1. PriceListo
  2. Prime 16 Menu with Prices 2026 (United States)

Prime 16 Menu with Prices 2026 (United States)

⭐ 0.00/5 (0) reviews
USD prices currency
$10.54 Average Item Price

Updated on:

You are viewing prices confirmed by PriceListo at the following Prime 16 location:
172 Temple St, New Haven, CT, 06510, US 1(203) 782-1616

On the Prime 16 menu, the most expensive item is The Smoker, which costs $16.95. The cheapest item on the menu is Ketchup, which costs $0.50. The average price of all items on the menu is currently $10.54.

View the Prime 16 menu prices list below for the most accurate and up-to-date menu prices. We aggregate data from 4 Prime 16 locations in our database to create the most accurate list of Prime 16 prices. Don't rely on outdated price data. We update our database frequently to ensure that the prices are as accurate as possible.

Prime 16 is a chain of gourmet burger restaurant and American tap house known for creative burgers, appetizers, and a large selection of craft beer. Popular items on the menu include the Smokehouse Burger and the Cowboy Burger. The cheapest dish is 6 Boneless Wings, which costs $10.95 to $12.95. The most expensive dish is the Belgium Bierhaus, which costs $26.00 to $28.00. The menu features burgers starting at $17.95, small bites from $8.50, and salads from $12.95.

Prime 16 was opened in New Haven, Connecticut, in April 2008. The restaurant quickly built a reputation for its commitment to high-quality ingredients, using all-natural, hormone-free beef for its burgers and offering a constantly rotating selection of craft beers. The "16" in the name originally referred to the number of beer taps, but this number has since grown. The establishment is known as a go-to destination for both burger lovers and craft beer enthusiasts in the area. The restaurant operates 3 Prime 16 locations, 2 in Connecticut and 1 in New York.

Prime 16 Menu

What is Prime 16 Most Famous For?

Prime 16 is most famous for its gourmet burgers and extensive selection of American craft beer. The restaurant is known for using all-natural, hormone-free ground beef and for a creative menu of burger combinations. What sets Prime 16 apart is the focus on pairing high-quality burgers with a carefully curated, rotating tap list of craft beers, creating a modern gastropub experience. The use of fresh, locally sourced ingredients when possible further distinguishes the establishment from standard burger bars.


What are the Most Popular Signature Items on the Prime 16 Menu?

The most popular items on the Prime 16 menu are the Smokehouse Burger and the Cowboy Burger. Other bestselling dishes are listed below:

  • Smokehouse Burger: A beef patty topped with smoked bacon, smoked gouda cheese, fried onion strings, and a house-made barbecue sauce.
  • Cowboy Burger: A beef patty with cheddar cheese, bacon, and a sunny-side-up fried egg.
  • Truffle Fries: Hand-cut French fries tossed with truffle oil, parmesan cheese, and fresh herbs.
  • The Prime Mac & Cheese: A creamy macaroni and cheese made with a blend of cheeses, with options to add bacon, pulled pork, or buffalo chicken.
  • The Blue Burger: A beef patty topped with blue cheese, bacon, and caramelized onions.
  • The Veggie Burger: A house-made vegetarian patty made with black beans, corn, and spices, served with avocado and a chipotle aioli.
  • Wings: Chicken wings tossed in a choice of sauces, including buffalo, barbecue, or garlic parmesan.


What Drinks and Beverages Can You Have at Prime 16?

Prime 16 offers a large, rotating selection of American craft beers on tap and a menu of signature cocktails. The beverage program is centered around the 20 tap lines that feature a mix of local and national craft breweries. The draft beer selection is a main feature, with styles chosen to pair with the rich flavors of the gourmet burgers.

  • Craft Beer on Tap: A constantly changing list of 20 American craft beers, with a focus on IPAs, stouts, and seasonal offerings from breweries in Connecticut and beyond.
  • Bourbon Selection: A curated list of bourbons and American whiskeys available for sipping or in cocktails.
  • Signature Cocktails: A menu of handcrafted cocktails, such as the P16 Old Fashioned or seasonal mules.
  • Wine Selection: A small list of red and white wines available by the glass or bottle.
  • Soft Drinks: Standard fountain drinks and bottled sodas.


