1. PriceListo
  2. Deerhead Pizza Tavern Menu with Prices 2026

Deerhead Pizza Tavern Menu with Prices 2026

⭐ 0.00/5 (0) reviews
USD prices currency
$6.85 Average Item Price
You are viewing prices confirmed by PriceListo at the following Deerhead Pizza Tavern location:
222 E Columbia St, Evansville, IN, 47711, US 1(812) 425-2515
This business is featured in 10 Best Evansville Restaurants

On the Deerhead Pizza Tavern menu, the most expensive item is Supreme Deerhead Double Decker Cheese Pizza, which costs $17.25. The cheapest item on the menu is Creamy Coleslaw, which costs $1.95. The average price of all items on the menu is currently $6.85.

View the Deerhead Pizza Tavern menu prices list below for the most accurate and up-to-date menu prices. We aggregate data from one or more Deerhead Pizza Tavern locations in our database to create the most accurate list of Deerhead Pizza Tavern prices. Don't rely on outdated price data. We update our database frequently to ensure that the prices are as accurate as possible.

Deerhead Pizza Tavern is a popular restaurant in Evansville, Indiana, that serves traditional American tavern fare. Customer favorites on the menu include the double-decker pizza, house stromboli, and Greek salad. Main entrees range from $4.95 to $25.00. The Strom is the most affordable meal at $4.95, while the Big Buck Classic Double Decker Pizza is the most expensive at $14.40 and up. A meal for one person at Deerhead Pizza Tavern costs between $10.00 and $20.00.

The family-owned business has operated for over 40 years, with the current building constructed in 1867. The establishment has functioned as a tavern for decades, becoming a local landmark in Evansville. The brand has built a reputation for sincere hospitality, an old-school spirit, and a sense of community. 

Deerhead Pizza Tavern offers dine-in, takeout, and house delivery services. The venue provides professional catering for events up to 100 guests and accommodates group reservations. Deerhead Pizza Tavern is a pet-friendly spot that welcomes dogs on the outdoor patio. Customers consider the restaurant a top choice for hearty comfort food and a relaxed environment, rating the establishment 4.5 on Google, 4.4 on TripAdvisor, and 4.3 on Yelp.

Deerhead Pizza Tavern Menu

What is Deerhead Pizza Tavern Most Famous For?

Deerhead Pizza Tavern is celebrated in Evansville, Indiana for the signature double-decker pizza, which features two layers of thin crust filled with sauce, cheese, and toppings. The establishment is recognized as a historic local landmark, operating in a building that dates back to the 1860s. Live music performances, ranging from blues to jazz, create a lively atmosphere that distinguishes the tavern from other area eateries. The combination of generous portions, friendly service, and a long-standing presence in the community makes the venue a standout destination in Evansville.


What are the Most Popular Signature Items on the Deerhead Pizza Tavern Menu?

The most popular signature items on the Deerhead Pizza Tavern menu are the double-decker pizza, house stromboli, and Greek salad. Details about these popular dishes are provided below.

  • Double-Decker Pizza: Two layers of thin crust packed with sauce, cheese, and a choice of toppings, creating a heavy, multi-layered meal.
  • House Stromboli: A classic preparation featuring pork sausage on a hoagie bun with Italian sauce, onions, green peppers, and mozzarella cheese.
  • Greek Salad: A fresh mix of lettuce, onions, green peppers, tomatoes, and black olives topped with feta cheese and homemade Greek dressing.
  • Meaty Blues Pizza: A gourmet thin-crust pizza topped with mozzarella cheese, Italian sausage, beef, pepperoni, bacon, and ham.
  • Jazzy Pepper Paradise Pizza: A gourmet thin-crust pizza featuring mozzarella cheese, red peppers, yellow peppers, banana peppers, jalapeno peppers, pepperoncini, bacon, and ham.


What Drinks and Beverages Can You Have at Deerhead Pizza Tavern?

The drinks and beverages at Deerhead Pizza Tavern include alcoholic options, caffeinated drinks, and soft beverages. These beverages provide a refreshing complement to the tavern fare such as pizzas, strombolis, and sandwiches. A list of beverage options follows.

