1. PriceListo
  2. Caruso's Italian Restaurant Menu with Prices 2026 (United States)

Caruso's Italian Restaurant Menu with Prices 2026 (United States)

⭐ 0.00/5 (0) reviews
USD prices currency
$10.25 Average Item Price

Updated on:

You are viewing prices confirmed by PriceListo at the following Caruso's Italian Restaurant location:
2036 Main St, Lititz, PA, 17543, US 1(717) 598-7149
This business is featured in 10 Best Italian Restaurants in Santa Barbara

On the Caruso's Italian Restaurant menu, the most expensive item is Full House Pizza (Large ), which costs $20.49. The cheapest item on the menu is Chicken Wings (Bleu Cheese), which costs $0.75. The average price of all items on the menu is currently $10.25.

View the Caruso's Italian Restaurant menu prices list below for the most accurate and up-to-date menu prices. We aggregate data from 3 Caruso's Italian Restaurant locations in our database to create the most accurate list of Caruso's Italian Restaurant prices. Don't rely on outdated price data. We update our database frequently to ensure that the prices are as accurate as possible.

Caruso's Italian Restaurant is a family-owned eatery in Lititz, PA serving authentic Italian cuisine. Signature offerings on Caruso’s menu include Tortellini Ala Pietro, a Mediterranean Salad, and the specialty Full House Pizza. The most affordable item is a pizza slice for $2.49, while the highest-priced selection is the Large Full House Pizza at $23.49. Meal prices range from $2.49 to $23.49. This dining spot also offers daily lunch specials and weekend rib specials.

Caruso's Italian Restaurant has been a fixture in the Lititz community since 1982. The restaurant maintains a reputation for its traditional recipes, generous portion sizes, and a casual, welcoming atmosphere. The cooks are renowned for their hand-tossed New York-style pizzas and freshly baked sub bread, which have made it a local favorite for over four decades.

This Italian restaurant offers dine-in, takeout, and house delivery services. The venue is a pet-friendly spot with two outdoor tables. The staff also provides catering services, featuring party-sized trays of lasagna and sub platters for various gatherings. Customers consider Caruso's Italian Restaurant a reliable choice for consistent food quality and friendly service, rating it 4.6 on Google.

Caruso's Italian Restaurant Menu

What is Caruso's Italian Restaurant Most Famous For?

Caruso's Italian Restaurant is celebrated for its authentic, hand-tossed New York-style pizza and its four-decade legacy in the Lititz community. The restaurant has built a strong reputation for its freshly baked sub bread, often praised by patrons as the best they've ever had, and its signature homemade tomato sauce. The chefs adhere to traditional family recipes, offering generous portions that provide excellent value. This commitment to classic flavors, combined with a welcoming and casual environment, has established Caruso's as a cherished local staple for family dinners and satisfying meals.


What are the Most Popular Signature Items on the Caruso's Italian Restaurant Menu?

Mediterranean Salad, Tortellini Ala Pietro, and Wings represent the most popular signature items on the Caruso's Italian Restaurant menu. A list of bestselling menu items from Caruso's Italian Restaurant follows.

  • Mediterranean Salad: A blend of romaine lettuce, onions, tomatoes, feta cheese, sweet peppers, and black olives starting at $11.99.
  • Tortellini Ala Pietro: A signature pasta dish featuring cheese-filled tortellini in a specialized house sauce for $18.99.
  • Wings: Fried chicken wings available in various sauces including Hot, Mild, Garlic Parm, and Mango Habanero starting at $17.98.
  • Full House Pizza: A specialty pie loaded with sausage, pepperoni, hamburger, ham, mushrooms, green peppers, onions, and extra cheese starting at $15.99.
  • Homemade Lasagna: Layers of pasta, seasoned beef, and ricotta cheese baked with marinara and mozzarella for $14.99.

What Drinks and Beverages Can You Have at Caruso's Italian Restaurant?

Fountain sodas, iced tea, and freshly brewed coffee are the primary drinks and beverages available at Caruso's Italian Restaurant. This establishment maintains a family-friendly, non-alcoholic beverage selection to accompany heavy pasta and pizza meals. Cold bottled water and various Pepsi products serve as standard options for dine-in and takeout. A list of beverage choices follows.

  • Fountain Sodas: Carbonated Pepsi products served in various sizes.
  • Iced Tea: Sweetened and unsweetened varieties available for a refreshing contrast to spicy wings.
  • Coffee and Hot Tea: Standard hot drinks provided throughout the day.
  • Bottled Water: Individual bottles available for $2.00 or less.

What is the Cheapest Meal on the Caruso's Italian Restaurant Menu?

The cheapest meal on the Caruso's Italian Restaurant menu is a single Pizza Slice, which costs $2.49 in Lititz, PA. This individual portion features hand-tossed dough topped with house-made tomato sauce and mozzarella cheese. Quick service makes this a frequent choice for a light lunch or snack. Diners frequently add a side of small fries for $2.99 to create a larger meal.

What is the Most Expensive Meal on the Caruso's Italian Restaurant Menu?

The most expensive meal on the Caruso's Italian Restaurant menu is the Large Full House Pizza, which costs $23.49 in Lititz, PA. This 16-inch specialty pizza features a combination of sausage, pepperoni, hamburger, ham, mushrooms, green peppers, onions, and extra cheese. High-quality toppings and a substantial size justify the premium price compared to standard cheese pizzas. Individual entrees like the Seafood Ala Casa or Grilled Chicken Primavera also represent higher price points at $19.99 and $20.99.

What are the Healthiest Meals on the Caruso's Italian Restaurant Menu?

