1. PriceListo
  2. Italian Prime At Salvatore's Menu Prices

Italian Prime At Salvatore's Menu with Prices 2026 (United States)

⭐ 0.00/5 (0) reviews
USD prices currency
$39.74 Average Item Price

Updated on:

You are viewing prices confirmed by PriceListo at the following Italian Prime At Salvatore's location:
6461 Transit Rd, Depew, NY, 14043, US
This business is featured in 10 Best Italian Restaurants in Buffalo

On the Italian Prime At Salvatore's menu, the most expensive item is Half Rack of Lamb with an 8oz Lobster Tail, which costs $114.95. The cheapest item on the menu is Sausage Loaf, which costs $15.00. The average price of all items on the menu is currently $39.74.

View the Italian Prime At Salvatore's menu prices list below for the most accurate and up-to-date menu prices. We aggregate data from one or more Italian Prime At Salvatore's locations in our database to create the most accurate list of Italian Prime At Salvatore's prices. Don't rely on outdated price data. We update our database frequently to ensure that the prices are as accurate as possible.

Italian Prime at Salvatore's is an award-winning Italian fine dining restaurant in Depew, New York. It is known for prime steak cuts, contemporary Italian cuisine, and an award-winning global wine list. The bestselling signature items on the menu include Sliced Prime Rib, Local Angus Filet Mignon, and 100-Layer Lasagna. The lowest priced item on the menu is the Sliced Prime Rib priced at $36.00, while the most expensive menu item is the 14oz Prime Strip Steak for $63.00. The average cost per person dining at Italian Prime at Salvatore's ranges from $35.00 to $70.00.

Italian Prime at Salvatore's was established in 1967 on Transit Road by four generations of the Salvatore family, continuing hospitality traditions originating in 1938 Buffalo. Rebranded as Buffalo's only Italian steakhouse, the restaurant showcases globally sourced Australian Broadleaf Wagyu beef, Creekstone Farms steaks, and stuffed banana peppers. The achievements gained by Italian Prime at Salvatore's include the DiRONA award and the Wine Spectator Award of Excellence with over 500 global wine offerings. Connected boutique lodging options at The Delavan Hotel & Spa and The Garden Place Hotel provide overnight getaway packages.

This Italian restaurant offers dine-in, takeout, and delivery services through DoorDash, Grubhub, and Uber Eats. Promotions feature $12 Tuesday Dinners, $15 Burger and Peroni Thursdays, half-price Wine Wednesdays under $99, and Filet Friday specials for $29.95. Indoor dining rules prohibit pets, permitting access strictly to certified service animals. Diners consistently recommend Italian Prime at Salvatore's, awarding an average 4.3 rating across major review platforms.

Italian Prime At Salvatore's Menu

What is Italian Prime at Salvatore's Most Famous For?

Italian Prime at Salvatore’s is most famous as Buffalo’s only contemporary Italian steakhouse, combining premium steaks and fresh seafood with classic Italian cuisine. Formerly called Salvatore’s Italian Gardens, the restaurant rebranded to highlight a menu largely focused on steaks, including Australian Broadleaf Wagyu and beef from Creekstone Farms. 

Other popular features include an award-winning wine list with more than 500 global bottles, the grand Chandelier Bar with cocktails and weekend music, and a Salvatore family hospitality legacy dating to 1938. Signature dishes include prime rib, filet mignon, stuffed banana peppers, Chicken Marsala, lasagna, Shrimp and Scallop Risotto, and tableside Bananas Foster. The awards received by the restaurant include the DiRONA award and Wine Spectator Award of Excellence.


What are the Most Popular Signature Items on the Italian Prime at Salvatore's Menu?

The most popular signature items on the menu of Italian Prime at Salvatore's are Sliced Prime Rib, Local Angus Filet Mignon, 100-Layer Lasagna, White Truffle Arancini, and Rack of Lamb. Here is a list of more top menu items available.

  • Sliced Prime Rib: Twelve ounces of tender slow-roasted prime rib served with horseradish cream sauce, broccolini, and garlic parmesan mashed potatoes.
  • Local Angus Filet Mignon: Tender local beef filet cooked to order, served alongside garlic mashed potatoes and prosciutto-wrapped asparagus.
  • 100-Layer Lasagna: Architectural layered pasta dish filled with bolognese, parmesan, asiago cheese, and smooth ricotta cream sauce.
  • White Truffle Arancini: Crispy risotto balls infused with rich, earthy white truffle cream flavor.
  • Rack of Lamb: Four-bone premium lamb rack grilled to order and served with rich sides.
  • Lobster Bisque: Creamy house-made soup packed with lobster meat and rich seasonings.

What Drinks and Beverages Can You Have at Italian Prime at Salvatore's?

