1. PriceListo
  2. Old Town Mexican Cafe Menu with Prices 2026 (United States)

Old Town Mexican Cafe Menu with Prices 2026 (United States)

⭐ 0.00/5 (0) reviews
USD prices currency
$10.99 Average Item Price

Updated on:

You are viewing prices confirmed by PriceListo at the following Old Town Mexican Cafe location:
609 Duval St, Key West, FL, 33040, US 1(305) 440-9921
This business is featured in 10 Best Mexican Restaurants In Old Town San Diego

On the Old Town Mexican Cafe menu, the most expensive item is *LIME CILANTRO SNAPPER or SHRIMP, which costs $22.50. The cheapest item on the menu is ROAST FRESH CORN, which costs $5.75. The average price of all items on the menu is currently $10.99.

View the Old Town Mexican Cafe menu prices list below for the most accurate and up-to-date menu prices. We aggregate data from 4 Old Town Mexican Cafe locations in our database to create the most accurate list of Old Town Mexican Cafe prices. Don't rely on outdated price data. We update our database frequently to ensure that the prices are as accurate as possible.

Old Town Mexican Cafe is a landmark restaurant in San Diego known for its authentic Mexican cuisine and festive atmosphere. The most popular items on the Old Town Mexican cafe menu are the Famous Carnitas and the Molcajete. The cheapest meal is the Bean & Cheese Burrito, which costs $6.99 to $9.95, while the most expensive dish is the Carna Asada Dinner, which costs $20.99 to $24.95. The menu features a wide selection of traditional dishes, with combination plates starting at $16.99.

The restaurant was established in 1977 by Bob Estrada, John Dahlen, and Sonia Ortega which quickly became an institution in San Diego's historic Old Town. Its reputation was built on its commitment to traditional preparation methods, most notably the handmade tortillas made fresh daily in the front window by the "tortilla ladies." They also feature strolling mariachis, making this restaurant a must-visit destination for both locals and tourists for over 40 years. Old Town Mexican Cafe operates its single, iconic location in the heart of Old Town San Diego, California. 

Old Town Mexican Cafe Menu

What is Old Town Mexican Cafe Most Famous For?

Old Town Mexican Cafe is most famous for its authentic, handmade tortillas and its signature Carnitas plate. For decades, the restaurant has been a landmark in San Diego's Old Town, distinguished by the sight of "tortilla ladies" hand-patting thousands of fresh flour and corn tortillas daily in the front window. The use of traditional cooking methods and the festive atmosphere filled with strolling mariachis, makes it a must-visit restaurant in the city. Its long-standing reputation for consistent, traditional Mexican dishes has made it a staple for both locals and tourists since 1977.


What are the Most Popular Signature Items on the Old Town Mexican Cafe Menu?

The most popular signature items on the Old Town Mexican Cafe menu are the "Old Town Famous Carnitas" and the Molcajete. The menu features a wide array of authentic Mexican dishes, from classic combinations to house specialties. A list of popular signature items is provided below:

  • Carnitas Plate: The restaurant's most famous dish, featuring tender, slow-cooked pork served traditionally with cilantro, onions, avocado, beans, and fresh handmade tortillas.
  • Molcajete: A sizzling volcanic stone bowl filled with grilled shrimp, chicken breast, steak, chorizo, nopales (cactus), and grilled cheese, served with roasted tomatillo sauce and tortillas.
  • Old Town Pollo: A traditional Mexican-style rotisserie chicken served with rice, beans, and handmade tortillas.
  • Street Tacos: A choice of carne asada, pollo asado, carnitas, or adobada served on small corn tortillas.
  • Spicy Tequila Ribs: Tequila-braised pork ribs served in a patented fire sauce.
  • Pozole: A traditional Mexican soup with chunks of pork and hominy in a clear broth, served with cabbage, cilantro, onion, and lime.


What Drinks and Beverages Can You Have at Old Town Mexican Cafe?

