Bahama Breeze Desserts Prices
Bahama Breeze desserts are the perfect way to end your meal. These selections are made with authentic island ingredients like real key lime juice and Jamaican rum to provide a consistent Caribbean flavor. Based on the latest Bahama Breeze desserts prices, most items fall between $9.99 and $11.49, with the Rebecca’s Key Lime Pie as the cheapest dessert option, and the Flaming Pineapple Butter Cake as the most expensive item.
Bahama Breeze menu prices 2026
How much is Rebecca's Key Lime Pie?
An order of Rebecca's Key Lime Pie involves Bahama Breeze desserts prices ranging from $9.99 to $11.49. This signature dessert features a graham cracker crust and a tart filling made with real key lime juice. Rebecca's Key Lime Pie costs $9.99 in Fayetteville, and $11.49 in New York City.
How much is a Chocolate Island?
Ordering a Chocolate Island involves Bahama Breeze desserts prices between $10.49 and $11.99. This rich chocolate mousse cake is served with vanilla bean ice cream and chocolate sauce. The Chocolate Island costs $10.49 in Fayetteville, and $11.99 in New York City.
How much is a Bananas Supreme?
The Bananas Supreme is no longer on the menu. In 2019, the cost for this item was $6.49 based on Bahama Breeze desserts prices at that time. This selection featured sliced bananas sautéed in butter and rum and served over vanilla ice cream.
How much is a Rum Cake?
The Rum Cake is no longer on the menu. Historical records for Bahama Breeze desserts prices show this item cost $7.49 in 2019. It provided a moist sponge cake soaked in Jamaican rum and topped with whipped cream.
How much is a Flaming Pineapple Butter Cake?
Getting the Flaming Pineapple Butter Cake involves Bahama Breeze desserts prices from $10.99 to $12.49. This warm butter cake is topped with fresh pineapple and is often ignited at the table with a rum glaze. The Flaming Pineapple Butter Cake costs $10.99 in Fayetteville, and $12.49 in New York City.
Bahama Breeze Desserts Prices by Year
PriceListo maintains yearly logs of Bahama Breeze desserts prices. Historical records show that standard desserts remained under $8.00 for several years before the brand moved toward larger, labor-intensive cakes and pies. Annual price updates now reflect the rising energy costs for daily in-house baking and the logistical requirements of maintaining fresh tropical fruit supplies. The table below lists the chronological price changes for Bahama Breeze desserts.
| Year (Index) | Name | Price |
|---|---|---|
| 2021 | Rebecca’s Key Lime Pie | $7.99 |
| 2021 | Chocolate Island | $8.49 |
| 2021 | Flaming Pineapple Butter Cake | $8.99 |
| 2022 | Rebecca’s Key Lime Pie | $8.39 |
| 2022 | Chocolate Island | $8.89 |
| 2022 | Flaming Pineapple Butter Cake | $9.39 |
| 2023 | Rebecca’s Key Lime Pie | $8.79 |
| 2023 | Chocolate Island | $9.29 |
| 2023 | Flaming Pineapple Butter Cake | $9.79 |
| 2024 | Rebecca’s Key Lime Pie | $9.19 |
| 2024 | Chocolate Island | $9.69 |
| 2024 | Flaming Pineapple Butter Cake | $10.19 |
| 2025 | Rebecca’s Key Lime Pie | $9.59 |
| 2025 | Chocolate Island | $10.09 |
| 2025 | Flaming Pineapple Butter Cake | $10.59 |
| 2026 | Rebecca’s Key Lime Pie | $9.99 |
| 2026 | Chocolate Island | $10.49 |
| 2026 | Flaming Pineapple Butter Cake | $10.99 |
The price factors that affect Bahama Breeze desserts prices include dairy and sugar market volatility, manual prep labor, and utility rates. These are discussed in detail below.
- Dairy and Sugar Volatility: Wholesale price shifts for heavy cream, butter, and refined sugar directly impact the retail rate for cakes and pies.
- Manual Prep Labor: Staff members spend significant time hand-making key lime pie fillings and hand-decorating chocolate mousse cakes daily.
- Logistics of Freshness: Delivering non-frozen pineapples and fresh citrus fruit frequently to every restaurant adds supply chain overhead.
- Utility Rates: Operating high-heat commercial ovens throughout a full business day results in high electricity and gas expenses for baking.
The average price for a Bahama Breeze dessert item was $6.50 to $8.50 in 2015. This range applied to items like the Bananas Supreme and Rum Cake. Data confirms that the baseline for a premium dessert plate moved past the nine-dollar mark after 2021 as the brand handled rising energy and food distribution costs. Recent trackers show the current national average for a signature island dessert has reached $10.50.
The Bahama Breeze desserts prices for the Chocolate Island and Flaming Pineapple Butter Cake have shown the most substantial growth. Statistical records confirm that premium cakes moved from an average price under $8.50 in 2017 to current costs exceeding $11.00 in some markets. This trend follows the rising wholesale costs of chocolate and the higher logistics needed for frequent tropical fruit deliveries.
