1. PriceListo
  2. Guarino's Restaurant Menu Prices

Guarino's Restaurant Menu with Prices 2026 (United States)

⭐ 0.00/5 (0) reviews
USD prices currency
$14.81 Average Item Price

Updated on:

You are viewing prices confirmed by PriceListo at the following Guarino's Restaurant location:
12309 Mayfield Rd, Cleveland, OH, 44106, US 1(216) 231-3100
This business is featured in 10 Best Cleveland Restaurants

On the Guarino's Restaurant menu, the most expensive item is Brasciole (Two pieces), which costs $27.00. The cheapest item on the menu is Italian Wedding Soup, which costs $6.00. The average price of all items on the menu is currently $14.81.

View the Guarino's Restaurant menu prices list below for the most accurate and up-to-date menu prices. We aggregate data from one or more Guarino's Restaurant locations in our database to create the most accurate list of Guarino's Restaurant prices. Don't rely on outdated price data. We update our database frequently to ensure that the prices are as accurate as possible.

Guarino's Restaurant is a dining spot in Cleveland, Ohio, famous for vintage speakeasy roots and time-tested Italian-American specialties. Bestsellers on the Guarino's Restaurant menu include the classic Lasagna, the Brasciole, and Chicken Piccata. The lowest priced item on the menu is the Solo Mio Pizza for $11.00, and the most expensive item is the Mama's Portion of the Brasciole for $29.00. The average cost per person dining at Guarino's Restaurant is from $15.00 to $30.00. Weekly promotions feature rotating culinary specials and complimentary live piano entertainment.

Guarino's Restaurant was founded in 1918 by Vincenzo and Mary Guarino. Over the years, the family-owned restaurant gained recognition for serving homemade Italian-American dinners in a cozy back dining room. The business expanded into a local landmark, incorporating a beautiful garden patio with a trumpet vine brought from Sicily and remodeling the dining space in Victorian decor.

This traditional Italian-American restaurant offers dine-in, take-out, and delivery services. Catering packages, private dining room rentals, and on-site valet parking are available for private events. Guarino's Restaurant is not pet-friendly, adhering strictly to local health regulations that prohibit animals inside the dining room. Customers consider Guarino's Restaurant a good option for family gatherings and small celebrations, rating the restaurant 4.4 on Google and 4.0 on Yelp.

Guarino's Restaurant Menu

What is Guarino's Restaurant Most Famous For?

Guarino's Restaurant is most famous for being Cleveland's oldest continuously operating restaurant, serving the community since 1918. The restaurant stands apart by maintaining a rich history in Cleveland's Little Italy, beginning as a poolroom and speakeasy where Mary Guarino prepared dinners in the back dining room. During prohibition, homemade wine and liquor were served in coffee cups while strings of beads hung from the ceiling to shield the bar from police in the streets. Over the decades, the clientele grew to include professors, musicians, politicians, and Metropolitan Opera stars. This dedication to traditional Italian-American recipes and a beautiful outdoor garden patio featuring a trumpet vine brought from Sicily gives the restaurant a distinct advantage over local competitors.


What are the Most Popular Signature Items on the Guarino's Restaurant Menu?

The most popular signature items on the Guarino's Restaurant menu include the classic Lasagna, the Brasciole, and Chicken Piccata. Here is a list of more bestselling menu items from Guarino's Restaurant.

  • Lasagna: A beloved house specialty crafted using a traditional family recipe over fifty years old.
  • Brasciole: A rolled flat steak stuffed with prosciutto, hard-boiled egg, cheese, fresh garlic, and parsley, served with pasta marinara.
  • Chicken Piccata: Tender chicken sautéed in white wine, roasted red peppers, lemon, and capers, served with a side of pasta.
  • Veal Saltimbocca: Lightly breaded, pan-fried veal topped with prosciutto, onions, mushrooms, and cheese, sautéed in white wine and served with pasta.
  • Eggplant Parmigiana: Seasoned, lightly breaded, and pan-fried eggplant topped with cheese and marinara, served with pasta marinara.
  • Manicotti: Rolled pasta stuffed with seasoned ricotta cheese and served in marinara sauce.

