Show Food Recommendations

J&J's Pizza Shack Menu Prices

Verified Prices
PriceListo is not associated with J&J's Pizza Shack
You are viewing J&J's Pizza Shack prices confirmed by PriceListo at the following location:
1454 West Lincolnway, Valparaiso, IN 46385 US 1(219) 476-1616
Order Online
Prices shown in: USD
Beta Price change data displayed below is the difference between the previous and the last record in our database. The two records could be derived from different sources, and as such, should only be used as estimates.
Item Price Change

Appetizers & Sides

Jalapeño Poppers (6)
Cheddar or cream cheese filled.
$4.75 - -
French Fries $1.50 - -
Onion Rings $2.50 - -
Mozzarella Cheese Sticks (6) $3.95 - -
Cheddar Cheese Cubes $3.95 - -
Breaded Mushrooms $3.95 - -
Breaded Cauliflower $3.95 - -
Broccoli Bites with Bacon (6)
Served with dipping sauce upon request.
$4.75 - -
Combo Plate
Breaded mushrooms, broccoli bites, breaded cauliflower, onion rings and mozzarella sticks.
$7.95 - -
Garlic Bread $1.50 - -
Garlic Bread with Cheese $3.25 - -
Tomato Bread $4.75 - -
Bread Sticks (6)
Buttered then sprinkled with garlic salt and Parmesan, served with a cup of pizza sauce.
$3.16 +$0.21 +7.12%
Bread Sticks with Cheese (6)
Our original bread sticks smothered in mozzarella cheese, served with a cup of pizza sauce.
$3.95 - -
Deep Fried Pickle Spears (6) $3.95 - -

Items Worth Indulging On

Customers can’t get enough of these dishes, we think you’ll love them too
The Kitchen Sink
Ground sausage, pepperoni, mushrooms, green pepper, onion, green olives, black olives, 100% real crumbled bacon, Canadian bacon and ham.
$12.95 - -
Cheese Pizza (Extra Large 16″) $17.65 - -
Cheese & Topping (Medium 12″)
Our original crust – not too thick, not too thin.
$10.95 - -
Cheese & Topping (Large 14″) $13.95 - -
Cheese & Topping (Extra Large 16″) $17.95 - -
Shack Pack (24) $17.00 - -

From the Garden

All salads are made fresh to order. Choose from: ranch, bleu cheese, French, Thousand island, honey mustard, Italian and fat-free Italian.
Mini Chef Salad (No Meat)
Lettuce, tomato, mushrooms, green peppers, onion, green olives, black olives and mozzarella.
$4.75 - -
Mini Chef Salad with Meat
Bacon bits, ham and Canadian bacon.
$6.75 - -
Tossed Salad
Lettuce and tomato.
$1.50 - -
Chef Salad (No Meat) $6.75 - -
Chef Salad with Meat $8.75 - -

Sandwiches

Burger toppings: ketchup, mustard, mayo, pickle, onion, lettuce, or tomato.
Fish Sandwich $3.95 - -
Hamburger $2.95 - -
Double Hamburger $3.95 - -
Cheeseburger $3.50 - -
Double Cheeseburger $4.50 - -
Corndog $1.50 - -
Breaded Chicken Sandwich
With mayonnaise, lettuce and tomato.
$3.95 - -
Grilled Chicken Sandwich $3.95 - -

Oven-Hot Sandwiches

Served on toasted French bread.
Stromboli
Pizza sausage, onion, green peppers, cheese and red sauce.
$5.95 - -
Texas Bar-B-Que
Pizza sausage, onion, green peppers, cheese and our own special bar-b-que sauce.
$5.95 - -
Sausage & Pepperoni
Pizza sausage, pepperoni, onion, green peppers, cheese and our own red sauce.
$5.95 - -
Ham & Cheese
Thinly sliced ham topped with mozzarella cheese.
$5.95 - -
Beef & Sausage Sandwich
An Italian sausage patty, green peppers, onion, and cheese topped with delicious sliced beef and red sauce.
$6.95 - -
Italian Beef
Delicious sliced beef served in its own juice cheese available upon request.
$5.95 - -
Beef Boat
Hot sliced beef, cheese, onion, green peppers and red sauce.
$5.95 - -
Beef Bar-B-Que
Delicious sliced beef, onion, green peppers, cheese and our own special beef bar-b-que sauce.
$5.95 - -
Italian Sausage
An Italian sausage patty with green peppers, onion, cheese and red sauce.
$5.95 - -
Meatball
Meatballs, cheese, onion, green peppers and red sauce.
$5.95 - -
Crispy French Bread Pizza
With your choice of three pizza toppings.
$5.95 - -

