Navigation
Show Food Recommendations
These are some of the top rated items our users enjoy. Rate your favorite items on PriceListo to get personalized recommendations.

Eagle Pizza Menu Prices

Verified Prices
PriceListo is not associated with Eagle Pizza
You are viewing Eagle Pizza prices confirmed by PriceListo at the following location:
2 North High Street, New Albany, OH 43054 US
Order Online
Prices shown in: USD
Beta Price change data displayed below is the difference between the previous and the last record in our database. The two records could be derived from different sources, and as such, should only be used as estimates.
Item Price Change

Top Menu Items

Small 11'' Cheese Pizza $6.90 - -
Cheese Pizza (Large 15'' ) $15.40 - -
Small 11'' Pepperoni Pizza
Pepperoni pizza.
$7.80 - -
Pepperoni (Large 15'' ) $13.15 - -

Dinners

Spaghetti Dinner
More than a pound of spaghetti served with salad and buttered roll.
$8.25 - -
Baked Spaghetti $5.00 - -
Garlic Bread $3.50 - -
Chicken Tenders
4 crispy chicken breast strips served with french fries.
$7.00 - -
Shrimp Dinner
21 count basket of shrimp with french fries, slaw and cocktail sauce.
$7.50 - -
Smothered Meatballs
4 meatballs baked with sauce and smothered with cheese.
$4.85 - -

Salads

House Salad
(Pint) tossed salad topped with cheese, pepperoni, olives and hot peppers.
$3.25 - -
Grilled Chicken Salad
Grilled chicken breast, tomatoes, cheddar- Monterrey cheese blend on a bed of lettuce. Served with buttermilk ranch dressing.
$7.25 - -
1/2 Gallon Salad
Tossed salad topped with cheese, pepperoni, olives and hot peppers.
$6.95 - -

Subs And Sandwiches

The Sub
Ham, salami, provolone cheese covered with lettuce, tomatoes, onions and hot peppers.
$5.80 - -
Chicken Sandwich
Chicken sandwich - breast filet of chicken topped with tomato, lettuce and mayo.
$4.00 - -
Turkey Sub
Turkey, lettuce, tomatoes, onions and hot peppers served on our famous sub bun.
$5.80 - -
Fish Sandwich
Fish sandwich - covered with lettuce and tartar sauce on the side.
$4.00 - -
Coney Dog
Coney dog - a quarter pound hot dog covered with coney sauce plus onion.
$2.65 - -
Meat Ball Sub
Meatballs smothered with spaghetti sauce and provolone cheese.
$6.25 - -
Double Sub
Twice the meat and cheese, still covered with lettuce, tomatoes, onions and hot peppers.
$3.75 - -
Cheese Sub
Lots of cheese topped with lettuce, tomatoes, onions and hot peppers.
$5.80 - -
Ham & Cheese Sandwich
Our house favorite served hot from the oven.
$2.10 - -
Pizza Sub
Our villa sub bun smothered with cheese, pepperoni and sauce. Served with open face.
$5.80 - -
Sausage Sub
Fresh ground sausage covered with cheese, pizza sauce, lettuce, onions and hot peppers.
$5.80 - -
Ham Sub
Ham and cheese topped with lettuce, tomatoes, onions and hot peppers.
$5.80 - -
Hot Dog
Hot dog - a quarter pound squeezes in a bun.
$2.25 - -
Chicken Salad Sandwich
Chicken salad sandwich- on Texas toast with lettuce.
$4.00 - -