What is the Cheapest Meal on the Prime 16 Menu?

The cheapest meal on the Prime 16 menu is 6 Boneless Wings, which costs $10.95 to $12.95 at the New Haven, CT location, served with carrots and celery. 

What is the Most Expensive Meal on the Prime 16 Menu?

The most expensive meal on the Prime 16 menu is the Belgium Bierhaus, which costs $26.00 to $28.00 at the New Haven, CT location. This burger features cracked black pepper patty, whipped Brie cheese, Belgium stew, tobacco fried onions on a toasted pretzel bun, served with French Dijon mustard dip and white truffle fries.


What are the Healthiest Meals on the Prime 16 Menu?

The healthiest meals on the Prime 16 menu are the Basic Salad and the Veggie Burger. The Basic Salad contains mixed greens, carrot, red onion, bell pepper, cucumber, tomato hopped house vinaigrette. The house-made Veggie Burger offers a non-meat alternative packed with black beans and vegetables.

What Do Prime 16 Burgers Taste Like?

The burgers at Prime 16 have a rich, beefy flavor due to the use of all-natural, hormone-free ground beef. The prime burger patties are known for being juicy and cooked to order, creating a fresh and high-quality taste. What makes the burgers special is the combination of this quality beef with creative and fresh toppings, such as smoked gouda, fried onion strings, or truffle aioli, all served on a brioche bun. The careful construction and unique ingredient pairings result in a balanced and flavorful gourmet burger experience.


How Often Does Prime 16 Offer Special Offers?

Prime 16 offers happy hour with prices ranging from $3 to $7 which includes small bites, and half price wines, beers, and cocktails. 

Does Prime 16 Offer Happy Hour Discounts?

Yes, Prime 16 offers a daily happy hour with discounts on drinks and food. Happy hour runs from 4:00 PM to 6:00 PM on weekdays and from 2:00 PM to 4:00 PM on weekends. During these times, all draft beers are half price. The menu also features $7 specialty cocktails like the Pineapple Express and Sangria de Madrid, as well as $7 glasses of Cabernet Sauvignon and Pinot Grigio. A selection of "Happy Hour Bites" is available, with prices from $5 to $8, including items like Mini Mac & Cheese, Fried Sweet Plantains, and Mini Beef & Cilantro Empanadas.

Does Prime 16 Have a Loyalty Program?

No, Prime 16 does not have a loyalty program. The restaurant does not offer a points-based or membership rewards system for repeat customers.

Does Prime 16 Offer Family Meal Bundles?

No, Prime 16 does not offer family meal bundles. The menu is designed for individual ordering in a restaurant setting and does not include family-style takeout packages.

Does Prime 16 Offer Vegan Options?

Yes, Prime 16 offers vegan options such as Buffalo Cauliflower, Vegetable Tacos, Tacos Suiza, Vegetable Sliders, Vegetable Quesadillas, and Vegan Cheese Nachos. 

Does Prime 16 Offer Gluten-Free Options?

Yes, Prime 16 offers gluten-free options. The gluten-free options on the menu are the burgers, which can be served on a gluten-free bun or on a bed of lettuce, and the House Salad. The restaurant provides gluten-free buns for an additional charge.

Is Prime 16 Pet-Friendly?

Yes, Prime 16 is pet-friendly at their locations with outdoor seating. The New Haven, CT, location has a patio where well-behaved dogs are welcome.

Can You Order Ala Carte in Prime 16?

Yes, customers can order a la carte at Prime 16. The entire menu is structured for individual ordering, with a la carte options such as the Smokehouse Burger, Truffle Fries, and Prime Mac & Cheese.


What Other Services Does Prime 16 Offer?

