1. PriceListo
  2. IL Toscano Ristorante Menu Prices

IL Toscano Ristorante Menu with Prices 2026 (United States)

⭐ 0.00/5 (0) reviews
USD prices currency
$24.48 Average Item Price

Updated on:

You are viewing prices confirmed by PriceListo at the following IL Toscano Ristorante location:
4205 235Th St, New York, NY, 11363, US 1(718) 631-0300
This business is featured in 10 Best Italian Restaurants in Queens

On the IL Toscano Ristorante menu, the most expensive item is Lobster Il Toscano, which costs $85.00. The cheapest item on the menu is Our Famous Napoleon, which costs $6.50. The average price of all items on the menu is currently $24.48.

View the IL Toscano Ristorante menu prices list below for the most accurate and up-to-date menu prices. We aggregate data from 3 IL Toscano Ristorante locations in our database to create the most accurate list of IL Toscano Ristorante prices. Don't rely on outdated price data. We update our database frequently to ensure that the prices are as accurate as possible.

IL Toscano Ristorante is an award-winning Italian restaurant in New York. This fine dining establishment is known for a signature menu item Lobster Toscano which was featured on the show "The Best Thing I Ever Ate!" Bestsellers on the menu include the Lobster Il Toscano, the Grilled Prime Ribeye Steak, and the Semolina Crusted Jumbo Shrimp. The lowest priced item on the menu is the Pollo Scarpariello for $33.00, and the most expensive item is the Lobster Il Toscano for $85.00. The average cost per person dining here is from $40.00 to $80.00. Daily specials feature custom prix fixe menus for specific annual holidays at IL Toscano Ristorante.

Mauro Privilegi founded the business in 1985. The founder utilized skills cultivated at an early age working on Italian cruise ships, learning that good cooking comes from using fresh, seasonal ingredients. Mauro worked at the Hotel Pierre in New York City for 19 years before opening the restaurant to live the American Dream. The son of the founder, Chef Alex Privilegi, graduated from the Culinary Institute of America and lived in Montefollonico, Italy, to sharpen culinary skills. Alex brings new ideas to the menu while maintaining the traditional Northern Italian style of cuisine at IL Toscano Ristorante.

Diners enjoy indoor meals, order takeout, or arrange delivery from the kitchen. Planners coordinate catering trays and reserve private banquet rooms for special events. Health department rules prohibit dogs and other animals from entering the dining area. Patrons rate the food highly, making the spot a solid choice for anniversary dinners and family meals at IL Toscano Ristorante.

IL Toscano Ristorante Menu

What is IL Toscano Ristorante Most Famous For?

IL Toscano Ristorante is most famous for the Lobster Toscano, which is made with a large fresh lobster cooked with garlic, lemon, white wine, butter, parsley, and hot pepper. The dish gained national attention after chef Michael Psilakis recommended the meal for the Cooking Channel show “The Best Thing I Ever Ate.” The Privilegi family has run the establishment since Mauro Privilegi opened the doors in 1985. Chef and co-owner Alex Privilegi now leads the kitchen and makes fresh pasta daily. The restaurant is also known for a Napoleon dessert and warm Northern Italian service. In 2024, the business received the Culinary Award from the Italian Language Foundation.


What are the Most Popular Signature Items on the IL Toscano Ristorante Menu?

The most popular signature items on the IL Toscano Ristorante menu include the Lobster Il Toscano, the Grilled Prime Ribeye Steak, the Semolina Crusted Jumbo Shrimp, and the Pollo Scarpariello. Here is a list of more bestselling menu items.

  • Lobster Il Toscano: A fresh shell lobster coated in cornstarch and cooked in garlic, oil, lemon, wine, and hot pepper, served with linguini or fresh spinach.
  • Grilled Prime Ribeye Steak: A premium cut of beef served with sautéed spinach, rosemary and Yukon gold potatoes, cipollini onions, and signature steak sauce.
  • Semolina Crusted Jumbo Shrimp: Pan-seared shrimp with a lemon and watercress risotto, crispy leeks, and sweet garlic vinaigrette.
  • Pollo Scarpariello: A whole baby chicken with Tuscan sausage, mushrooms, red bliss potatoes, and asparagus.
  • Lasagna Bolognese Pasta: A layered pasta dish filled with Bolognese sauce, béchamel, and Parmigiano cheese.
  • Linguini Vongole: Fresh little neck and chopped clams tossed with garlic, lemon, and white wine.
  • Famous Napoleon: A light and creamy layered pastry served with fresh berry coulis.