The drinks and beverages available at Italian Prime at Salvatore's are Salvatore's Black Manhattan, Blood Orange Margarita, and Award-Winning Wines. Salvatore's Black Manhattan is Redemption Rye mixed with Carpano Vermouth and Amaro Montenegro, Blood Orange Margarita delivers Tequila blended with Grand Marnier and blood orange juice, and Award-Winning Wines offer over 500 global wine choices. Below is a list of more drinks available at the Italian restaurant.

  • Classic & Specialty Cocktails: Salvatore's Black Manhattan features Redemption Rye, together with Burnt Orange Old Fashioned, Happier Thoughts, and Pineapple Express.
  • Award-Winning Wine List: Global wine choices include over 500 international bottles recognized by Wine Spectator, with half-price bottles under $99 on Wine Wednesdays.
  • Beer & Spirits: Peroni draft beers include Italian lagers, as well as allocated bourbons, scotches, and high-end spirits at the Chandelier Bar.
  • Non-Alcoholic Beverages & Mocktails: Fig Et About It combines fig syrup, honey ginger syrup, lemon, and ginger ale, together with Sublime mocktails, seltzer, espresso, and coffee.

What is the Cheapest Meal on the Italian Prime at Salvatore's Menu?

The cheapest meal on Italian Prime at Salvatore's is the Sliced Prime Rib priced at $36.00. Sliced Prime Rib consists of twelve ounces of slow-roasted beef served with horseradish cream sauce, broccolini, and garlic parmesan mashed potatoes.

What is the Most Expensive Meal on the Italian Prime at Salvatore's Menu?

The most expensive meal on Italian Prime at Salvatore's is the 14oz Prime Strip Steak priced at $63.00. 14oz Prime Strip Steak features a fourteen-ounce prime strip steak served with loaded potato pancakes and prosciutto-wrapped asparagus.

What are the Healthiest Meals on the Italian Prime at Salvatore's Menu?

The healthiest meals on the Italian Prime at Salvatore's menu are Gulf Shrimp Cocktail, Charred Octopus, Local Angus Filet Mignon, and Cold Water Lobster Tail. Gulf Shrimp Cocktail provides chilled lean protein served with traditional cocktail sauce. Charred Octopus offers a nutrient-dense starter featuring fire-roasted tomatoes and yellow pepper vinaigrette. Local Angus Filet Mignon presents the leanest cut of red meat on the menu when paired with sautéed broccolini or asparagus. Cold Water Lobster Tail delivers steamed lean seafood protein served with basmati rice.

How Often Does Italian Prime at Salvatore's Offer Special Offers?

Italian Prime at Salvatore’s offers recurring weekly promotions along with seasonal and milestone deals throughout the year. Regular offers include a $12 Tuesday dinner special, half-price wine bottles under $99 on Wednesday, and a Thursday deal featuring a burger with Peroni for $15 or a snow crab leg dinner for $35.95. Filet Friday includes a seven-ounce prime filet with garlic mashed potatoes and bacon-wrapped asparagus for $29.95, plus $3 happy-hour drinks starting at 4:00 p.m. Birthday diners may also receive entrée credits from Sunday through Friday, while limited-time offers have included an $88 anniversary dinner for two.

Does Italian Prime at Salvatore's Have a Loyalty Program?

Yes, Italian Prime at Salvatore's offers a loyalty program accessed via the official mobile app. Registered mobile app users earn 1 point per $1 spent, with double points on app takeout orders and 25 bonus points upon joining. Stacking 50 points unlocks a $2.50 discount credit on future meals.

Does Italian Prime at Salvatore's Offer Family Meal Bundles?

No, Italian Prime at Salvatore’s does not offer standard family meal bundles. The fine dining steakhouse mainly serves separately priced steaks, prime rib, seafood, and pasta. Alternatives include an $88 Anniversary Dinner for Two in August, a $29.95 Friday filet dinner, and a birthday entrée credit worth up to $50 from Sunday through Friday. Customized group packages are available for private events with at least 15 people.

Does Italian Prime at Salvatore's Offer Vegan Options?

Yes, Italian Prime at Salvatore's offers vegan options on the menu such as The House Salad, Custom Chef Preparations, and Sautéed Broccolini. The House Salad features mixed greens, pickled red onions, and garbanzo beans tossed in red wine vinaigrette without gorgonzola. Custom Chef Preparations present tailored grain and vegetable dishes assembled by the culinary team upon advance request. Sautéed Broccolini offers fresh broccolini sautéed in olive oil without cheese or butter.

Does Italian Prime at Salvatore's Offer Gluten-Free Options?

Yes, Italian Prime at Salvatore's has gluten-free options on the menu that include Gluten-Free Bread, Gluten-Free Pasta Substitutions, Angus Filet, Surf & Turf, Flourless Chocolate Torte, and Caramel Bourbon Cheesecake. Gluten-Free Bread features separate gluten-free bread and rolls served with dedicated table accompaniments. Gluten-Free Pasta Substitutions allow swapping gluten-free pasta into signature pasta dishes. Angus Filet and Surf & Turf entrees present naturally gluten-free steaks and seafood. Flourless Chocolate Torte and Caramel Bourbon Cheesecake on a pecan crust supply gluten-free desserts.

