1. PriceListo
  2. Iaria's Italian Restaurant Menu Prices

Iaria's Italian Restaurant Menu with Prices 2026 (United States)

⭐ 0.00/5 (0) reviews
USD prices currency
$10.17 Average Item Price

Updated on:

You are viewing prices confirmed by PriceListo at the following Iaria's Italian Restaurant location:
317 S College Ave, Indianapolis, IN, 46202, US
This business is featured in 10 Best Italian Restaurants in Indianapolis

On the Iaria's Italian Restaurant menu, the most expensive item is Fettuccini with Our Original Clam Sauce, which costs $20.99. The cheapest item on the menu is Cup of Sauce, which costs $1.25. The average price of all items on the menu is currently $10.17.

View the Iaria's Italian Restaurant menu prices list below for the most accurate and up-to-date menu prices. We aggregate data from one or more Iaria's Italian Restaurant locations in our database to create the most accurate list of Iaria's Italian Restaurant prices. Don't rely on outdated price data. We update our database frequently to ensure that the prices are as accurate as possible.

Iaria's Italian Restaurant is a popular Italian restaurant in Indianapolis, Indiana specializing in homestyle Italian dishes, house-made sauces, and a century-old family legacy. Bestsellers include the Baked Lasagne, Spaghetti with Meatballs, and Fettuccini Alfredo. The lowest priced item on the menu is the Traditional A la Carte Pasta for $11.99, and the most expensive item is the Seafood Pasta for $24.99. The average cost per person dining is from $15.00 to $30.00. Daily specials feature rotating drink deals and weekly dinner features at Iaria's Italian Restaurant.

Pete and Antonia Iaria founded the business in 1913 as a neighborhood grocery store. The business changed into a full-service restaurant in the 1930s and has remained in the same family for four generations on the exact same corner. The founders attracted a loyal following by serving original old-world recipes passed down through generations. Iaria's Italian Restaurant is celebrated for its vintage aesthetic, homey atmosphere, and fourth-generation original family recipes.

This traditional Italian restaurant offers dine-in and carry-out services. Catering packages and private room rentals are available for groups of 15 or more. The venue welcomes pets at limited outdoor seating tables. Customers consider the spot a reliable choice for milestone celebrations, rating Iaria's Italian Restaurant 4.5 on Google.

Iaria's Italian Restaurant Menu

What is Iaria's Italian Restaurant Most Famous For?

Iaria's Italian Restaurant is famous for being one of the oldest family-run spots in Indianapolis, serving the community from the same corner since 1913. Pete and Antonia Iaria first opened a grocery store before the owners changed the shop into a tavern and full-service restaurant during the 1930s. This change happened because the family gave away more free spaghetti to neighbors than grocery stock sold. 

Iaria's menu features original old-world recipes passed down through four generations, with a focus on house-made red sauces and traditional Sicilian spice blends. A nostalgic atmosphere with a retro neon sign and vintage decor makes the location a staple for milestone birthdays and anniversaries.


What are the Most Popular Signature Items on the Iaria's Italian Restaurant Menu?

The most popular signature items on the Iaria's Italian Restaurant menu include the Baked Lasagne, Spaghetti with Meatballs, and Fettuccini Alfredo. Check out these other top-selling dishes on the menu.

  • Baked Lasagne: A multi-layered pasta dish made with ricotta cheese, seasoned ground beef, and house tomato sauce.
  • Spaghetti with Meatballs: Large homemade meatballs served over pasta with signature red sauce.
  • Fettuccini Alfredo: A creamy pasta choice available with or without chicken.
  • Chicken Drogato: Blackened chicken tossed with penne and peppers in a spicy Cajun cream sauce.
  • Mate’s Mozzarella: Fresh mozzarella coated in house breadcrumbs and sautéed in olive oil.
  • Tiramisu: A traditional dessert featuring coffee-soaked ladyfingers layered with mascarpone cheese.

What Drinks and Beverages Can You Have at Iaria's Italian Restaurant?

The drinks and beverages customers can have at Iaria's Italian Restaurant are the Lord Street cocktail, the Sorrento, and the Pesco. The Lord Street cocktail pairs well with the savory Mimo’s Maximus pizza, while the Sorrento complements the rich flavors of the Baked Lasagne. The Pesco offers a fruity option that matches the fresh taste of the Caprese salad. Here are other beverage options to enjoy.

  • Specialty Cocktails: Lord Street (Rosé Prosecco, St. Germain, Italicus), Sorrento (Pallini Limoncello, Prosecco), Pesco (Pallini Peachello, Prosecco), Aperol Spritz, and Little Italy (Michter's Rye Bourbon infused with vanilla bean and cherries).
  • Wine & Beer: A list of red and white options available by the glass or bottle, alongside rotating draft beers, local craft options, and imported Italian bottles like Peroni.
  • Non-Alcoholic Beverages: San Pellegrino sparkling mineral water, fountain drinks including Pepsi and Dr. Pepper, lemonade, and freshly brewed chilled iced tea.
  • Hot Coffee Drinks: Freshly brewed coffee, lattes, cappuccinos, and bold espresso shots.

What is the Cheapest Meal on the Iaria's Italian Restaurant Menu?

The cheapest meal on the Iaria's Italian Restaurant menu is the Traditional A la Carte Pasta, which costs $11.99. This option includes a choice of spaghetti, capellini, or penne pasta served with house sauce. Diners have the option to upgrade to a full dinner for a small additional fee.

What is the Most Expensive Meal on the Iaria's Italian Restaurant Menu?

