1. PriceListo
  2. Carmella's Cafe Menu with Prices 2026 (United States)

Carmella's Cafe Menu with Prices 2026 (United States)

⭐ 0.00/5 (0) reviews
USD prices currency
$11.20 Average Item Price

Updated on:

You are viewing prices confirmed by PriceListo at the following Carmella's Cafe location:
2934 Sw Blvd, Kansas City, MO, 64108, US
This business is featured in 10 Best Italian Restaurants in Utica, NY

On the Carmella's Cafe menu, the most expensive item is Crossroads Country Breakfast, which costs $26.50. The cheapest item on the menu is Sausage gravy, which costs $2.30. The average price of all items on the menu is currently $11.20.

View the Carmella's Cafe menu prices list below for the most accurate and up-to-date menu prices. We aggregate data from 2 Carmella's Cafe locations in our database to create the most accurate list of Carmella's Cafe prices. Don't rely on outdated price data. We update our database frequently to ensure that the prices are as accurate as possible.

Carmella's Cafe is a family-owned Italian restaurant in Youngstown, OH. Opened in 2011 as a tribute to the family's matriarch, Carmella's Cafe serves dishes made from homestyle recipes that have been passed down through generations. The menu features hearty dishes like the Homemade Meat Lasagna, Chicken Carmella, and Shrimp & Scallop Mornay. Appetizers begin at $9.00, while dinner entrees start at $28.00.

Inside, the restaurant has a warm and nicely decorated interior, reflecting an old-fashioned Italian family charm. A full bar offers a selection of Italian and Californian wines to complement the meals. The restaurant also provides extensive catering services for off-site events, with a wide selection of its cuisine available for planning.

Carmella's Cafe can accommodate some dietary needs, offering gluten-free entrees and vegan options through its "Build Your Own Pasta" selection. Takeout is available for the full menu, and delivery is managed through third-party platforms. The restaurant also has a covered patio for outdoor dining. Patrons often highlight the delicious food, huge portions, and attentive service, earning the restaurant ratings of 4.3 stars on TripAdvisor and 4.1 stars on Yelp.

Carmella's Cafe Menu

What is Carmella's Cafe Most Famous For?

Carmella's Cafe is most famous for serving hearty homestyle Italian food based on personal family recipes passed down through generations. The restaurant in Youngstown, Ohio, first opened in 2011 as a tribute to the family's grandmother, Carmella. It is known for its warm, family-friendly atmosphere, generous portions, and classic dishes that provide a comforting and authentic dining experience.


What are the Most Popular Signature Items on the Carmella's Cafe Menu?

The most popular signature items on the Carmella's Cafe menu include the Fried Provolone Cheese, the Broiled or Fried Haddock, and the Chicken Carmella. Below are details on some of the popular dishes at Carmella's Cafe.

  • Fried Provolone Cheese: Lightly breaded provolone cheese is served with a homemade marinara sauce for $10.00.
  • Broiled or Fried Haddock: Haddock is either broiled with lemon-infused olive oil or fried with a light Panko breading, priced at $22.00.
  • Chicken Carmella: Grilled chicken is topped with Italian greens, mushrooms, roasted red peppers, and plum tomato, then finished with Romano and mozzarella cheeses for $14.00.
  • Homemade Meat Lasagna: This classic dish is layered with fresh ricotta cheese, meats, and four blended cheeses, then baked with house sauce for $20.00.
  • Italian Greens: Escarole is sautéed in olive oil with fresh garlic and banana peppers, served with Italian bread for $13.00.
  • Stuffed Banana Peppers: Banana peppers are stuffed with homemade sausage and mozzarella cheese, then topped with house sauce for $12.00.


What Drinks and Beverages Can You Have at Carmella's Cafe?

The drinks and beverages available at Carmella's Cafe include a full bar selection with a focus on wine. The wine list features bottles from Italy and California, designed to pair with the rich pasta and meat dishes. A list of available drink choices from Carmella's Cafe follows.

  • Italian Wine: The wine list includes selections like Castello Di Abola Chianti Classico from Tuscany.
  • Californian Wine: A robust selection of wines from California is available, with notable bottles such as Louis Martini Cabernet Sauvignon and Kendall Jackson Chardonnay.
  • Other Wines: The list is rounded out with wines from other regions, including Trapiche Oak Cask Malbec from Argentina and Jacobs Creek Moscato from Australia.
  • Cocktails: A full bar is available to prepare a range of classic cocktails.
  • Non-Alcoholic Beverages: The menu includes a standard assortment of soft drinks.


What is the Cheapest Meal on the Carmella's Cafe Menu?

The cheapest meal on the Carmella's Cafe menu is the Fried Egg and Bologna Sandwich, priced at $11.00. This sandwich features a thick slice of fried bologna topped with a fried egg and provolone cheese and includes a choice of a side like french fries or pasta.

What is the Most Expensive Meal on the Carmella's Cafe Menu?

