comparison
GrubHub Cheapest$24.06DoorDash$24.16Uber Eats$26.18Includes base price + estimated fees
Soup & Salads
There are 5 food items in the Pappy's Place Soup & Salads menu, with an average price of $ 14.6. The cheapest item is Pear and Candied Pecan Salad, priced at $ 10.99, while the most expensive is Buffalo Chicken salad at $ 18.00. You can examine, compare, and download pricing and calorie data by browsing the full list of food items.
-
Steak House Choped Salad
$18.00
Delivery Price Comparison
GrubHub Cheapest$22.86DoorDash$23.15Uber Eats$25.07Includes base price + estimated fees
-
P’s Greek Salad
$13.00
Fresh greens tossed with Pappy’s house-made dressing served over house-made potato salad and topped with feta cheese, ka
Delivery Price Comparison
GrubHub Cheapest$16.90DoorDash$18.14Uber Eats$19.48Includes base price + estimated fees
-
Buffalo Chicken salad
$18.00
Delivery Price Comparison
GrubHub Cheapest$22.86DoorDash$23.15Uber Eats$25.07Includes base price + estimated fees
-
Pappy’s Wedge Salad
$13.00
Pappys family traditional wedge salad crisp iceberg lettuce topped with Amableu cheese dressing, diced red onions, real
Delivery Price Comparison
GrubHub Cheapest$16.90DoorDash$18.14Uber Eats$19.48Includes base price + estimated fees
-
Pear and Candied Pecan Salad
$10.99
Spring greens tossed with P’s creamy maple cider dressing served with pear wedges and topped with Amablue cheese crumble
Delivery Price Comparison
GrubHub Cheapest$14.50DoorDash$16.12Uber Eats$17.24Includes base price + estimated fees
Desserts
There are 2 food items in the Pappy's Place Desserts menu, with an average price of $ 7. The cheapest item is P's House Made Cheesecake (Desserts), priced at $ 7.00, while the most expensive is P's House Made Cheesecake (Desserts) at $ 7.00. You can examine, compare, and download pricing and calorie data by browsing the full list of food items.
-
P's House Made Cheesecake (Desserts)
$7.00
Delivery Price Comparison
GrubHub Cheapest$9.73DoorDash$12.11Uber Eats$12.79Includes base price + estimated fees
-
Raspberry breadpudding (Desserts)
$7.00
Delivery Price Comparison
GrubHub Cheapest$9.73DoorDash$12.11Uber Eats$12.79Includes base price + estimated fees
Specials
There are 1 food items in the Pappy's Place Specials menu, with an average price of $ 19. The cheapest item is Friday Fish Fry, priced at $ 19.00, while the most expensive is Friday Fish Fry at $ 19.00. You can examine, compare, and download pricing and calorie data by browsing the full list of food items.
-
Friday Fish Fry
$19.00
Special rub and slowly braised to perfection! Finished with P’s house-made BBQ sauce.
Delivery Price Comparison
GrubHub Cheapest$24.06DoorDash$24.16Uber Eats$26.18Includes base price + estimated fees
Download Menu PDF
Enter your email to download the Pappy's Place menu prices PDF.