What Drinks and Beverages Can You Have at Guarino's Restaurant?

The drinks and beverages customers can have at Guarino's Restaurant are the Joe-Lato cocktail, the Capone cocktail, and the Negroni. The Joe-Lato cocktail pairs well with the Solo Mio Pizza, while the Capone cocktail complements the rich flavors of the Brasciole. The Negroni offers a classic, herbal option that matches the savory taste of the Lasagna. Here is a list of more drinks available from Guarino's Restaurant.

  • Manhattan: A classic cocktail prepared with Maker’s Mark Bourbon, sweet vermouth, bitters, and a cherry.
  • White Chocolate Truffle: A sweet dessert cocktail designed to accompany after-dinner treats.
  • Peroni: A classic imported Italian lager served ice cold.
  • Espresso: A bold, concentrated Italian coffee served hot.

What is the Cheapest Meal on the Guarino's Restaurant Menu?

The cheapest meal on the Guarino's Restaurant menu is the Solo Mio Pizza, which costs $11.00. The Solo Mio Pizza features a single-serving single-topping pizza with a choice of pepperoni, sausage, or tomato.

What is the Most Expensive Meal on the Guarino's Restaurant Menu?

The most expensive meal on the Guarino's Restaurant menu is the Mama's Portion of the Brasciole, which costs $29.00. The Mama's Portion of the Brasciole features a larger serving of rolled flat steak stuffed with prosciutto, hard-boiled egg, cheese, fresh garlic, and parsley.

What are the Healthiest Meals on the Guarino's Restaurant Menu?

The healthiest meals on the Guarino's Restaurant menu are the Scrod Al Forno, the Chicken Piccata, and the Artichoke & Eggplant Salad. The Scrod Al Forno features a New England cod fillet broiled with Italian seasonings and served with a sautéed garlic and olive oil vegetable medley. The Chicken Piccata offers a lean protein option sautéed in white wine, roasted red peppers, lemon, and capers. The Artichoke & Eggplant Salad combines spring greens, pan-sautéed eggplant slices, tomatoes, capers, and artichokes tossed in olive oil and balsamic.

How Often Does Guarino's Restaurant Offer Special Offers?

Guarino's Restaurant offers weekly culinary specials, seasonal event menus, and complimentary live piano entertainment. Value is added through high-quality dining and weekend entertainment rather than short-term price discounts. The restaurant also coordinates special features during major neighborhood events like the Feast of the Assumption.

Does Guarino's Restaurant Have a Loyalty Program?

No, Guarino's Restaurant does not have a loyalty program. Customers purchase gift cards directly through the restaurant or contact management directly to inquire about group rates and seasonal promotions.

Does Guarino's Restaurant Offer Family Meal Bundles?

No, Guarino's Restaurant does not offer family meal bundles. Sharing is accommodated through larger platters like the "Mama's Portion" of the Antipasto or by ordering multiple classic entrees to pass around the table. The menu remains structured around single-serving dining portions, allowing families to customize dinner choices.

Does Guarino's Restaurant Offer Vegan Options?

Yes, Guarino's Restaurant offers vegan options like Pasta Primavera, Angel Hair Marinara, and the Artichoke & Eggplant Salad ordered without cheese. Pasta Primavera features spaghetti pasta sautéed with assorted chopped vegetables served in marinara or with garlic and olive oil. Angel Hair Marinara offers a simple, plant-based pasta dish. The Artichoke & Eggplant Salad combines spring greens, pan-sautéed eggplant slices, tomatoes, capers, and artichokes tossed in olive oil and balsamic.

Does Guarino's Restaurant Offer Gluten-Free Options?

Yes, the gluten-free options on the Guarino's Restaurant menu include gluten-free penne pasta, the Brasciole, and the Caprese Salad. Gluten-free penne pasta is available as a substitute for most traditional pasta dishes on the menu. The Brasciole features rolled flat steak stuffed with prosciutto, hard-boiled egg, cheese, garlic, and parsley, naturally avoiding gluten. The Caprese Salad offers a naturally gluten-free starter with sliced tomatoes, fresh mozzarella, basil purée, and balsamic vinegar.

