1. PriceListo
  2. Big M's Pizzeria Menu with Prices 2026

Big M's Pizzeria Menu with Prices 2026

⭐ 0.00/5 (0) reviews
USD prices currency
$15.94 Average Item Price
You are viewing prices confirmed by PriceListo at the following Big M's Pizzeria location:
1313 N First Ave, Evansville, IN, 47710, US 1(812) 434-6909
This business is featured in 10 Best Evansville Restaurants

On the Big M's Pizzeria menu, the most expensive item is 20'' Extra Large Crustbuster Pizza, which costs $39.16. The cheapest item on the menu is Drinks, which costs $0.75. The average price of all items on the menu is currently $15.94.

View the Big M's Pizzeria menu prices list below for the most accurate and up-to-date menu prices. We aggregate data from one or more Big M's Pizzeria locations in our database to create the most accurate list of Big M's Pizzeria prices. Don't rely on outdated price data. We update our database frequently to ensure that the prices are as accurate as possible.

Big M's Pizzeria was a family-owned and operated restaurant located in Evansville, Indiana. The business specialized in thin and crispy crust pizzas, homemade lasagna, and hearty sandwiches. Patrons frequently enjoyed the Pepperoni Lover's Pizza, the Stromboli, and the Taco Pizza. The Lunch Combo served as the most economical meal on the Big M's Pizzeria, priced at $4.63, whereas the Big M-F'er extra-large pizza ranked as the highest-priced single food item at $35.60. The restaurant is permanently closed.

The owners of Big M's Pizzeria built a loyal following by using quality ingredients and preparing items like salads with scratch-made dressings. The setting provided a casual, rock-music-filled atmosphere where locals gathered for weekend meals. A welcoming interior and friendly staff kept the dining room busy with residents looking for delicious, locally made food.

The restaurant provided dine-in, takeout, and home delivery services directly to customers. Diners utilized the comfortable indoor seating for casual meals or ordered food to be brought to the far north side of the city. Online feedback consistently praised the great pizza and sweet delivery drivers, resulting in a rating of 3.9 on Google.

Big M's Pizzeria Menu

What is Big M's Pizzeria Most Famous For?

Big M's Pizzeria was most famous for serving high-quality, thin and crispy crust pizzas and homemade lasagna in a casual, family-owned setting. The business stood apart from competitors by delivering to the far north side of Evansville and cultivating a fun environment with great rock music playing in the background. The shop honored traditional pizza-making methods, ensuring every pie featured excellent ingredients and a perfectly baked crust before ultimately closing its doors in November 2018 due to health code violations.


What are the Most Popular Signature Items on the Big M's Pizzeria Menu?

The most popular signature items on the Big M's Pizzeria menu were the Pepperoni Lover's Pizza, the Stromboli, and the homemade Lasagna. A selection of additional fan-favorite dishes from the restaurant is detailed below.

  • Pepperoni Lover's Pizza: A thin and crispy crust came loaded with a generous portion of pepperoni and melted cheese.
  • Stromboli: A classic baked sandwich featured savory meats and cheeses folded into fresh dough.
  • Lasagna: This homemade pasta dish offered layers of rich meat sauce, cheese, and perfectly cooked noodles.
  • Taco Pizza: A creative pie combined traditional taco ingredients like seasoned beef, lettuce, and tomatoes over a crispy crust.
  • Big M Skins: Potato skins came loaded with either bacon and cheese or a Texas BBQ mix of stromboli meat, sauce, and cheese.


What Drinks and Beverages Can You Have at Big M's Pizzeria?

The drinks and beverages at Big M's Pizzeria included a nostalgic selection of canned and two-liter sodas. The drink menu featured selections curated to pair with the savory, cheesy notes of the pizzas and sandwiches. A collection of available beverages follows.

  • Ski: A regional favorite, this citrus soda provided a sweet and highly caffeinated kick.
  • Big Red: A classic red cream soda offered a unique, sweet flavor profile.
  • RC Cola: A traditional cola served as a standard pairing for hearty Italian-American meals.
  • A&W Root Beer: A rich, creamy root beer provided a caffeine-free refreshment.
  • Diet Rite: A zero-calorie cola option catered to guests seeking a lighter drink.


What is the Cheapest Meal on the Big M's Pizzeria Menu?

The cheapest meal on the Big M's Pizzeria menu was the Lunch Combo, which cost $4.63. This affordable option allowed guests to choose between a five-inch one-topping pizza, a five-inch sandwich, or an eight-ounce portion of lasagna, all served with a choice of side and a drink.

What is the Most Expensive Meal on the Big M's Pizzeria Menu?

The most expensive meal on the Big M's Pizzeria menu was the Big M-F'er, which cost $35.60. This massive, extra-large twenty-inch pizza included every available topping and pepperoncinis, creating a colossal feast meant for sharing.

What are the Healthiest Meals on the Big M's Pizzeria Menu?