The most expensive meal on the Iaria's Italian Restaurant menu is the Seafood Pasta, which costs $24.99. This dish consists of a mix of shrimp, scallops, and mussels served over fettuccini in a light basil cream sauce.

What are the Healthiest Meals on the Iaria's Italian Restaurant Menu?

The healthiest meals on the Iaria's Italian Restaurant menu are Chicken Piccata, Minestrone Soup, and Seasonal Sautéed Vegetables. Chicken Piccata provides a lean protein source sautéed in a light white wine and lemon butter sauce. Minestrone Soup offers a nutrient-dense option made with a house vegetable and bean recipe. Seasonal Sautéed Vegetables serve as a fiber-rich alternative to traditional pasta sides. Garden salads ordered with oil and vinegar also provide a low-calorie starter.

How Often Does Iaria's Italian Restaurant Offer Special Offers?

Iaria's Italian Restaurant offers daily drink specials and weekly dinner features. Drink deals include $3.50 well drinks on specific days and half-priced wine bottles every Tuesday night. Participation in city-wide events like Devour Indy provides curated multi-course meal bundles for two people.

Does Iaria's Italian Restaurant Have a Loyalty Program?

No, Iaria's Italian Restaurant does not have an official loyalty program. The business operates on traditional service models rather than digital points systems. Patrons who order via third-party platforms might earn rewards through those specific delivery services.

Does Iaria's Italian Restaurant Offer Family Meal Bundles?

Yes, Iaria's Italian Restaurant offers family-style options through large catering pans and event platters. Family Style Platters cost $37.00 per person and allow groups to share three sides and two main entrees. Scalable catering pans for salads and pastas provide bulk options for off-site meals. Pairs dining in the restaurant can also find shared multi-course packages during local dining festivals.

Does Iaria's Italian Restaurant Offer Vegan Options?

Yes, Iaria's Italian Restaurant offers vegan options such as Minestrone Soup and pasta with house marinara. Minestrone Soup is prepared using a plant-based recipe. House marinara sauce contains no meat or dairy products. Diners order pasta dishes like spaghetti or penne with marinara and a side of steamed Asparagus Italiano for a plant-based meal.

Does Iaria's Italian Restaurant Offer Gluten-Free Options?

Yes, Iaria's Italian Restaurant offers gluten-free options including alternative pasta and pizza crusts. Diners can request gluten-free noodles for any traditional pasta dinner. Thin-crust pizzas are prepared using an alternative gluten-free base upon request. House garden salads and the Deluxe Antipasto provide wheat-free starters when ordered without croutons or bread.

Is Iaria's Italian Restaurant Pet-Friendly?

Yes, Iaria's Italian Restaurant is pet-friendly in the outdoor seating area. Dogs are permitted at the limited number of tables located outside the building. Pets are prohibited from entering the indoor dining rooms.

Can You Order Ala Carte in Iaria's Italian Restaurant?

Yes, Iaria's Italian Restaurant offers an ala carte menu structure. Every entrée is available as a standalone item or as a full dinner. Choosing the ala carte option reduces the price by $3.00 and excludes the soup or salad side.

What Other Services Does Iaria's Italian Restaurant Offer?

Iaria's Italian Restaurant offers full-service catering and private event hosting. The venue provides a private parking lot free of charge for all customers. Online ordering supports both takeout and delivery requests. The restaurant also functions as a stop for local city tours.

Does Iaria's Italian Restaurant Offer Catering Services?

Yes, Iaria's Italian Restaurant provides professional catering services tailored to fit unique event requirements. Headcounts starting at a minimum of 15 people are accommodated. Service levels span from standard delivery to full-service catering, which covers complete setup. Menus feature signature family-style platters and large-format pans of pasta and salad.

Can You Rent Iaria's Italian Restaurant for Private Occasions?

Yes, Iaria's Italian Restaurant is available for private rentals on Sundays and Mondays. The entire venue can be reserved for large parties when the restaurant is closed to the general public. Closing the bar side for a private group is also possible for an additional fee. Private events utilize family-style platters, featuring classic entrees like baked lasagna or chicken parmesan passed around the tables.

Does Iaria's Italian Restaurant Do House Delivery?

Yes, Iaria's Italian Restaurant provides house delivery for takeout orders. Customers who want delivery can order through services like Grubhub, Uber Eats, and Total Takeout. Diners also arrange for direct takeout and curbside pickup from the downtown location.

How are the Reviews for Customer Experience at Iaria's Italian Restaurant?

Diners frequently mention the efficient service and nostalgic atmosphere at Iaria's Italian Restaurant. Patrons often talk about the family-run feel and the warm reception from staff members. The 1950s-style decor with checkered tablecloths provides a unique backdrop for meals. Food quality earns praise for generous portions and traditional flavors found in the garlic cheese bread and veal dishes.

Who are the Top Competitors of Iaria's Italian Restaurant?

The top competitors of Iaria's Italian Restaurant include Iozzo's Garden of Italy and Nesso Italian restaurant. Here is a list of more competitors.

  • Iozzo's Garden of Italy: Iozzo's Garden of Italy is a direct local competitor featuring classic family recipes in a garden setting.
  • Nesso Italian restaurant: Nesso Italian restaurant is a modern alternative focusing on coastal Italian dishes.
  • Mama Carolla's: Mama Carolla's is a neighborhood restaurant serving classic Italian comfort food inside a home.
  • Capri Italian Restaurant: Capri Italian Restaurant is a cozy dinner spot known for large portions and Italian pastas.
  • Magoo's Pizza: Magoo's Pizza is a local favorite for casual Italian dining and specialty pizzas.
Category Restaurants
Iaria's Italian Restaurant prices

Popular Restaurants