Show Food Recommendations

Carlo's Bakery Menu Prices

Average Prices
PriceListo is not associated with Carlo's Bakery
Edited by: Editorial Staff
Updated on: July 17, 2022
Top Rated Items at Carlo's Bakery
Vanilla Buttercream Cupcake $3.65
You are viewing average Carlo's Bakery prices from 23 locations in our database.
5.00 based on 1 item ratings
Prices shown in: USD
Average Item Price: $19.53
Beta Price change data displayed below is the difference between the previous and the last record in our database. The two records could be derived from different sources, and as such, should only be used as estimates.
Item Price Change

Popular Items

Individual Dark Chocolate Mousse
A thin layer of dark chocolate cake filled with light, chocolate mousse, dipped in ganache, and topped with milk chocolate drizzle, and dark chocolate shavings.
$8.12 +$0.03 +0.37%
Rainbow Slice
Six layers of rainbow colored vanilla cake filled high with a sweet vanilla icing, and covered with rainbow sprinkles.
$8.95 - -
Individual White Chocolate Mousse
A thin layer of vanilla cake topped with light, white chocolate mousse, dipped in ganache, and topped with white chocolate drizzle, and marble chocolate shavings.
$8.12 +$0.03 +0.37%
Red Velvet Slice
Red velvet cake filled and decorated with a sweet cream cheese frosting, covered in cake crumbs.
$8.95 - -

Pastries

Classic Cannoli
Crispy Italian shell filled with sweet ricotta cheese, chocolate chips, a hint of cinnamon, and dusted with powdered sugar.
$5.73 +$0.17 +3.06% 1
Traditional Lobster Tail
Flaky dough baked to a golden brown, filled with our signature French cream, and a hint of Baileys liqueur, topped with powdered sugar.
$6.58 +$0.05 +0.77%
Chocolate Dipped Cannoli
Crispy Italian shell dipped in chocolate and filled with sweet ricotta cheese, chocolate chips, and a hint of cinnamon. Dusted with powdered sugar.
$6.95 - -
Brownie
Classic fudge like brownie topped with chocolate fudge frosting.
$4.95 +$1.45 +41.43%

Cake Slices

Chocolate Fudge Slice
Layers of decadent chocolate cake filled and iced with chocolate fudge frosting and topped with chocolate sprinkles.
$8.95 - -
Carrot Cake Slice $9.35 +$0.33 +3.66%
Chocolate Fudge Cake Slice $9.58 +$0.38 +4.13%
Rainbow Fudge Slice
Six layers of rainbow colored vanilla cake filled and iced with chocolate fudge frosting, covered in rainbow sprinkles.
$8.95 - -
Rainbow Fudge Cake Slice
Six layers of rainbow-colored vanilla cake filled and iced with rich chocolate fudge icing, covered in rainbow sprinkles.
$9.71 - -
Rainbow Strawberry Cake Slice
Six layers of rainbow-colored vanilla cake filled and iced with sweet strawberry buttercream icing and covered in rainbow sprinkles.
$9.73 - -
Rainbow Cake Slice $9.58 +$0.38 +4.13%
Vanilla Confetti Slice
Vanilla cake with a burst of rainbow sprinkles filled, and iced with a sweet vanilla buttercream confetti icing.
$8.95 - -
Vanilla Confetti Cake Slice $9.58 +$0.38 +4.13%
Red Velvet Cake Slice $9.52 +$0.32 +3.48%
Cookies and Cream Slice $9.03 +$0.01 +0.11%
Salted Caramel Slice
Vanilla cake layered and iced with salted caramel buttercream and dulce de leche, covered in marble chocolate shavings.
$8.95 - -

Chocolate Dipped Strawberries

Chocolate Dipped Strawberries
Fresh long-stem strawberries dipped in a mix of decadent white, milk and dark Belgian chocolate. Small Box: Four Pieces.
$19.39 +$3.89 +25.10%

Cakes

6" Black and White Cake
Our classic vanilla and chocolate cake layered with rich chocolate fudge icing, decorated with a sweet buttercream icing.
$44.95 - -
6" Vanilla Confetti Cake
Vanilla cake with a burst of rainbow sprinkles filled and iced with a sweet buttercream confetti icing.
$35.76 +$0.81 +2.32% 1
6" Chocolate Fudge Cake $37.21 +$2.26 +6.47%
6" Cannoli Cake
Classic vanilla cake filled with our traditional ricotta cannoli cream, decorated with whipped cream and sprinkles.
$42.81 - -
6" Carrot Cake
Our classic carrot cake contains chunks of pineapple, chopped walnuts, coconut shavings, and golden raisins. Filled and topped with a sweet cream cheese icing and carrot cake crumbs.
$42.22 - -
6" Cookies and Cream Cake
Decadent chocolate cake filled and iced with a silky cookies and cream mousse. Design may vary.
$40.66 - -
6" Rainbow Fudge Cake $46.38 - -
6" Rainbow Strawberry Cake $44.95 - -
6" Red Velvet Cake
Red velvet cake filled and iced with cream cheese frosting. Decorated with red velvet cake crumbs.
$43.52 - -
6" Rainbow Cake $45.20 +$0.25 +0.56%