  • Alcoholic Beverages: The bar serves ice-cold fishbowls and pitchers of beer, providing a classic tavern experience for adult guests.
  • Caffeinated Drinks: Freshly brewed gourmet coffee and sweet or unsweetened iced tea are available for diners seeking a traditional refreshment.
  • Soft Beverages: Fountain options include Pepsi, Dr. Pepper, Mountain Dew, Starry, Mug Root Beer, and pink lemonade to pair with meals.


What is the Cheapest Meal on the Deerhead Pizza Tavern Menu?

The Strom is the cheapest meal on the Deerhead Pizza Tavern menu, costing $4.95. This sandwich features pork sausage on a hoagie bun with Italian sauce, onions, green peppers, and mozzarella cheese. Each order includes a pepperoncini, a kosher spear pickle, and a side of chips.

What is the Most Expensive Meal on the Deerhead Pizza Tavern Menu?

The Big Buck Classic Double Decker Pizza is the most expensive meal on the Deerhead Pizza Tavern menu, with prices starting at $14.40 for a small and increasing for larger sizes. This substantial dish consists of two layers of thin crust filled with mozzarella cheese, Italian sausage, beef, pepperoni, ham, onions, mushrooms, green peppers, and black olives. Preparation involves stacking the ingredients to create a dense, multi-layered pie that serves as the tavern's signature premium offering.

What are the Healthiest Meals on the Deerhead Pizza Tavern Menu?

The healthiest meals at Deerhead Pizza Tavern are the Greek salad, house salad, and thin-crust vegetable pizza. The Greek salad features fresh lettuce, onions, green peppers, tomatoes, black olives, and feta cheese, providing a nutrient-dense option. The house salad offers a lighter starter with fresh vegetables and a choice of dressing. The thin-crust vegetable pizza allows diners to enjoy fresh toppings like mushrooms, onions, and green peppers on a lighter crust without the extra dough of the double-decker style.

How Often Does Deerhead Pizza Tavern Offer Special Offers?

Deerhead Pizza Tavern provides special offers through daily lunch specials and military discounts. Lunch specials run Monday through Saturday from 11:00 AM to 3:00 PM, featuring an 8-inch pizza with up to three toppings for $7.95. Military members and first responders receive a discount on orders as a gesture of appreciation for service. Seasonal promotions, such as the annual Mardi Gras event, introduce temporary menu items like Seafood Gumbo for $10.95, Shrimp Jambalaya for $12.45, a Po'boy for $12.95, and a Combo Plate for $15.95.

Does Deerhead Pizza Tavern Have a Loyalty Program?

No, Deerhead Pizza Tavern does not maintain an independent loyalty program or rewards system for customers. Diners can sign up through the official website to receive notifications regarding upcoming deals and events.

Does Deerhead Pizza Tavern Offer Family Meal Bundles?

No, Deerhead Pizza Tavern does not offer family meal bundles but provides large specialty pizzas and generous portions that are suitable for sharing. Families order a variety of items such as double-decker pizzas and appetizer samplers to accommodate groups. The menu includes a dedicated kiddie section for guests aged 10 and under, featuring chicken bites and grilled cheese for $7.25.

Does Deerhead Pizza Tavern Offer Vegan Options?

Yes, the vegan options on the Deerhead Pizza Tavern menu include the thin-crust vegetable pizza and house salad when ordered without cheese. The kitchen staff accommodates dietary requests by omitting cheese or meat toppings from pizzas and salads. The black bean veggie burger serves as a plant-based alternative to traditional beef patties. 

Does Deerhead Pizza Tavern Offer Gluten-Free Options?

Yes, the gluten-free options on the Deerhead Pizza Tavern menu include salads and specific appetizers prepared without wheat ingredients. The kitchen staff works to accommodate diners with gluten sensitivities by offering alternatives like the Greek salad or house salad. 

Is Deerhead Pizza Tavern Pet-Friendly?

Yes, Deerhead Pizza Tavern is pet-friendly at the Evansville, IN location. The establishment welcomes dogs on the outdoor patio area, where pets must remain on a leash and not disturb other guests. 