What Drinks and Beverages Can You Have at IL Toscano Ristorante?

Customers order drinks from a beverage menu that features specialty cocktails, sparkling champagne, and an extensive wine list. The Il Toscano's Boulevardier pairs well with the Grilled Prime Ribeye Steak. A Raspberry Limoncello Martini complements the flavors of the Semolina Crusted Jumbo Shrimp. The Spicy Margarita Cocktail offers a crisp option matching the fresh taste of the Lobster Il Toscano. Check out other beverage options on the menu.

  • Il Toscano's Boulevardier: Jim Beam Bourbon, aperitivo, and red vermouth.
  • Spicy Margarita Cocktail: Goza tequila, lime juice, Cointreau, and a jalapeño pepper salted rim.
  • Lychee Pear Martini: Pear Grey Goose, lychee juice, and St. Germain, garnished with lychee.
  • Makers Mark New Fashion: Maker's Mark, Bada Bing cherries, red vermouth, orange bitters, and soda.
  • Raspberry Limoncello Martini: Stoli Raspberry, limoncello, and a splash of cranberry.
  • Prosecco Monforte Brut: Available by the single glass for $14.00.
  • Veuve Clicquot Brut: French champagne priced at $115.00 per bottle.
  • Dom Perignon (2004): French vintage champagne priced at $275.00 per bottle.

What is the Cheapest Meal on the IL Toscano Ristorante Menu?

The cheapest meal on the IL Toscano Ristorante menu is the Pollo Scarpariello, which costs $33.00. The Pollo Scarpariello features a whole baby chicken served with Tuscan sausage, mushrooms, red bliss potatoes, and asparagus.

What is the Most Expensive Meal on the IL Toscano Ristorante Menu?

The most expensive meal on the IL Toscano Ristorante menu is the Lobster Il Toscano, which costs $85.00. The Lobster Il Toscano features over 2 pounds of fresh shell lobster sautéed in garlic, lemon, white wine, and butter.

What are the Healthiest Meals on the IL Toscano Ristorante Menu?

The healthiest meals on the IL Toscano Ristorante menu are the Grilled Branzino, the Pollo Scarpariello, and the Semolina Crusted Jumbo Shrimp. The Grilled Branzino provides a lean protein option packed with healthy omega-3 fats, served with corn, zucchini, snap peas, tomatoes, and salsa verde. The Pollo Scarpariello features a whole baby chicken with Tuscan sausage, mushrooms, red bliss potatoes, and asparagus, creating a balanced meal when ordered with extra asparagus. The Semolina Crusted Jumbo Shrimp provides lean seafood protein served with a nutrient-dense lemon and watercress risotto, crispy leeks, and sweet garlic vinaigrette.

How Often Does IL Toscano Ristorante Offer Special Offers?

IL Toscano Ristorante offers custom prix fixe menus or menus for specific annual holidays, rather than running frequent discount campaigns or regular weekly specials. The restaurant provides special holiday-themed menus roughly 1 time a year for events such as Thanksgiving Day, New Year's Eve, Mother's Day, Easter Sunday, and Valentine's Day.

Does IL Toscano Ristorante Have a Loyalty Program?

No, IL Toscano Ristorante does not have a loyalty program. The business does not offer an official in-house point tracking system or VIP club promotions. Customers purchase gift cards directly through the restaurant to access convenient dining options or gift meals to friends and family.

Does IL Toscano Ristorante Offer Family Meal Bundles?

No, IL Toscano Ristorante does not offer family meal bundles. The menu focuses on individual portions of pasta, veal, chicken, seafood, and wood-fired pizzas rather than fixed family meal packages. Diners arrange official catering services to order half or full trays of items like Chicken Parmesan, Penne Vodka, and Lasagna Bolognese, requiring a 48-hour advance notice for large family gatherings. The restaurant accommodates groups through private event hosting and pre-arranged banquet packages for groups of 20 or more.

Does IL Toscano Ristorante Offer Vegan Options?

No, the IL Toscano Ristorante menu does not offer vegan options. The restaurant focuses heavily on fresh seafood, meats, and house-made pastas, and traditional pasta and vegetable preparations contain cheese, butter, or stock. Plant-based diners must make specific requests to standard dishes to secure a basic vegan meal.