The healthiest meals on the Big M's Pizzeria menu were the Salad with Dressing, the Veggie Lover's Pizza, and the Naked Wings. The Salad provided a fresh mix of greens that could be paired with lighter dressing options. The Veggie Lover's Pizza offered a nutrient-dense alternative to meat-heavy pies, featuring bell peppers, onions, mushrooms, tomatoes, and olives. The Naked Wings supplied a high-protein, low-carbohydrate choice prepared without heavy breading.

How Often Does Big M's Pizzeria Offer Special Offers?

Big M's Pizzeria offered special offers daily through its dedicated Lunch and Dinner Combos. Guests secured discounted rates on smaller portions of pizzas, sandwiches, and lasagna paired with sides and drinks. The shop also featured ongoing large-scale promotions, such as buying a sixteen-inch specialty pizza to receive a free one-topping pizza, or a combo deal featuring two sandwiches, two pounds of wings, and a two-liter soda for $25.54.

Does Big M's Pizzeria Have a Loyalty Program?

No, Big M's Pizzeria did not have a loyalty program. The family-owned business focused on providing high-quality ingredients, friendly service, and value-driven daily specials to encourage repeat visits from the local community.

Does Big M's Pizzeria Offer Family Meal Bundles?

Yes, Big M's Pizzeria offered family meal bundles designed to feed large groups. The menu featured a special where purchasing a sixteen-inch Specialty Pizza included a free sixteen-inch one-topping pizza for $24.95. Another bundle provided two twelve-inch sandwiches, two pounds of wings, and a two-liter drink for $25.54, making it easy to feed a crowd.

Does Big M's Pizzeria Offer Vegan Options?

Yes, the vegan options on the Big M's Pizzeria menu included the basic side salad and the Veggie Lover's Pizza when ordered without cheese. Guests customized their pizzas with a variety of plant-based toppings such as bell peppers, onions, mushrooms, tomatoes, black olives, green olives, jalapenos, and banana peppers.

Does Big M's Pizzeria Offer Gluten-Free Options?

Yes, the gluten-free options on the Big M's Pizzeria menu included the Naked Wings and the Salad with Dressing. The Naked Wings were prepared without breading, offering a safe protein choice. Diners with severe sensitivities needed to exercise caution, as the kitchen handled wheat-based dough daily, increasing the risk of cross-contamination.

Is Big M's Pizzeria Pet-Friendly?

No, Big M's Pizzeria was not pet-friendly. The restaurant did not permit dogs inside the dining area, requiring guests to leave their pets at home while enjoying their meals.

Can You Order Ala Carte in Big M's Pizzeria?

Yes, the ala carte options on the Big M's Pizzeria menu consisted of various appetizers and extras, with prices ranging from $0.92 to $6.56. Diners selected single portions of Bread Sticks for $4.71, Garlic Cheese Bread for $5.64, or basic Nachos for $2.48. Extra dipping sauces like Marinara or Nacho Cheese were also available for $0.92 each.

What Other Services Does Big M's Pizzeria Offer?

Big M's Pizzeria offered dedicated delivery services that reached the far north side of Evansville, a convenience highly appreciated by local residents. The shop also provided a fun, music-filled atmosphere where the owner frequently played great rock music for dine-in guests.

Does Big M's Pizzeria Offer Catering Services?

Yes, Big M's Pizzeria offered catering services for events. The business supplied large quantities of its thin-crust pizzas, homemade lasagna, and party-sized salads to feed guests at off-site gatherings and community celebrations.

Can You Rent Big M's Pizzeria for Private Occasions?

No, Big M's Pizzeria could not be rented for private occasions. The shop did not feature private dining rooms, focusing instead on standard dine-in, takeout, and delivery operations for the general public.

Does Big M's Pizzeria Do House Delivery?

Yes. Big M's Pizzeria supported delivery directly to local neighborhoods. Customers who wanted delivery from the restaurant ordered by calling the shop directly, and drivers were known for arriving early with hot food.

How are the Reviews for Customer Experience at Big M's Pizzeria?

Customer reviews for Big M's Pizzeria were generally positive, reflecting a strong local following and resulting in a rating of 3.9 on Google. Patrons frequently commended the friendly staff and the owner, who kept the atmosphere lively with great rock music. Diners consistently praised the quality ingredients used in the pizzas, homemade lasagna, and salads. Reviewers also pointed out the reliable and fast delivery service, noting that drivers often arrived earlier than expected with piping hot food.

Who are the Top Competitors of Big M's Pizzeria?

The competitors of Big M's Pizzeria are Turoni's Pizzery & Brewery, Roca Bar, and Kipplee's. A list of alternatives follows.

  • Turoni's Pizzery & Brewery: A famous Evansville institution, Turoni's Pizzery & Brewery is known for its house-brewed beers and signature thin-crust pizzas.
  • Roca Bar: A historic local favorite, Roca Bar serves up classic tavern-style pizzas and hearty Italian-American sandwiches.
  • Kipplee's: A lively sports bar environment, Kipplee's offers popular thin-crust pizzas and a wide selection of appetizers.
  • Lombardi's New York Pizza: A traditional pizzeria, Lombardi's Pizza focuses on authentic, hand-tossed New York-style slices and whole pies.
Category Restaurants
Big M's Pizzeria prices

Popular Restaurants