Pumphouse Creamery Menu with Prices 2026 (United States)

Mint Chocolate Chip

Homemade chocolate chips meets powerful Boyajian mint extract. A great combination with soft chocolate chips that melt i

Homemade chocolate chips meets powerful Boyajian mint extract. A great combination with soft chocolate chips that melt in your mouth.

Cookies and Cream using Newman O’s

We use the all natural and organic version of Oreos here – Newman O’s. First we soak the cookies overnight in milk to ge

We use the all natural and organic version of Oreos here – Newman O’s. First we soak the cookies overnight in milk to get a cookie milk then churn it. What’s next? Adding even more cookies! Creamy, bold, and like all of our flavors, this is the best we know to make it.

Salty Peanut Butter with Chocolate Chips

Our year-round best selling ice cream. locally made peanut butter from good life is used in the base with our homemade s

Our year-round best selling ice cream. locally made peanut butter from good life is used in the base with our homemade semi soft, chocolate chips folded in. A salty kiss of Jacobsen sea salt from oregon’s coastal waters is the key to bringing out the peanut butter yumminess.

Madagascar Vanilla

If you want to know how fresh our ice cream is give our madagascar vanilla a try. We use both vanilla beans and vanilla

If you want to know how fresh our ice cream is give our madagascar vanilla a try. We use both vanilla beans and vanilla extract grown in the madagascar region. We don’t mess around with this robust and full-bodied flavor with notes that include bourbon, cigar box and caramel.

Chocolate

We use guittard cocoa powder and wow! - you get a creamy, dense, fudgy chocolate base. It’s chocolate ice cream the best

We use guittard cocoa powder and wow! - you get a creamy, dense, fudgy chocolate base. It’s chocolate ice cream the best way we know how to make it. If you are a chocolate fanatic, we made this 1 for you.

Sea Salt, Caramel and Praline Pecans

Using King’s cupboard’s simple, all-natural caramel sauce makes this flavor a go-to for many fans. Jacobsen salt co. in

Using King’s cupboard’s simple, all-natural caramel sauce makes this flavor a go-to for many fans. Jacobsen salt co. in netarts bay provides us the sea salt harvested from Oregon’s cold coastal waters. Food and wine magazine awarded us top 20 ice cream shop in America and this flavor was highlighted, yea - it’s that good.

Coconut, Roasted Almonds and Chocolate Chips

A top selling flavor and quite a standout. Coconut ice cream is the base using pureed coconut. We then fold in our homem

A top selling flavor and quite a standout. Coconut ice cream is the base using pureed coconut. We then fold in our homemade chocolate chips along with roasted and salted almonds. You can’t go wrong, it’s the owners favorite flavor at the shop.

Malted Vanilla with All-Natural Malted Milk Balls

If you are a malt fan this is your jam! Malt powder combined with Autumnwood Farm dairy is heaven. All natural malted mi

If you are a malt fan this is your jam! Malt powder combined with Autumnwood Farm dairy is heaven. All natural malted milk balls are folded in to boost the maltiness and give a nice chunky texture.

Mint Chocolate Chip (Ice Cream)

Homemade chocolate chips meets powerful Boyajian mint extract. A great combination with soft chocolate chips that melt i

Homemade chocolate chips meets powerful Boyajian mint extract. A great combination with soft chocolate chips that melt in your mouth.

Cookies and Cream using Newman O’s (Ice Cream)

We use the all natural and organic version of Oreos here – Newman O’s. First we soak the cookies overnight in milk to ge

We use the all natural and organic version of Oreos here – Newman O’s. First we soak the cookies overnight in milk to get a cookie milk then churn it. What’s next? Adding even more cookies! Creamy, bold, and like all of our flavors, this is the best we know to make it.

Fresh Banana

Our fresh banana ice cream is a secret gem here, we have a cult following behind this flavor. Equal exchange fresh fair

Our fresh banana ice cream is a secret gem here, we have a cult following behind this flavor. Equal exchange fresh fair trade organic bananas, cream, milk, cane sugar and organic egg yolks are all you need.

Strawberry

Strawberries are fresh in June, july here in minnesota and we take full advantage of that. SE MN food network is where w

Strawberries are fresh in June, july here in minnesota and we take full advantage of that. SE MN food network is where we get our local berries. As always with this farming community, no pesticides or chemicals are used and organic practices are customary.

Salty Peanut Butter with Chocolate Chips (Ice Cream)

Our year-round best selling ice cream. locally made peanut butter from good life is used in the base with our homemade s

Our year-round best selling ice cream. locally made peanut butter from good life is used in the base with our homemade semi soft, chocolate chips folded in. A salty kiss of Jacobsen sea salt from oregon’s coastal waters is the key to bringing out the peanut butter yumminess.

Ruby Roasters Coffee with Almond Toffee

Central wisconsin ruby roasters decaf coffee is steeped for 2 days, strained and churned into a robust, full-bodied, cof

Central wisconsin ruby roasters decaf coffee is steeped for 2 days, strained and churned into a robust, full-bodied, coffee ice cream. Chunks of handmade almond toffee from mayana chocolates in spooner, wisc. are added as soon as it comes out of the machine.

Lemon Infused Olive Oil

California lemons infused with California olive oil. New flavor this spring that is wildly popular.

California lemons infused with California olive oil. New flavor this spring that is wildly popular.

Vietnamese Cinnamon

Fresh Farmers Market Pumpkin

Using Long Island Cheese squash from the St. Paul Farmers Market. We take our local ingredients serious here and this on

Using Long Island Cheese squash from the St. Paul Farmers Market. We take our local ingredients serious here and this one puts an exclamation mark on our commitment.

Cinnamon, Anise, Fennel, Black Pepper, Cloves

Black Raspberry Crisp

Black raspberry jam from Mrs. miller’s homemade jam in fredericksburg, Ohio is our source for simple all natural jam swi

Black raspberry jam from Mrs. miller’s homemade jam in fredericksburg, Ohio is our source for simple all natural jam swirled in a base of Mexican vanilla ice cream. We make the crisp here using local organic oats, butter, whole wheat heirloom wheat flour, and muscovado sugar.

Non Dairy Salty Peanut Butter with Chocolate Chips

Our best selling non-dairy flavor uses locally-made peanut butter from Good Life along with our homemade chocolate chips

Our best selling non-dairy flavor uses locally-made peanut butter from Good Life along with our homemade chocolate chips. A salty kiss of Jacobsen Sea Salt from Oregon’s coastal waters is a key component to this stellar vegan option.

Passion Fruit and Mango Sorbet

One of our best selling sorbets combines sweet mango with tart passion fruit. Low in sugar and high in fruit.

One of our best selling sorbets combines sweet mango with tart passion fruit. Low in sugar and high in fruit.