The most expensive meal on the Carmella's Cafe menu is the Lobster Mac and Cheese, a daily special which costs $30.00. This dish is made with cavatappi pasta and tender lobster tossed in a rich garlic parmesan cream sauce and topped with melted Italian cheeses.

What are the Healthiest Meals on the Carmella's Cafe Menu?

The healthiest meals on the Carmella's Cafe menu include the Fresh Grilled Salmon and the Carmella Mediterranean Salad. The Fresh Grilled Salmon is grilled and served atop sautéed vegetables for $25.00. The Carmella Mediterranean Salad combines mixed Italian greens with artichoke hearts, tomatoes, olives, roasted peppers, and goat cheese for $14.00.

How Often Does Carmella's Cafe Offer Special Offers?

Carmella's Cafe offers daily specials, including a Soup of the Day and unique entrees like Lobster Mac and Cheese or Pierogi. The restaurant is also known for its Beer Battered Haddock special on Fridays, for which reservations are recommended.

Does Carmella's Cafe Have a Loyalty Program?

No, Carmella's Cafe does not have a loyalty program. The restaurant focuses on its food quality, friendly service, and family atmosphere to bring guests back.

Does Carmella's Cafe Offer Family Meal Bundles?

No, Carmella's Cafe does not offer family meal bundles. The menu is structured for individual dishes, but the catering service is the primary option for large-format meals.

Does Carmella's Cafe Offer Vegan Options?

Yes, Carmella's Cafe offers some vegan options. A vegan meal can be created from the Build Your Own Pasta Dish by selecting a pasta like spaghetti with the Marinara or Aglio Olio sauce and adding vegetable toppings. A salad with a vinaigrette dressing is another vegan choice.

Does Carmella's Cafe Offer Gluten-Free Options?

Yes, Carmella's Cafe has gluten-free options available. The gluten-free items at Carmella's Cafe include the salads, such as the Grilled Chicken or Steak Salad without croutons. Entrees like the Choice Cut Sirloin or Fresh Grilled Salmon are also gluten-free choices.

Is Carmella's Cafe Pet-Friendly?

No, Carmella's Cafe is not pet-friendly. While the restaurant has a covered patio, it is not designated for pets.

Can You Order Ala Carte in Carmella's Cafe?

Yes, orders at Carmella's Cafe are à la carte. The entire menu is structured for guests to select dishes individually, from appetizers like Kagoots for $11.00 to entrees such as Veal Parmesan for $24.00.

What Other Services Does Carmella's Cafe Offer?

Other services Carmella's Cafe offers include a full bar, a covered outdoor patio, and takeout. The patio provides a space for open-air dining, and the full menu is available for takeout orders, which customers note stay hot and fresh.

Does Carmella's Cafe Offer Catering Services?

Yes, Carmella's Cafe does offer catering services. The restaurant provides a wide selection of its Italian cuisine for off-site events, from backyard parties to boardroom meetings, and works with customers to plan the menu.

Can You Rent Carmella's Cafe for Private Occasions?

No, Carmella's Cafe does not offer rentals for private occasions. The restaurant is not a large space, but it does accept reservations and can accommodate larger groups in its main dining area with advance planning.

Does Carmella's Cafe Do House Delivery?

Yes, Carmella's Cafe provides house delivery through third-party platforms. Customers can place orders for delivery through services like DoorDash.

How are the Reviews for Customer Experience at Carmella's Cafe?

Reviews for the customer experience at Carmella's Cafe are very positive. Customers state the food is excellent and delicious, with the homemade lasagna and haddock dishes earning specific praise. The portions are consistently described as huge, providing great value. The service is highlighted as very attentive and pleasant, with patient and helpful waitstaff. The atmosphere is cozy and family-friendly, making it a go-to spot that customers are sure to repeat. The restaurant holds a 4.3-star rating on TripAdvisor and a 4.1-star rating on Yelp.

Who are the Top Competitors of Carmella's Cafe?

The top competitors for Carmella's Cafe are other family-owned Italian restaurants in the Youngstown, Ohio area, as well as major national Italian restaurant chains. These establishments compete for diners seeking a traditional Italian-American meal.

  • Aqua Pazzo: A key local competitor in Boardman, Aqua Pazzo is known for its modern, upscale approach to Italian cuisine, featuring a lively atmosphere and an extensive wine list.
  • Michael Alberini's Restaurant and Wine Shop: Located in Boardman, Michael Alberini's is another competitor that offers a fine dining experience with a diverse menu that includes Italian-inspired dishes and a large wine selection.
  • Olive Garden Italian Kitchen: As a major national chain, Olive Garden is a direct competitor known for its family-friendly atmosphere, unlimited breadsticks, and consistent menu of Italian-American favorites.
  • BRAVO! Italian Kitchen: BRAVO! is a national chain that offers classic Italian dishes in a more upscale-casual setting, often located in lifestyle centers.
Category Restaurants
Carmella's Cafe prices

Popular Restaurants