At Old Town Mexican Cafe, customers can have a wide variety of margaritas and an extensive selection of tequilas. The bar is a central feature of the restaurant, offering drinks that pair well with the savory and spicy flavors of the food, such as the popular Carnitas Plate or Spicy Tequila Ribs. The complete list of drinks and beverages available on the Old Town Mexican Cafe menu is provided below:

  • Margaritas: A vast selection, including house margaritas, Cadillac margaritas, and specialty versions with various tequilas and fruit flavors like mango and watermelon.
  • Tequila: An extensive list with over 100 choices of Silver, Reposado, Añejo, and Mezcal varieties.
  • Mexican Beer: A selection of popular Mexican and domestic beers on draft and in bottles.
  • Cocktails: A full bar serving mixed drinks, including Mexican-inspired creations like the Mexican Candy shooter.
  • Non-Alcoholic Drinks: Traditional options like Agua de Jamaica (hibiscus tea) and soft drinks are available.


What is the Cheapest Meal on the Old Town Mexican Cafe Menu?

The cheapest meal on the Old Town Mexican Cafe menu is Bean & Cheese Burrito, which costs $6.99 to $9.95. The burrito comes with a flour tortilla with beans and cheese.

What is the Most Expensive Meal on the Old Town Mexican Cafe Menu?

The most expensive meal on the Old Town Mexican Cafe menu is the Carna Asada Dinner, which costs $20.99 to $24.95. A Carna Asada Dinner charbroiled steak is served with Pico de Gallo, guacamole, rice and beans, and a choice of tortillas.

What are the Healthiest Meals on the Old Town Mexican Cafe Menu?

The healthiest meals on the Old Town Mexican Cafe menu are the Pollo Asado Plate, the Ceviche Tostada, and the Ensalada de Pollo Asado. The Pollo Asado Plate features a grilled chicken breast, offering a lean protein source served with beans and rice. The Ceviche Tostada is a light option consisting of fresh fish marinated in lime juice with onions, tomatoes, and cilantro served on a crispy tortilla. The Ensalada de Pollo Asado is a large salad topped with grilled chicken, providing a balanced meal with fresh greens.

Does Old Town Mexican Cafe Serve Tacos or Tortilla Specials?

Yes, Old Town Mexican Cafe serves a variety of tacos, which are a highlight of the menu due to the restaurant's famous handmade tortillas. The menu features classic Old Town San Diego tacos, including street tacos with fillings like carne asada, pollo asado, carnitas, and adobada. The freshness of the tortillas, made in the front window of the cafe, is a key component that elevates the quality of all the taco dishes offered.


How Often Does Old Town Mexican Cafe Offer Special Offers?

Old Town Mexican Cafe offers special offers through its daily happy hour, which runs from 3:00 PM to 6:00 PM. During this time, customers can get $1 off draft beers, $5 well drinks, and $6 house margaritas and High Noon Tequila Seltzers. 

Is There a Happy Hour at Old Town Mexican Cafe?

Yes, there is a happy hour at Old Town Mexican Café which runs daily from 3:00 PM to 6:00 PM, featuring discounted prices on select drinks, including house margaritas and beers, as well as appetizers. Happy hour Old Town in San Diego offers $1 off all draft beers, $5 well drinks, and $6 house margaritas and High Noon Tequila Seltzers.

Does Old Town Mexican Cafe Have a Loyalty Program?

No, Old Town Mexican Cafe does not have a formal loyalty or rewards program for its customers.

Does Old Town Mexican Cafe Offer Family Meal Bundles?

Yes, Old Town Mexican Cafe offers family meal bundles with its Family Packs to Go menu. These meals are designed for takeout and typically include 32 ounces of rice, 32 ounces of beans, and a pound of chips with salsa. Options include a pack with 6 cheese enchiladas and 6 crispy tacos, a 10-pack of crispy tacos, or two pounds of chile verde or chile colorado, with most packs priced at $34.99. Larger combination packs and taquito platters are also available.

Does Old Town Mexican Cafe Offer Vegan Options?

Yes, Old Town Mexican Cafe offers vegan options. The vegan options on the menu include the Veggie Fajitas, which can be prepared without cheese or sour cream, and bean burritos made with whole beans instead of refried beans, which contain lard.

Does Old Town Mexican Cafe Offer Breakfast or Brunch?

Yes, Old Town Mexican Cafe offers an extensive breakfast and brunch menu served daily until noon. The menu features a wide array of traditional Mexican favorites that many consider the best breakfast in Old Town San Diego, including Chilaquiles, Huevos Rancheros, Machaca con Huevos, Menudo, and specialty omelettes. The cafe also serves American classics like pancakes and steak and eggs.

