1. PriceListo
  2. Potbelly Menu with Prices 2026

Potbelly Menu with Prices 2026

⭐ 3.67/5 (3) reviews
USD prices currency
$8.98 Average Item Price
You are viewing prices confirmed by PriceListo at the following Potbelly location:
571 E. Lincoln Hwy, New Lenox, IL, 60451, US 1(815) 320-7388

On the Potbelly menu, the most expensive item is Prime Rib Steak (BIG), which costs $19.39. The cheapest item on the menu is Potbelly Whole Pickle, which costs $1.69. The average price of all items on the menu is currently $8.98.

View the Potbelly menu prices list below for the most accurate and up-to-date menu prices. We aggregate data from 722 Potbelly locations in our database to create the most accurate list of Potbelly prices. Don't rely on outdated price data. We update our database frequently to ensure that the prices are as accurate as possible.

Potbelly restaurant is a popular sandwich shop known for toasted sandwiches, fresh salads, and hearty soups. The popular items at Potbelly are A Wreck Sandwich, Italian Sandwich, Mediterranean Sandwich, Avo Turkey, and Chicken Salad​. The cheapest sandwich on the Potbelly menu is Grilled Cheese sandwich, which costs $7.79. The most expensive sandwich on the Potbelly menu is Avo Turkey, which costs $9.39 as of January 14, 2025. The Potbelly menu features sandwiches for as low as $7.79, salads starting at $9.19, pick-your-pair (combo) from $9.19, sides for as low as $2.89, and drinks for $3.09 or more.

Potbelly Sandwich Shop was founded in 1977 in Chicago, Illinois, when Peter Hastings and his wife began serving sandwiches to customers at the couple’s antique shop in the Lincoln Park neighborhood. The shop quickly gained popularity for the unique toasty sandwiches and welcoming atmosphere. Potbelly's regular, Bryant Keil, purchased the business from Hastings, marking the beginning of Potbelly's transformation into a beloved sandwich brand. Potbelly has grown into a well-known national brand over the years, with 425 USA restaurants, including 75 franchised locations.  Potbelly also has international branches in Toronto, the United Kingdom, United Arab Emirates, Kuwait, and Bahrain. Potbelly has won several awards throughout the years, including the Community Choice Awards which it received for eight consecutive years.

Potbelly Menu Prices

Locate Your Nearest Potbelly

View Potbelly local menu, prices, and items from over 722 number of locations

Potbelly Menu

Fresh picks related to Potbelly

These are the key ingredients commonly used by Potbelly: Chicken, Chips, Cheese

Chicken calories Chicken calories Chicken is one of the ingredients used in chicken club dishes at Potbelly
Chicken nutrition
Chips calories Chips calories Chips is one of the ingredients used in zapp's salt and vinegar chips dishes at Potbelly
Chips nutrition
Cheese calories Cheese calories Cheese is one of the ingredients used in mac and cheese dishes at Potbelly
Cheese nutrition

What is Potbelly Most Famous For?

Potbelly is most famous for toasted sandwiches, hand-sliced ingredients, and a unique atmosphere. Originating as a Chicago-based antique shop, Potbelly has grown into a beloved national chain that offers sandwiches featuring freshly toasted bread, hand-sliced meats, and carefully crafted toppings. The sandwich chain is also famous for its in-store-made chicken salad using the founder’s original five-ingredient recipe. Every Potbelly store is uniquely designed, with locally sourced artifacts and artwork that reflect the surrounding neighborhood. Potbelly fosters an engaging environment and previously commissioned live music performances at the restaurants. 



What are the Most Popular Signature Items on the Potbelly Menu?

The most popular signature items on the Potbelly menu are listed below:

  • A Wreck: Features ham, roast beef, turkey breast, salami, and Swiss cheese on fresh white bread.
  • Italian: Highlights salami, capicola, pepperoni, mozzarella, banana peppers, and lettuce with zesty Italian dressing on a toasted sub roll.
  • Mediterranean: Consists of marinated grilled chicken, hummus, cucumber slices, tomato, Romaine lettuce, roasted red peppers, feta, and Kalamata olives on toasted pita or flatbread.
  • Avo Turkey: Comes with turkey breast, Swiss cheese, avocado, and cucumber slices on multigrain bread.
  • Chicken Salad: Showcases diced chicken, celery, shredded carrots, cucumbers, cherry tomatoes, red onion, and creamy dressing on a bed of mixed greens.
  • Chicken Club Sandwich: Highlights grilled chicken breast, bacon, lettuce, tomato, avocado, and mayo on toasted whole-grain bread.
  • Roast Beef Sandwich: Features slow-cooked roast beef with fresh vegetables and your choice of toppings on a toasted sandwich roll.
  • BLTA Sandwich: Includes crispy bacon, avocado, tomato, lettuce, and mayo-mustard sauce on toasted sourdough bread.
  • Mama’s Meatball: Comes with meatballs in marinara sauce, topped with mozzarella, Parmesan, and fresh basil on a toasted hoagie roll.
  • Grilled Chicken Sandwich: Showcases grilled chicken breast, lettuce, tomato, pickles, and mayo or aioli on a toasted bun or whole-grain bread.