The healthiest meals on the Caruso's Italian Restaurant menu are the Mediterranean Salad, Pasta Primavera, and the Grilled Chicken Salad. Mediterranean Salad provides a nutrient-dense mix of romaine, tomatoes, sweet peppers, and feta cheese for $11.99. Pasta Primavera features a selection of fresh vegetables sautéed in a light sauce, offering a lower-calorie alternative to meat-heavy dishes for $18.99. Grilled Chicken Salad serves as a lean protein source atop a bed of fresh greens and vegetables for $11.99. Requesting oil and vinegar dressing on the side helps maintain a low-fat profile.

How Often Does Caruso's Italian Restaurant Offer Special Offers?

Caruso's Italian Restaurant offers daily lunch specials from 11:00 AM to 3:00 PM featuring discounted pizza, sub, or pasta combinations. Weekend rib specials include a half rack for $13.99 or a full rack for $18.99, served with a side salad, garlic bread, and French fries. Super Bowl deals provide value through wing and pizza bundles, such as two large cheese pizzas and two dozen wings for $54.99. Seasonal promotions highlight holiday-themed menu items.

Does Caruso's Italian Restaurant Have a Loyalty Program?

No, Caruso's Italian Restaurant does not have a loyalty program. Patrons pay standard menu prices for all visits without a digital points system or rewards application. The business relies on consistent quality and a forty-year reputation to encourage repeat visits.

Does Caruso's Italian Restaurant Offer Family Meal Bundles?

Yes, Caruso's Italian Restaurant offers family meal bundles including pizza and wing combinations. One popular deal features two large cheese pizzas for a set price. Another option includes one large cheese pizza and one dozen wings for $27.99. These bundles provide a cost-effective way to feed groups of four or more people during gatherings or sports events.

Does Caruso's Italian Restaurant Offer Vegan Options?

Yes, the vegan options on the Caruso's Italian Restaurant menu are the Tossed Salad, Pasta Marinara, and Veggie Pizza without cheese. Tossed Salad features a mix of iceberg and romaine lettuce with tomatoes and onions for $8.99. Pasta Marinara utilizes a meatless tomato sauce free from dairy products for $11.99. Veggie Pizza ordered without mozzarella provides a plant-based meal loaded with onions, mushrooms, green peppers, and black olives. Diners should specify the omission of butter and cheese when placing an order.

Does Caruso's Italian Restaurant Offer Gluten-Free Options?

Yes, the gluten-free options on the Caruso's Italian Restaurant menu include gluten-free pizza crusts and cauliflower crusts. A 12-inch Gluten-Free Pizza costs $12.99 and allows guests with wheat sensitivities to enjoy traditional toppings. Cauliflower Pizza Crust serves as an alternative base for $13.99. Fresh salads without croutons provide additional naturally gluten-free choices.

Is Caruso's Italian Restaurant Pet-Friendly?

Yes, Caruso's Italian Restaurant is a pet-friendly eatery at the two outdoor tables. These seating options allow guests to dine with pets in an open-air environment. Indoor seating remains restricted to human guests and service animals.

Can You Order Ala Carte in Caruso's Italian Restaurant?

Yes, the ala carte options on the Caruso's Italian Restaurant menu are side orders of meatballs, sausage, and garlic bread with prices ranging from $3.99 to $6.99. A side of two meatballs or two sausages costs $6.99. Garlic bread is available for $3.99, with an option to add mozzarella for $6.49. These items allow for the customization of any main pasta dish or salad.

What Other Services Does Caruso's Italian Restaurant Offer?

Caruso's Italian Restaurant offers takeout, online ordering, and gift card sales. A dedicated counter facilitates quick pickup for phone and web orders. Gift cards are available in various denominations for use at the Lititz location.

Does Caruso's Italian Restaurant Offer Catering Services?

Yes, Caruso's Italian Restaurant offers catering services such as party-sized trays of lasagna for $60.99 and baked ziti for $50.99. Sub platters featuring Italian, turkey, or ham and cheese sandwiches serve eight people for $28.99 to $32.99. Wings are available in bulk, with a tray serving sixteen people for $61.99. These options suit corporate lunches, family reunions, and large parties.

Can You Rent Caruso's Italian Restaurant for Private Occasions?

No, Caruso's Italian Restaurant does not offer private room rentals for occasions. The dining area remains open to the public during all operating hours. Staff members assist large groups by putting tables together to accommodate big parties in the main seating section.

Does Caruso's Italian Restaurant Do House Delivery?

Yes, Caruso's Italian Restaurant does house delivery through several third-party platforms. Grubhub provides contact-free delivery for local orders. DoorDash allows customers to schedule a delivery in advance. Seamless offers delivery for a $7.49 fee plus a 15% service fee capped at $14.00.

How Are the Reviews for Customer Experience at Caruso's Italian Restaurant?

Customer reviews for Caruso's Italian Restaurant frequently highlight the excellent service and the quality of the sub bread. Diners on Google provide a 4.6-star rating, praising the consistent food quality and the thin-crust pizza. One reviewer noted that the bread used for grinders is the best they have ever had. Feedback also mentions the friendly staff and the clean, plentiful seating inside the establishment.

Who Are the Top Competitors of Caruso's Italian Restaurant?

Roma Pizza and Nino's NY Style Pizza are primary competitors of Caruso's Italian Restaurant in the Lititz area. A list of competitors follows.

  • Roma Pizza: Roma Pizza offers a selection of specialty pizzas, subs, and Italian dinners.
  • Nino's NY Style Pizza: Nino's NY Style Pizza is known for thin-crust pizza and a selection of hot and cold sandwiches.
  • Lititz Pizza Company: Lititz Pizza Company provides gourmet pizzas and wings in a modern environment.
  • Pizza Hut: Pizza Hut provides a casual dining experience with a menu of classic pan pizzas, wings, and pasta.
Category Restaurants
Caruso's Italian Restaurant prices

Popular Restaurants