Is Guarino's Restaurant Pet-Friendly?

No, Guarino's Restaurant is not pet-friendly. The restaurant location on Mayfield Road in Cleveland, Ohio, strictly follows local health codes that prohibit animals inside the dining room. Everyday pets and emotional support animals are not permitted on the premises. Only certified service dogs are allowed on the outdoor patio.

Can You Order Ala Carte in Guarino's Restaurant?

Yes, customers can order ala carte at Guarino's Restaurant such as single-serving pasta dishes, appetizers, and side salads. Prices for ala carte items range from $6.00 for garlic and cheese bread to $24.00 for the Frutti Di Mare.

What Other Services Does Guarino's Restaurant Offer?

Guarino's Restaurant offers private dining in the upstairs Victorian Parlors, outdoor garden seating with a weatherproof tent system, live weekend music, and valet parking services. The upstairs Victorian Parlors are decorated with antiques, china, and glassware, providing a private space for meetings, showers, and weddings. The outdoor garden patio seats over one hundred people comfortably under lush trumpet vines and has been named to numerous city patio lists. The restaurant provides regular dine-in and takeout services at the location on Mayfield Road in Cleveland's Little Italy, complete with free on-site parking.

Does Guarino's Restaurant Offer Catering Services?

Yes, Guarino's Restaurant offers catering services such as customized Italian-American buffet packages, large-party pasta trays, and shareable appetizers. The restaurant provides catering options for groups ranging from twenty to one hundred guests, accommodating weddings, bridal showers, graduation parties, and holiday gatherings. Office get-togethers and family reunions benefit from reasonably priced menu choices designed to make events comfortable and entertaining.

Can You Rent Guarino's Restaurant for Private Occasions?

Yes, Guarino's Restaurant offers venue rentals for private occasions. The restaurant features private indoor rooms and an outdoor garden patio that combine to host events for twenty to one hundred guests. Groups of twenty to thirty-five people require a personalized menu featuring three to six entree choices. Bar options for private events are extremely flexible, offering fully hosted bars, cash bars, or limited host packages featuring beer and wine.

Does Guarino's Restaurant Do House Delivery?

Yes, Guarino's Restaurant provides house delivery through major third-party platforms like DoorDash. Customers also have the option to order directly online through ToastTab for quick pickup.

How are the Reviews for Customer Experience at Guarino's Restaurant?

Customer reviews for Guarino's Restaurant frequently praise the old-school Little Italy charm, traditional lasagna, and free valet service. Online reviews regularly celebrate the cozy, home-like atmosphere of the main dining room, the weekend live piano music, and the beautiful outdoor patio. Reviewers also appreciate the vintage speakeasy legacy of the Cleveland landmark. 

The food quality receives praise for time-tested Italian-American recipes, particularly the lasagna made with a fifty-year-old family recipe and the authentic braciole. Service is described as friendly and accommodating, though some reviewers note occasional delays during peak weekend hours. A major advantage noted in community feedback is the free on-site parking lot and valet service, which helps diners bypass difficult neighborhood street parking.

Who are the Top Competitors of Guarino's Restaurant?

The top competitors of Guarino's Restaurant are Trattoria Roman Garden and La Dolce Vita. Here is a list of more competitors of Guarino's Restaurant.

  • Trattoria Roman Garden: Located on Mayfield Road, Trattoria Roman Garden is famous for large portions, homemade meat sauce, and a spacious patio.
  • La Dolce Vita: La Dolce Vita competes directly for the Little Italy dining crowd with an intimate, old-world atmosphere and Opera Nights.
  • Angelos Nido Italia: Angelos Nido Italia offers an upscale, old-school standby dining experience with a romantic, elegant setting.
  • Carrabba's Italian Grill: Carrabba's Italian Grill offers wood-fired pizzas and classic pasta dishes across hundreds of locations.
Category Restaurants
Guarino's Restaurant prices

Popular Restaurants