Does IL Toscano Ristorante Offer Gluten-Free Options?

Yes, IL Toscano Ristorante offers gluten-free options. The kitchen accommodates dietary needs with advance notice, modifying fresh fish, meat, or vegetable dishes. Diners should inform the staff of dietary limitations for safe preparation and to guide guests through choices like grilled fish or meat entrees without cross-contamination.

Is IL Toscano Ristorante Pet-Friendly?

No, IL Toscano Ristorante is not a pet-friendly restaurant. The establishment strictly follows local health codes that do not allow animals inside the dining room. Although the venue features seasonal outdoor dining in heated cedar gazebos, there is no designated pet-friendly policy or infrastructure for dogs.

Can You Order Ala Carte in IL Toscano Ristorante?

Yes, customers order ala carte at IL Toscano Ristorante. The menu features an individually priced format where diners pick out exact dishes item by item. Options include single appetizers like Calamari Fritti for $18.00, starters such as Mozzarella Fresca for $18.00, and main dishes like the Grilled Prime Ribeye Steak for $58.00.

What Other Services Does IL Toscano Ristorante Offer?

Il Toscano Ristorante offers dine-in service, catering, takeout, delivery, and spaces for private events. Guests can reserve the Wine Room, Sky Room, secluded Table X for up to 5 people, or the upstairs Country Style Tuscan Table. Catering orders include half and full trays of Italian dishes and require at least 48 hours’ notice. Online ordering is also available through major delivery platforms. Free parking with attendant is provided in the L.I.R.R. lot across the street.

Does IL Toscano Ristorante Offer Catering Services?

Yes, IL Toscano Ristorante offers catering for events held off-site and on-premises banquets. The catering menu includes half and full trays of Italian dishes like Chicken Parmesan and Lasagna Bolognese, requiring a 48-hour notice and a $75.00 deposit for chafing dishes. Lunch and dinner banquet packages accommodate groups with a minimum of 20 guests. Customers contact the restaurant at (718) 631-0300 to discuss menu options and place large orders.

Can You Rent IL Toscano Ristorante for Private Occasions?

Yes, IL Toscano Ristorante offers space for private events and large gatherings. Guests arrange custom menus based on group preferences and group size, accommodating groups ranging from 10 to 65 people. The venue features private rooms, including the Wine room, Sky room, and the Country Style Tuscan Table upstairs. To book a private event, customers call (718) 631-0300 or email [email protected].

Does IL Toscano Ristorante Do House Delivery?

Yes, IL Toscano Ristorante offers house delivery. Takeout orders are fulfilled via third-party services like Grubhub and Postmates. Customers also place direct orders by calling the restaurant directly at (718) 631-0300 for curbside pickup. Delivery and pickup hours run from 5:00 PM to 8:30 PM.

How are the Reviews for Customer Experience at IL Toscano Ristorante?

Customer reviews of IL Toscano Ristorante mention the attentive family hospitality, classic ambiance, and standout Northern Italian dishes. Diners enjoy the well-prepared ingredients and a great selection of fine wines and cocktails. Popular dishes include the signature Lobster Il Toscano, homemade pastas, and the Napoleon dessert. The service is described as warm and accommodating, with friendly servers and attentive management. The dining room offers a comfortable, quiet, and traditional fine-dining atmosphere, enhanced by conveniences like valet parking.

Who are the Top Competitors of IL Toscano Ristorante?

The top competitors of IL Toscano Ristorante are Il Bacco Ristorante and Picciotto. Check out other alternatives offering Italian cuisine.

  • Il Bacco Ristorante: Il Bacco Ristorante is a prominent Italian restaurant and event space.
  • Picciotto: Picciotto offers wood-fired pizzas and classic dishes in an authentic local setting.
  • Toskana Pizzeria Restaurant: Toskana Pizzeria Restaurant focuses on Italian comfort food and pizzeria favorites.
  • Luigi's Italian Restaurant: Luigi's Italian Restaurant provides a dining experience with traditional pasta dishes.
  • Trattoria 35: Trattoria 35 serves classic Italian comfort food in a cozy neighborhood setting.
Category Restaurants
IL Toscano Ristorante prices

Popular Restaurants