Cookies

Peanut Butter Cookie $4.08 +$0.01 +0.25%
Chocolate Chip Cookie
Our signature soft baked chocolate chip cookie.
$4.15 +$0.08 +1.97%
M&M Cookie
Soft baked chocolate chip cookie with chocolate M and Ms.
$4.13 +$0.06 +1.47%
Oatmeal Raisin Cookie
Classic soft baked oatmeal cookie with raisins.
$4.08 +$0.01 +0.25%
12-pack Spring Cookie Bundle
Twelve assorted, handcrafted Spring cookies. Assortment, design, and color may vary.
$62.95 - -
6-pack Spring Cookie Bundle
Six assorted, handcrafted Spring cookies. Assortment, design, and color may vary.
$34.95 - -
Black and White Cookie
Soft, cake-like cookie covered half and half with vanilla and chocolate icing.
$4.66 - -
Vanilla Rainbow Cookie
Soft cake-like cookie covered in vanilla icing and rainbow sprinkles.
$4.66 - -

BUNDLES

5-Pack Cannoli Box
Four classic cannolis and one chocolate dipped cannoli.
$25.87 +$0.42 +1.65%
4-pack Cake Slice
Four of our most popular cake slices including Rainbow, Vanilla Confetti, Chocolate Fudge, and Red Velvet. Flavors subject to change.
$34.22 - -
4-pack Lobster Tail Box
Four traditional Lobster Tails that are hand-pulled flaky dough baked to a golden brown, filled with our signature French cream and a hint of Bailey's liqueur, topped with powdered sugar.
$25.28 - -
6-pack Cake Slice
Six of our most popular cake slices including Rainbow, Rainbow Fudge, Vanilla Confetti, Chocolate Fudge, Red Velvet, and Carrot. Flavors subject to change.
$49.39 - -
6-pack Cookie Box
Six classic soft-baked chocolate chip cookies.
$19.31 - -
6-pack Cupcake Box
Six assorted cupcakes.
$21.08 - -
Buddy's Favorites Box
Two Traditional Lobster Tails and four Classic Cannolis.
$32.28 - -

PIES

Apple Crumb Wedge
A piece of our classic apple pie topped with a cinnmon crumb.
$6.95 - -

Buddy Bundles

5-Pack Cannoli Bundle $24.95 - -
4-Pack Specialty Lobster Tail Bundle
Try them all! One signature French cream lobster tail, one chocolate hazelnut lobster tail, one cookie and cream lobster tail, and one salted caramel lobster tail.
$23.10 - -
Lobster Tail 4-pack Bundle
Choose any four lobster tails.
$23.87 - -
Buddy's Favorite Bundle
Two signature French cream lobster tails and four classic cannolis.
$30.95 - -

Cheesecake

Individual Strawberry Cheesecake
Our classic New York style cheesecake made with cream cheese and a graham cracker crust bottom, topped with fresh glazed strawberries.
$9.16 +$1.21 +15.22%

Cupcakes

Vanilla Buttercream Cupcake
Vanilla cupcake topped with vanilla buttercream icing and confetti sprinkles.
$3.65 +$0.35 +10.61% 5.0
Chocolate Fudge Cupcake
Chocolate cupcake topped with chocolate fudge frosting and confetti sprinkles.
$3.64 +$0.34 +10.30%
Vanilla Fudge Cupcake
Vanilla cupcake topped with chocolate fudge frosting and confetti sprinkles.
$3.65 +$0.35 +10.61%
Disclaimer: PriceListo gathers actual pricing information from sources such as on-site visits, business websites, and phone interviews. The prices reported on this webpage derive from one or more of those sources. Naturally, the prices reported on this website may not be current, and may not apply to all locations of a given business brand. To obtain current pricing, contact the individual business location of interest to you.

About Carlo's Bakery

Made even more famous through the TLC reality television series, Cake Boss, Carlo’s Bakery is akin to heaven for people with a sweet tooth, as well as for those who appreciate edible art through cakes. Currently owned by Buddy Valastro, the Hoboken, New Jersey-based chain of bakeries was established by Carlo Guastaferro in 1910 and bought by Buddy Valastro, Sr. in 1964. Today, it’s still a family-run business known for its wide range of sumptuous cakes, pastries and dessert items.

The Cake Boss cake creations have been featured in various prestigious industry publications including The Knot and Modern Bride, as well as voted as the best cake design by Today’s Show viewers. The chain has created countless novelty themed cakes, wedding cakes, and specialty cakes, both on and off the show. There are several locations across California, Georgia, and Nevada, among other states, as well as kiosks in Sao Paulo, Brazil.

The Carlo's Bakery prices are on the expensive side but when it comes to taste, texture and flavor, the cakes, pastries and desserts are worth every cent – and bite.

Above are the latest Carlo's Bakery menu prices.

Back to Top