What Drinks and Beverages Can You Have at Potbelly?

The drinks and beverages customers can order at Potbelly include Craft refreshers, shakes, soft drinks, tea, lemonade, and bottled water.  The complete list of drinks and beverages available on the Potbelly menu is provided below:

  • Lemonade Craft Refresher
  • Strawberry Dragonfruit Refresher
  • Strawberry Shake
  • Toasted Marshmallow Shake
  • American Apple Pie Shake
  • Chocolate Shake
  • Vanilla Shake
  • Cold Brew Shake
  • OREO Cookie Shake
  • IBC Root Beer
  • IBC Cream Soda
  • Coke
  • Diet Coke
  • Sprite
  • Cherry Coke
  • Coke Zero Sugar
  • Crush
  • Powerade Mountain Berry Blast
  • San Pellegrino Blood Orange
  • Peach Tea Snapple
  • Gold Peak Green Tea
  • Gold Peak Sweet Tea
  • Bottled Water
  • Smartwater
  • San Pellegrino
  • Nantucket Nectars Orange Mango
  • Vitamin Water Squeezed Lemonade
  • Vitamin Water XXX Acai Blue Pom


What is the Cheapest Sandwich on the Potbelly Menu?

The cheapest sandwich on the Potbelly menu is Grilled Cheese sandwich, which costs $7.79 on January 14, 2025. The Grilled Cheese Sandwich includes toasted bread filled with layers of cheese. 


What is the Most Expensive Sandwich on the Potbelly Menu?

The most expensive sandwich on the Potbelly menu is Avo Turkey, which costs $9.39 as of January 14, 2025. The Avo Turkey consists of lean turkey breast, creamy Swiss cheese, avocado, cucumber slices, and multigrain bread.


What are the Healthiest Sandwiches on the Potbelly Menu?

The healthiest sandwiches on the Potbelly menu are Mediterranean Sandwich and Powerhouse Salad. The Mediterranean contains 440 calories, 10 g of fat, 1,050 mg of sodium, 55 g of carbs, and 35 g of protein. Powerhouse Salad contains 560 calories, 15 g of fat, 3 g of saturated fat, 75 g of carbohydrates, 30 g of protein, and 1,590 mg of sodium.


How Good are the Sandwiches on the Potbelly Menu?

Sandwiches on the Potbelly menu are known for hand-sliced meats and cheeses, freshly toasted bread, and well-balanced toppings. The toasting process enhances the texture of the Potbelly sandwich, creating a crispy crust. The fresh ingredients, like the signature five-ingredient chicken salad created by Potbelly’s founder, boosts the taste of the Potbelly sandwiches, while unique flavor combinations, such as the rich Potbelly sandwich Roast Beef or creamy Avocado Turkey, make each sandwich satisfying and filling. 


How Big are the Sandwiches on the Potbelly Menu?

Potbelly sandwich sizes are Original, Big, and Skinny. The Original measures 6 inches, the Potbelly Big size measures 9 inches (with 30% more bread, meat, cheese, and toppings than the Original), while the Skinny uses thinner bread and fewer toppings to reduce calories by 30% compared to the Original.


Can You Customize a Sandwich at Potbelly?

Yes, customers can customize a sandwich at Potbelly including bread type, toppings, and extras. For bread, customers can choose from multigrain, white, or flatbread. For toppings the options include lettuce, tomato, onions, pickles, and hot peppers. Extras include extra meat, cheese, or premium add-ons like avocado or bacon. The sauces and dressings, such as mustard, or mayonnaise, can also be adjusted to taste. 


Are the Soup Items on the Potbelly Menu Worth Trying?

Yes, the soups on the Potbelly menu are worth trying and the top options include Broccoli Cheddar Soup, Baked Potato Soup, Chicken Pot Pie Soup, Chicken Enchilada Soup, and Lentil, Kale & Turkey Sausage Soup. The Potbelly soups are flavorful and hearty, making them an excellent complement to Potbelly's sandwiches. Potbelly’s Chili is also a good option as it has a rich taste and high protein content. Customers can choose from three portion sizes: regular bowl, a smaller cup, or a skinny pair side. 


How Often Does Potbelly Offer Special Offers?

Potbelly introduces special offers regularly, such as Weekly Wednesday, Sweetheart Combo, Spring Fling, and Summer Sizzle. Weekly Wednesday features a Sandwich & Soup Combo where customers can get a sandwich and a cup of soup for just $9.19. The Sweetheart Combo runs from February 12th to 14th and customers can treat a loved one to 2 sandwiches and 2 drinks for $18.99, with an option to add a sugar cookie for only $1. The Spring Fling promotion from March 21st to 31st offers 20% off any Veggie Melt or Mediterranean sandwich, and pairing with a Powerhouse Salad for just $4.99. With the Summer Sizzle in June, BBQ fans can enjoy a Steakhouse Beef sandwich for $8.39, with the option to add Zapp’s Mesquite Bar-B-Que Chips for just $2.89. 