Can You Order Ala Carte in Deerhead Pizza Tavern?

Yes, the ala carte options on the Deerhead Pizza Tavern menu are French fries, breadsticks, and individual salads, with prices ranging from $2.35 to $5.95. These items allow for the customization of main entrees like the Pork Tenderloin, Catfish Sandwich, and Cheeseburger. Customers add these sides to pizzas or sandwiches to create a complete dining experience. Individual pizza toppings and extra sauces are also available for separate purchase.

What Other Services Does Deerhead Pizza Tavern Offer?

Deerhead Pizza Tavern provides takeout, dine-in, and delivery services. The establishment features a drive-thru window for convenient pickup of phone or online orders. Curbside delivery is available upon request for those preferring to remain in vehicles. The tavern also sells alcohol with food orders for off-site consumption.

Does Deerhead Pizza Tavern Offer Catering Services?

Yes, Deerhead Pizza Tavern provides catering services for various events and gatherings of up to 100 guests. The menu allows for large-format orders of pizzas, strombolis, and appetizers to accommodate groups. Customers coordinate directly with the staff to plan orders and schedule pickups or deliveries for off-site events.

Can You Rent Deerhead Pizza Tavern for Private Occasions?

No, Deerhead Pizza Tavern does not offer private room rentals for exclusive events. The tavern operates as a public dining space, though large groups are accommodated through reservations which can be booked in advance via the official website. 

Does Deerhead Pizza Tavern Do House Delivery?

Yes, Deerhead Pizza Tavern delivers food directly to customers' homes using external delivery apps like Grubhub and UberEats. Order availability and delivery fees depend entirely on how close the delivery address is to the Columbia Street restaurant location.

How Are the Reviews for Customer Experience at Deerhead Pizza Tavern?

Customer reviews for Deerhead Pizza Tavern are consistently positive, resulting in a 4.5-star rating on Google, a 4.4-star rating on TripAdvisor, and a 4.3-star rating on Yelp. Patrons highlight the unique double-decker pizza and the high quality of the house strombolis. Feedback mentions the fast service and the welcoming nature of the long-term staff, some of whom have worked at the tavern for over 30 years. The outdoor covered patio is a favored spot for enjoying live music and cold beverages. Local residents describe the establishment as a beloved gem with a historic atmosphere that remains consistent over decades.

Who Are the Top Competitors of Deerhead Pizza Tavern?

The top competitors of Deerhead Pizza Tavern are Turoni's Pizzery and Brewery, Roca Bar and Pizza, and Azzip Pizza. The list below details several alternatives in the Evansville area.

  • Turoni's Pizzery and Brewery:  Turoni's Pizzery and Brewery is known for thin, crispy crust and house-brewed beers.
  • Roca Bar and Pizza: A long-standing Evansville landmark, Roca Bar and Pizza, specializes in thin-crust pies and signature Italian salads.
  • Azzip Pizza: This fast-casual chain, Azzip Pizza, allows diners to create custom pizzas with a variety of unique toppings.
  • Pangea Kitchen:  Pangea Kitchen offers Neapolitan-style pizzas and Thai-inspired dishes in a modern setting.
  • Pizza Hut:  Pizza Hut serves a variety of pan pizzas, wings, and pasta dishes with extensive delivery options.


What Does the Menu of Deerhead Pizza Tavern Restaurant Look Like?

The menu at Deerhead Pizza Tavern functions as a tribute to traditional Midwestern tavern culture, prioritizing heavy, multi-layered pizzas and classic hoagie-style sandwiches. A focus on the proprietary double-decker technique defines the pizza selection, offering a substantial alternative to standard thin-crust styles. Sandwich options lean toward marinated pork and seasoned beef, utilizing toasted kaiser rolls and hoagie buns to provide a sturdy base for generous fillings. Appetizers and sides consist of breaded and fried vegetables or cheese, emphasizing a casual, social dining experience. Regional influences appear through the inclusion of Cajun red beans and rice and German bologna, adding variety to the core pizza and sandwich offerings.

Category Restaurants
Deerhead Pizza Tavern prices

Popular Restaurants