Prime 16 operates as a modern American tap house with a full-service bar. The bar is a central part of the experience, featuring 20 rotating taps dedicated to American craft beer, alongside a curated selection of bourbons and signature cocktails.

Does Prime 16 Offer Catering Services?

Yes, Prime 16 offers catering with a menu of half-tray and full-tray platters. Half trays are designed to serve 10 guests, while full trays serve 15-20 guests. The menu includes a wide selection of items, from finger foods to full entrees. Meat and poultry options like Mini Burger Sliders and Baby Back BBQ Ribs range from $55 to $170 per tray. Vegetarian and vegan platters, such as Kale Falafel Bites and Vegan Vegetable Tacos, are available with prices from $45 to $160. The catering menu also features salads, sides like Truffle Parmesan Fries, and "Mexibites" like quesadillas and nachos.

Can You Rent Prime 16 for Private Occasions?

Yes, Prime 16 can be rented for private occasions. The restaurant offers several options for private parties and events, including formal sit-down dinners and cocktail-style parties, with a non-refundable deposit of $150 required for booking. For formal, sit-down events with an 18-person minimum, Prime 16 provides several multi-course menu options. A two-course menu is available for $29.95 per person, and three-course menus are offered at $36.95 and $40.95 per person. These packages allow guests to choose from entrees like the Tap House Signature Burger, Prime16 Famous Fried Chicken Sandwich, and Kale Falafel Pita. For more casual, cocktail-style parties, the restaurant offers a selection of party platters. Each platter is designed to serve 15-20 guests. Pricing for platters ranges from $55 for Fried Sweet Plantains to $195 for Mini Blue Claw Crab Cakes. 

Options include Mini Burger Sliders, Boneless Wings, Mac & Cheese, and various nacho and taco platters. Several bar packages are also available for private events priced per person for a two-hour service, with options to extend for an additional hourly fee. Packages range from the "Meet and Greet" at $24 per person to "The Platinum" full bar at $42 per person. All charges are subject to state sales tax and a 20% service charge.

Does Prime 16 Do House Delivery?

Yes, Prime 16 does house delivery. Delivery is available through third-party platforms like Grubhub, Doordash, and Uber Eats.

Does Prime 16 Accept Online Orders?

Yes, Prime 16 accepts online orders. Customers can place orders for takeout or delivery directly through the restaurant's website or via third-party delivery applications.

How are the Reviews for Customer Experience at Prime 16?

Reviews for the customer experience at Prime 16 are often positive, with customers praising the high-quality gourmet burgers and the extensive craft beer selection. The atmosphere is described as a lively, casual gastropub, making it a popular spot for both dinner and drinks. The food quality is a standout feature, with the all-natural beef and creative topping combinations receiving frequent commendation. Service is generally seen as friendly and knowledgeable, especially regarding the rotating beer list, though the restaurant can get very busy, affecting wait times.

Who are the Top Competitors of Prime 16?

The top competitors of Prime 16 are Louis' Lunch and Shake Shack. The list of competitors includes other well-regarded burger restaurants and gastropubs in the New Haven area.

  • Shake Shack: A popular fast-casual chain famous for its smashed-style burgers, crinkle-cut fries, and frozen custard shakes.
  • Red Robin: A long-standing restaurant chain, Red Robin is best known for gourmet burgers. 
  • Louis' Lunch: A historic New Haven eatery claiming to be the birthplace of the hamburger sandwich, known for serving burgers on white toast.
  • The Cask Republic: A gastropub with a large selection of craft beers and a menu of upscale pub food, including burgers.
  • Au Chalet: A food truck in New Haven specializing in Swiss-inspired burgers and raclette cheese dishes.


Is Prime 16 One of the Famous Restaurants in New Haven?

Yes, Prime 16 is one of the famous restaurants in New Haven, especially for burger enthusiasts. Prime 16 New Haven has built a strong reputation and is consistently listed as a destination for the best burger in New Haven. 

Category Restaurants
Prime 16 prices

Popular Restaurants