Does Potbelly Have a Loyalty Program?

Yes, Potbelly has a loyalty program called Potbelly Perks, which allows customers to earn and redeem rewards. Members earn 10 coins for every $1 spent, with higher membership levels such as Rookie, Pro, and Boss, offering increased earning potential. Redemption begins at 200 coins, which can be used for menu items like sides, cookies, shakes, fountain drinks, and entrées. Members also enjoy special benefits, including 2x coin days and a free cookie or Dream Bar on birthdays. 


Does Potbelly Offer Family Meal Bundles?

No, Potbelly does not offer family meal bundles. Potbelly previously offered family meal bundles in 2020, which indicates a possibility of return in the future.


Does Potbelly Offer Vegan Options?

Yes, Potbelly offers vegan options such as PB&J Sandwich, Mediterranean Sandwich, Veggie Sandwich, Apple Walnut Salad, and Powerhouse Salad. 


Does Potbelly Offer Gluten-Free Options?

Yes, Potbelly offers gluten-free options, such as Apple Walnut Salad, Chicken Salad, Clubhouse Salad, Farmhouse Salad, Italian Salad, Powerhouse Salad, and Gonzo Bonzo Salad. Gluten Free sandwiches include Skinny Sandwich and Cup of Soup, and Skinny Sandwich and Half Salad. Skinny Sandwiches can be made gluten-free by opting for gluten-free bread.


Is Potbelly Pet-Friendly?

Yes, Potbelly is pet-friendly and pets are welcome at the dog-friendly outdoor areas.


Can You Order Ala Carte in Potbelly?

Yes, customers can order ala carte at Potbelly Sandwich Shop with options like Turkey Breast, Smoke Ham, Roast Beef, Zapp's Salt & Vinegar Chips, Oatmeal Chocolate Chip Cookie, American Apple Pie Shake, and Cold Brew Shake. 


What Other Services Does Potbelly offer?

Potbelly offers both catering and delivery. Catering services from Potbelly is an excellent option for parties, events, and meetings. The Potbelly delivery is available through the website, app, as well as third party delivery platforms. 


Does Potbelly Offer Catering Services?

Yes, Potbelly offers catering services with different options to choose from including boxed lunches for $13.19, sandwiches starting at $16.99, salads from $7.79, soups for $52.39 (for party size), sides starting at $4.79, chips from $2.79, desserts for as low as $2.99, and beverages starting at $2.99. 


Can You Rent Potbelly for Private Occasions?

No, customers cannot rent Potbelly for private occasions. For guests arriving with a group, it is recommended that they come early especially during peak hours and weekends to reserve tables and ensure everyone can be seated and accommodated.


Does Potbelly Do House Delivery?

Yes, Potbelly offers delivery to homes and offices. Delivery orders can be made through the official Potbelly website or app, and third party delivery platforms such as DoorDash, Grubhub, and UberEats.


How are the Reviews for Customer Experience at Potbelly?

Customer reviews for Potbelly praise the restaurant for good food, flavorful sandwiches, and an overall enjoyable dining experience. Customers often commend the friendly service, noting that staff are courteous, approachable, and attentive to individual preferences. The welcoming atmosphere, with cozy interiors and unique store designs, creates a pleasant environment inside the sandwich shop. Some reviews mentioned challenges with customer service, such as difficulties during phone interactions and occasional dissatisfaction with service quality. Majority of the reviews agree that Potbelly offers good food and a positive dining experience at reasonable prices.


Who are the Top Competitors of Potbelly?

The top competitors of Potbelly are listed below:

  • Subway: Subway is a global fast-food chain known for customizable submarine sandwiches. Subway has over 37,000 locations worldwide.
  • Jimmy John's: Jimmy John's is a sandwich chain famous for its freaky fast delivery and fresh ingredients. Jimmy John's also offers Unwich options, which replace bread with lettuce wraps, catering to low-carb diets.
  • Firehouse Subs: Firehouse Subs is a fast-casual chain specializing in hot subs. Firehouse Subs is known for hearty sandwiches and generous portions, compared to Potbelly's more balanced portion sizes.
  • Jersey Mike's Subs: Jersey Mike's Subs is a sandwich chain known for fresh-sliced, made-to-order subs. 
  • Panera Bread: Panera Bread is a bakery-café chain that offers soups, salads, and sandwiches on the menu. 
  • Quiznos: Quiznos is a fast-food restaurant chain famous for toasted submarine sandwiches. Quiznos has an innovative flavor focus with options like the Baja Chicken Sub, which adds a spicy twist not commonly found on Potbelly's classic menu.
  • Jason's Deli: Jason's Deli is a fast-casual restaurant chain known for its diverse deli menu. Jason's Deli features salad bars, catering to health-conscious customers, offering more variety than Potbelly's salad options.
Category Restaurants
Potbelly prices

Popular Restaurants