Pasta

Served with garlic bread and a tossed salad.
Spaghetti Dinner $7.95 - -
Lasagna Dinner $7.95 - -
Mostaccioli $7.95 - -

Create Your Own Pizza

1/2 items charged full price. Thin crust.
Cheese Pizza (Small 10″) $8.45 +$2.20 +35.20%
Cheese Pizza (Medium 12″) $11.93 +$2.68 +28.97%
Cheese Pizza (Large 14″)
Served with drink.
$14.34 +$2.59 +22.04%
Cheese Pizza (Extra Large 16″) (Create Your Own Pizza) $17.65 - -
Cheese & Topping (Small 10″) $6.95 -$1.00 -12.58%
Cheese & Topping (Medium 12″) (Create Your Own Pizza) $10.95 - -
Cheese & Topping (Large 14″) (Create Your Own Pizza) $13.95 - -
Cheese & Topping (Extra Large 16″) (Create Your Own Pizza) $17.95 - -
Stuffed Crust Cheese Pizza $20.44 - -

Specialty Pizzas

No additions, subtractions or substitutions.
The Kitchen Sink (Specialty Pizzas) $12.95 - -
Supreme – Our Special!
Ground sausage, pepperoni, mushrooms, green peppers, onion and cheese.
$9.55 - -
Taco Pizza
Ground sausage, taco seasoning, mozzarella cheese, cheddar cheese, lettuce and tomato.
$10.05 +$0.50 +5.24%
Vegetable Pizza
Mushrooms, green peppers, black olives, green olives, onion and tomatoes.
$9.55 - -
The Meat Pie
Ground sausage, pepperoni, ham, 100% real crumbled bacon, Canadian bacon and sliced beef.
$12.95 - -

Wings

Buffalo Wings (12) $8.75 - -
Shack Pack (24) (Wings) $17.00 - -
Bucket of Wings (48) $33.50 - -
Wing Dinner
With French fries and a dinner roll.
$9.95 - -

Dinners

Served with French fries and a dinner roll.
Chicken Dinner (4 Pieces) $7.95 - -
Shrimp Basket $7.95 - -
Jumbo Shrimp Dinner (6 Pieces) $8.95 - -
Chicken Strip Dinner (2 Pieces)
Served with BBQ sauce or honey mustard.
$5.95 - -
Fish Dinner (2 Pieces) $8.75 - -
Fish, Chicken & Shrimp Dinner
One fish, one chicken strip and two jumbo shrimp.
$9.95 - -

Extras

Cheese $0.75 - -
Meat $0.75 - -
Vegetables $0.75 - -
Jalapeño Peppers $0.50 - -
Packet of Parmesan Cheese $0.50 - -
Packet of Red Peppers $0.50 - -
Packet of Dressing $0.50 - -
Cup of Red Sauce $0.50 - -
Cup of Au Jus $0.50 - -
Cup of Hot Sauce $0.50 - -
Cup of Cheddar Cheese $1.00 - -
Cup of Garlic Butter $0.50 - -
Honey Mustard $0.50 - -
BBQ Sauce $0.50 - -

Desserts

Eli’s® Cheesecake (Slice)
Our cheese cake is available in plain or chocolate chip.
$2.95 - -
Lemon Cake Roll (Slice) $2.95 - -
Red Velvet Cake Roll (Slice) $2.95 - -
Tiramisu (Slice) $2.95 - -
Disclaimer: PriceListo gathers actual pricing information from sources such as on-site visits, business websites, and phone interviews. The prices reported on this webpage derive from one or more of those sources. Naturally, the prices reported on this website may not be current, and may not apply to all locations of a given business brand. To obtain current pricing, contact the individual business location of interest to you.
Back to Top