Signature Pizza

Large 15'' Chicken Bacon BBQ Pizza
Sweet Barbeque base covered with chicken, blended cheese sprinkled with bacon.
$15.75 - -
Pizza Sub (Signature Pizza)
Our villa sub bun smothered with cheese, pepperoni and sauce. Served open face.
$5.80 - -
Small 11'' Cheese Pizza (Signature Pizza) $6.90 - -
Bake at Home Pizza
Bake at home pizza - our traditional large pizza prepared on a specially designed pan ready for the oven. Great for late night snack or visiting out of town friends. Available in large size only.
$12.50 - -
Small 11'' Pepperoni Pizza (Signature Pizza) $7.80 - -
Hawaiian (Large 15'' )
Hawaiian pizza : ham plus pineapple. A summertime favorite!.
$14.00 - -
Large 15'' Taco Pizza
Mexican style sauce covered with blended cheeses and seasoned hamburger cooked till crisp. Then topped with more cheese, fresh shredded lettuce and diced tomatoes. Taco sauce packets and sour cream available also.
$16.50 - -
Small 11'' All the Way Pizza
The house tradition. Pepperoni, hamburger, mushrooms, green peppers, sausage, ham and onions. (anchovies available).
$11.40 - -
Small 11'' Chicken Bacon BBQ Pizza
Sweet Barbecue base covered with chicken, blended cheese sprinkled with bacon.
$9.50 - -
Large 15'' All the Way Pizza $18.90 - -
Large 15'' All Meat Pizza
Ham, pepperoni, sausage, bacon and hamburger.
$18.90 - -
Pepperoni and Mushroom Pizza (Small 11'' ) $8.30 - -
Vegetable (Large 15'' )
Mushrooms, onions, black olives, tomatoes and green peppers.
$18.90 - -
Sausage and Hot-Pepper (Large 15'' )
Sausage and hot pepper pizza.
$14.40 - -
Gluten Free Pizza ( 10" ) $8.50 - -
All Meat (Small 11'' ) $11.00 - -
Pepperoni (Large 15'' ) (Signature Pizza) $13.15 - -
Taco (Small 11'' )
Mexican style sauce covered with blended cheeses and seasoned hamburger cooked till crisp. Then topped with more cheese, fresh shredded lettuceand diced tomatoes. Taco sauce packets and sour cream available also.
$10.90 - -
Pepperoni and Mushroom Pizza (Large 15'' ) $15.90 - -
Vegetable (Small 11'' ) $11.00 - -
Hawaiian (Small 11'' ) $8.20 - -
Sausage and Hot-Pepper (Small 11'' ) $8.70 - -
Cheese Pizza (Large 15'' ) (Signature Pizza) $15.40 - -

Kid'S Menu

Child's Hot Dog Meal
With french fries and fruit cup.
$4.50 - -
Child's-Spaghetti Meal
With roll and fruit cup.
$4.50 - -
Kids Fruit Cups
Mixed fruit.
$0.95 - -
Child's Chicken Tender Meal
Two pieces of chicken, french fries and fruit cup.
$4.50 - -

Side Orders

Garlic Bread (Side Orders) $3.50 - -
French Fries $1.75 - -
Side Sampler
A sampling of mushrooms, cauliflower, hot potatoes and onion rings.
$6.50 - -
French Fried Mushrooms $3.50 - -
Chicken Wings
Chicken wings - 6 or 12 piece chicken wings smothered in our special hot sauce.
$6.00 - -
Cheesy Bacon Fries
French fries smothered in cheddar cheese sauce and generously topped with bacon.
$3.35 - -
Chicken Wings (Side Orders)
Chicken wings - 6 or 12 piece chicken wings smothered in our special barbecue sauce.
$6.00 - -
Steak Cut Onion Rings $3.00 - -
Boneless Chicken Wings
Per pound boneless chicken wings (hot - BB - sriracha bourbon) served ready for your crowd.
$12.00 - -
Cole Slaw
Individually packaged container of fresh cole slaw.
$0.80 - -
French Fried Cauliflower $3.60 - -
Jalapeno Poppers
6 breaded jalapeno peppers filled with cream cheese.
$3.95 - -
Hot Potatoes
8 - hot potatoes with cheddar cheeseand jalapeno.
$3.00 - -

Desserts

Resch's Bakery Cake
Chocolate and white.
$12.00 - -
Cinnamon Dessert Pizza
Special dessert crust, baked with cinnamon spread on top and swirls of vanilla icing.
$4.25 - -
Fruit Cups $0.95 - -
Chocolate Chip Cookies
Our most popular tradition, baked right here at villa pizza.
$0.80 - -
Sugar Cookies
With vanilla frosting.
$0.80 - -

Beverages

Bottled Coca Cola Products $1.60 - -
Fountain Coca Cola Products $1.60 - -
Disclaimer: PriceListo gathers actual pricing information from sources such as on-site visits, business websites, and phone interviews. The prices reported on this webpage derive from one or more of those sources. Naturally, the prices reported on this website may not be current, and may not apply to all locations of a given business brand. To obtain current pricing, contact the individual business location of interest to you.