Rebecca’s Key Lime Pie remained the most stable among Bahama Breeze desserts prices over the last decade. This selection uses staple ingredients with lower market volatility compared to high-end chocolate or seasonal fruit-heavy cakes. High-volume procurement of key lime juice allows the brand to keep price points steadier than other alternatives.
Why do Bahama Breeze prices vary by location?
Bahama Breeze desserts prices vary from one location to another because individual restaurant owners set rates. A Bahama Breeze restaurant in a high-density urban center faces rent and utility burdens that are higher than those of a suburban standalone location. The table below shows the costs of these sweets across various US markets.
Bahama Breeze's Prices — Atlanta, GA
Current average prices as of August 2026
| Item | Price (USD) |
|---|---|
| Rebecca’s Key Lime Pie | $9.99 |
| Chocolate Island | $10.49 |
| Flaming Pineapple Butter Cake | $10.99 |
Bahama Breeze's Prices — Orlando, FL
Current average prices as of August 2026
| Item | Price (USD) |
|---|---|
| Rebecca’s Key Lime Pie | $9.99 |
| Chocolate Island | $10.49 |
| Flaming Pineapple Butter Cake | $10.99 |
Bahama Breeze's Prices — Fayetteville, NC
Current average prices as of August 2026
| Item | Price (USD) |
|---|---|
| Rebecca’s Key Lime Pie | $9.99 |
| Chocolate Island | $10.49 |
| Flaming Pineapple Butter Cake | $10.99 |
Bahama Breeze's Prices — Houston, TX
Current average prices as of August 2026
| Item | Price (USD) |
|---|---|
| Rebecca’s Key Lime Pie | $10.49 |
| Chocolate Island | $10.99 |
| Flaming Pineapple Butter Cake | $11.49 |
Bahama Breeze's Prices — Los Angeles, CA
Current average prices as of August 2026
| Item | Price (USD) |
|---|---|
| Rebecca’s Key Lime Pie | $10.99 |
| Chocolate Island | $11.49 |
| Flaming Pineapple Butter Cake | $11.99 |
Bahama Breeze's Prices — New York City, NY
Current average prices as of August 2026
| Item | Price (USD) |
|---|---|
| Rebecca’s Key Lime Pie | $11.49 |
| Chocolate Island | $11.99 |
| Flaming Pineapple Butter Cake | $12.49 |
Yes, Bahama Breeze desserts prices adjust every year to manage the national pressure of inflation on the food industry. Official reports show price updates handle the higher costs of fuel for distribution and the energy needed for constant kitchen operation. These adjustments ensure the brand can continue to provide quality ingredients like real butter and fresh fruit without lowering standards.
Wholesale procurement rates for dairy and fresh produce directly impact Bahama Breeze desserts prices. A 10 percent increase in the price of heavy cream leads to a measurable jump in the cost of chocolate mousse and ice cream items. Sourcing costs for tropical pineapples and specialty key lime juice also dictate the final retail price for island desserts.
Yes, promos like the rewards program provide lower Bahama Breeze desserts prices for guests. Members of the rewards program frequently receive digital coupons for a free dessert on their birthday or a percentage off a dessert with the purchase of a full-price entree. These offers are managed through the mobile application to encourage frequent visits.
Yes, choosing a Bahama Breeze dessert as part of a promotional pairing or a Caribbean Bundle results in a lower effective cost than standalone desserts. Bundling desserts with mains provides guests with the best overall value for a multi-course meal.
Delivery platforms such as UberEats, DoorDash, and Grubhub apply built-in markups of 15 to 25 percent on every item to cover platform fees and driver logistics. A Key Lime Pie priced at $9.99 in-store is listed for $12.50 on a mobile app before service fees are added. This increases the final bill for the customer compared to the standard Bahama Breeze desserts prices found inside the restaurant.
What are the Other Menus of Bahama Breeze?
Bahama Breeze menus available across its restaurants in Florida, Georgia, and North and South Carolina are listed below.
- Bahama Breeze 0% Alcohol. 100% Fun. Prices
- Bahama Breeze Appetizers Prices
- Bahama Breeze Boozy Beats Prices
- Bahama Breeze Caribbean Bundles Prices
- Bahama Breeze Chicken Prices
- Bahama Breeze Cocktails Prices
- Bahama Breeze Drafts Prices
- Bahama Breeze Fresh Hits Prices
- Bahama Breeze Frozen Tracks Prices
- Bahama Breeze Gluten Sensitive Menu Prices
- Bahama Breeze Handhelds Prices
- Bahama Breeze Hard Seltzers Prices
- Bahama Breeze It's Margarita Time Prices
- Bahama Breeze Juicy Jams Prices
- Bahama Breeze Kids Meal Prices
- Bahama Breeze Lemonades & Teas Prices
- Bahama Breeze Lunch Combos Prices
- Bahama Breeze Salads Prices
- Bahama Breeze Seafood Prices
- Bahama Breeze Sides Prices
- Bahama Breeze Sodas & Water Prices
- Bahama Breeze Soup and Salad Prices
- Bahama Breeze Steak & Pork Prices
- Bahama Breeze Vegetarian Menu Prices