Is Italian Prime at Salvatore's Pet-Friendly?

No, Italian Prime at Salvatore's is a fine-dining Italian steakhouse and does not allow pets inside the restaurant. Only certified service animals are legally permitted.

Can You Order Ala Carte in Italian Prime at Salvatore's?

Yes, Italian Prime at Salvatore’s offers an à la carte menu alongside prix-fixe dinners and promotional packages. Customers build a meal by ordering appetizers, salads, entrées, sides, and desserts separately. Examples include Calamari with Hot Peppers for $18, Gulf Shrimp Cocktail for $22, salads from $15 to $17, Brick Chicken Piccata for $39, and a nine-ounce Local Angus Filet for $62. Standalone desserts include tableside Bananas Foster and skillet cookies.

What Other Services Does Italian Prime at Salvatore's Offer?

Italian Prime at Salvatore’s is part of a larger hospitality campus offering lodging at The Delavan Hotel & Spa, beauty and wellness treatments, the Chandelier Bar, Perla Seafood Bistro, and an on-site gift shop. The nearby Garden Place Hotel also provides complimentary transportation to the restaurant. Three ballrooms accommodate private events for 10 to 600 people, with professional planning available for weddings, showers, galas, and corporate meetings. Full-service and drop-off catering are offered throughout Western New York. Additional services include weekend live music and dancing, takeout, and delivery through Grubhub and Seamless.

Does Italian Prime at Salvatore's Offer Catering Services?

Yes, Italian Prime at Salvatore’s provides on-site and off-site catering for weddings, corporate functions, family celebrations, and other events. Three on-site ballrooms accommodate 50 to 600 people and offer custom menus, beverage packages, carving stations, and late-night food stations. Full-service and drop-off catering are available throughout much of Western New York, while private dining rooms suit business dinners and family gatherings. Smaller events order charcuterie, cheese, and vegetable platters serving up to 10 people through ezCater.

Can You Rent Italian Prime at Salvatore's for Private Occasions?

Yes, Italian Prime at Salvatore’s offers private dining rooms for celebrations, family gatherings, and business dinners, generally using group packages for 15 or more people. Full restaurant buyouts are not normally available for small events during regular dining hours. The larger Salvatore’s Hospitality campus provides eight banquet and event spaces for 40 to 600 people, including the intimate Victorian Suites, the New Crystal Room, the Venetian Ballroom, and the 600-person Grand Bellamore Ballroom. 

Weddings, showers, milestone birthdays, corporate meetings, holiday parties, and galas include customized multi-course menus, beverage packages, and bottles from the award-winning wine list. Event planners are reached at (716) 635-9000, while restaurant group dining inquiries are made at (716) 683-7990.

Does Italian Prime at Salvatore's Do House Delivery?

Yes, Italian Prime at Salvatore's offers house delivery via third-party apps such as DoorDash, Grubhub, and Uber Eats.

How are the Reviews for Customer Experience at Italian Prime at Salvatore's?

Customer reviews are generally positive, averaging 4.2 to 4.4 stars. Diners appreciate the professional tuxedo-clad servers, attentive hospitality, craft cocktails, and grand atmosphere featuring dim lighting and star-like ceilings. Popular dishes include sausage bread, lobster bisque, prime rib, and Wagyu Tomahawk steak. The restaurant is regularly recommended for date nights and milestone celebrations. 

Common concerns include slower service during holidays or busy weekends, occasional steaks served at the wrong temperature, and prices that some diners consider high for the consistency of the food. Opinions on the lavish décor vary, while patron attire ranges from formal clothing to jeans and hoodies despite the upscale setting.

Who are the Top Competitors of Italian Prime at Salvatore's?

The top competitors of Italian Prime at Salvatore's are Giancarlo's Sicilian Steakhouse and Russell's Steaks, Locks & More. Check out below the other top competitors offering steakhouse and Italian cuisine.

  • Giancarlo's Sicilian Steakhouse: Giancarlo's Sicilian Steakhouse serves prime steaks, seafood, and Sicilian Italian dishes.
  • Russell's Steaks, Locks & More: Russell's Steaks, Locks & More offers luxury steakhouse dining, chops, and seafood.
  • The Italian Village: The Italian Village serves traditional red-sauce Italian pasta meals, pizza, and comfort food.
  • Black & Blue Steak & Crab: Black & Blue Steak & Crab offers high-end steakhouse dining, fresh crab, and seafood.
  • Biaggi's Ristorante Italiano: Biaggi's Ristorante Italiano serves large-portion Italian pasta dishes, seafood, and wood-fired pizzas with over 30 locations nationwide.
  • Fazoli's: Fazoli's offers fast-casual baked pastas, personal pizzas, and signature garlic breadsticks with over 200 locations across the country.
Category Restaurants
Italian Prime At Salvatore's prices

Popular Restaurants