Does Old Town Mexican Cafe Offer Gluten-Free Options?

Yes, Old Town Mexican Cafe offers gluten-free options. The gluten-free options on the menu include corn tortillas, which are made fresh on-site, as well as many of the main dishes like the Carnitas Plate, Carne Asada, and most taco fillings when served on corn tortillas.

Is Old Town Mexican Cafe Pet-Friendly?

Yes, Old Town Mexican Cafe is pet-friendly. The restaurant has a large outdoor patio area where leashed dogs are welcome to join their owners.

Can You Order Ala Carte in Old Town Mexican Cafe?

Yes, customers can order à la carte at Old Town Mexican Cafe. The menu includes an extensive à la carte section with items such as single tacos, enchiladas, tamales, and tostadas. Sides like rice, beans, and guacamole can also be ordered individually.


What Other Services Does Old Town Mexican Cafe Offer?

Old Town Mexican Cafe operates as a full-service restaurant and bar. A central feature of the restaurant is its large cantina, which offers an extensive selection of tequilas and margaritas. The restaurant also provides catering services and has a retail space where customers can purchase branded merchandise and food items.

Does Old Town Mexican Cafe Offer Catering Services?

Yes, Old Town Mexican Cafe offers extensive catering services for events of all sizes ranging from $40 to $120. All catering services require a $50 deposit to hold the date, and an 18% gratuity plus 7.75% sales tax are added to the final bill. The catering menu includes traditional Mexican entrees, a full breakfast selection, an Oak Wood BBQ menu, and finger foods, with all main packages including sides like beans, rice, tortillas, and salsa. The cafe also provides party trays and specialized catering for events like Quinceaneras.

Can You Rent Old Town Mexican Cafe for Private Occasions?


Yes, Old Town Mexican Cafe hosts private occasions and banquets. Large and spacious dining areas accommodate a wide range of events, including Quinceaneras, wedding rehearsals, retirement parties, and company meetings. Based on group size, the restaurant provides different service styles, including off-the-menu ordering, a buffet, or a customized restricted menu. The cafe maintains a customer-friendly policy with no hidden fees for services like cake cutting or the use of extra tables for gifts.

Does Old Town Mexican Cafe Do House Delivery?

Yes, Old Town Mexican Cafe does house delivery through Doordash, Ubereats, and Postmates.

How are the Reviews for Customer Experience at Old Town Mexican Cafe?

Reviews for the customer experience at Old Town Mexican Cafe mostly praise the authentic food and the lively atmosphere. The ambiance is consistently described as festive and bustling, often with live mariachi music contributing to the energetic environment. The food is noted for its traditional flavors and generous portions. Service receives mixed feedback, with some finding it attentive while others note it can be slow during peak hours due to the high volume of customers. The overall perception is that of a classic, must-visit San Diego spot for a fun and authentic Mexican dining experience.

Who are the Top Competitors of Old Town Mexican Cafe?

The top competitors of Old Town Mexican Cafe are other long-standing and popular Mexican restaurants within Old Town San Diego, such as Cafe Coyote and Casa de Reyes. A list of competitors in the area is provided below.

  • Coyote Cafe: Coyote Cafe is a large and festive restaurant in Old Town known for its extensive menu, large patio, and lively atmosphere, also famous for its handmade tortillas.
  • Guadalajara: Guadalajara is known for its colorful, hacienda-style decor and extensive menu of traditional Mexican dishes, Casa Guadalajara is another popular dining destination in Old Town.
  • The Taco Stand: The Taco Stand is a highly popular, casual eatery with several locations that draws long lines for its authentic Tijuana-style street tacos and extensive salsa bar.
  • Tacos El Gordo: Tacos El Gordo is a famous Tijuana-based taqueria with a location in Chula Vista, renowned for its authentic street tacos, particularly the adobada carved directly from the trompo.
  • Oscar's Mexican Seafood: Oscar's Mexican Seafood is a local favorite with multiple locations, specializing in fresh seafood tacos, ceviche, and its signature Torta de Oscar.
  • La Puerta: La Puerta is a popular destination in the Gaslamp Quarter known for its extensive tequila selection, energetic bar scene, and late-night taco service.
Category Restaurants
Old Town Mexican Cafe prices

Popular Restaurants